Yeah, sorry about that. I'm generally against obfuscation, but in this case, the "why" of the resulting differences in calculations is well known to most progra

Yeah, sorry about that. I'm generally against obfuscation, but in this case, the "why" of the resulting differences in calculations is well known to most programmers; the big issue is not "why we get different results", but rather "are we ok this type of inconsistent behavior". If you simply showed that modulo and implicit casting work differently in different languages, we wouldn't have had any discussion. With the obfuscation, we got some discussion about the main point... and the discussion about the obfuscation. Honestly, none of us managed to capture all the perspectives well enough. Yeah, the "Ask HN" could have used a less obfuscated expression and been better worded to clarify that the specific semantic differences weren't the main point here. Similarly, most commenters (myself included in my previous comment) failed to realize/clarify that there were two discussions going on here, but that one of them is settled with a technical footnote.