3 ms·
> One of the most toxic things that happens in politics is re-framing a problem away from rational competence towards emotive and narrative non-logic. In polit
by crispyambulance 5y ago
> One of the most toxic things that happens in politics is re-framing a problem away from rational competence towards emotive and narrative non-logic.
In politics emotional and even irrational narratives are a centerpiece of how effective leaders lead.
In virtually all sufficiently complicated human affairs there is NEVER enough facts and visibility at hand to make objective decisions. Moreover, now more than ever, influencers and thought leaders can easily cherry-pick whatever facts rhyme with their narrative and sound completely rational and "facts-based" to those who lack (or have been conditioned to lack) critical thinking skills and experience.
All effective leaders, regardless of whether they're good or evil, democratic or autocratic make decisions and motivate people by appealing to emotion, history, cultural background. "Logic and rationality" of course is necessary for success but it's only one component. The finest leaders are fully in touch with their subjectivity _and_ can also draw from deep knowledge and rational thought.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoWhich is kind of why democracy got popular - it got rid of leaders, it confined appeals to emotion to the election circus, and replaced energetic leadership with boredom of mind-numbing parliamentary meetings - and in the process removed one of the biggest threat to ongoing peace and prosperity, namely leaders "appealing to emotion, history, cultural background" to get their subjects to do something stupid. I mean, what you say is true - effective political leaders were/are like you describe. But I question whether we need that kind of leadership, and I'm convinced we should not glorify it. Being effective at manipulating and abusing people at scale is not a trait of a good person.
- philwelch 5y agoDemocracy provides an inherent advantage to an "energetic leader" who can manipulate people at scale, because that's how you win elections.