4 ms·
To be a good computer scientist, math is critical. If the writer meant programmer, then it's more debatable. Some of the best programmers I've known have been p
by Jtsummers 5y ago
To be a good computer scientist, math is critical. If the writer meant programmer, then it's more debatable. Some of the best programmers I've known have been perfectly mediocre and even bad at math. However, that also cut off large categories of programs from them. Or, they could do it but it was more as a plumber or applying ideas rather blindly, or getting someone to explain it in enough detail that they could code it (guided, but still no real understanding).
But computer science isn't (just) programming. Many areas of discrete mathematics are highly applicable to the field of CS. Particularly number theory, graph theory, probability, combinatorics, logic, and set theory. And those are just the discrete math topics I've used in my own career (which isn't that long, approaching 15 professional years).
Algebra, calculus, linear algebra, and trigonometry have also been part of my work, though that's been more as a programmer than as a computer scientist (translating mathematical formulas and such into code).
- abetusk 5y agoI was once asked casually by someone I had just met what are good resources for computer science. I started listing MIT OCW and was about to recommend a bunch of math textbooks that I thought were relevant before I realized he was asking how to create a phone app. I would argue that there are large tracts of computer science that are indistinguishable from mathematics and so learning math is critical. I would argue in the affirmative for learning math for computer programming even though I agree that the utility is debatable. Software architecture is more akin to engineering or even construction...math might underpin those areas and may even be needed but often many people in those fields get by without deep math knowledge. Increasingly it's becoming more of a good idea to have some math knowledge with GPUs, neural networks, machine learning, etc. but as with many deeper mathematical concepts, they'll no doubt get "black boxed" into something more digestible for people who don't want or need a deeper understanding of the inner workings.
- dgb23 5y agoSomeone who is building a phone app benefits very likely from modeling their data with relational algebra. Good fundamentals in that category will help the longevity and quality of an application more than anything else.
- iamstupidsimple 5y agoGreat point. The advantage to learning CS concepts via maths is that it teaches you to think in a completely different, more abstract way. And because it's just 'maths', the skills you learn are widely transferable. My favourite example of this is graph theory, which you can find deep applications of just about anywhere in programming.
- wheels 5y ago> Increasingly it's becoming more of a good idea to have some math knowledge with GPUs, neural networks, machine learning, etc. but as with many deeper mathematical concepts, they'll no doubt get "black boxed" into something more digestible for people who don't want or need a deeper understanding of the inner workings. That's already happened. My wife teaches data science, including machine learning, and it's always surprising to me the extent to which modern industrial practice is about picking the right pre-coded tools from toolkits and combining them. Even though such would be up her alley (she has a PhD in astrophysics), in seven years of working in industry before teaching, she never had to translate from math to code (which I did a lot of earlier in my career).
- dgb23 5y agoThe first category of math topics I would call fundamental to abstraction and modeling. The second category I would call domain math, that is the application of math to a given problem that requires it. As being merely a programmer myself I would say both are important. The first as a fundamental thinking tool and the second depending on a project. But that’s only one part. In some of Alan Kay’s recent talks he emphasized the importance of combining math, science, engineering, art and something he calles tinkering. I think craftsmanship ought to be in there too, or maybe that is between tinkering, engineering and art? In any case I’m not sure, whether he addresses mere programmers with these. But thinking about the possible application of these concepts to any given project or creative activity really helps. So yes, I think mathematics is important, but it’s also just beautiful and fun. There are also many ways to learn it, from historical to visual and practical.
- nsonha 5y agoto be any scientist math is critical. We should be very dubious of "science" in which there is no formal proof nor statistics to support ideas.
- UK-Al05 5y agoI don't think most sciences use "formal" proof. Maths & Computer science do.
- dgb23 5y agoMicroeconomics uses formal logic and deduction, typically given assumptions and definitions around rational actors. I’m a layman but my partner is studying economics and I help her out a bit with logic and math stuff when it comes up, but I don’t know how prevalent these concepts are beyond academics.
- myWindoonn 5y agoEvery hard science uses statistics, a formal branch of pure maths, in order to justify why its models are decent at predicting real-world phenomena. The proofs usually flow backwards from how you're imagining; statisticians create new proofs which put constraints on modeling, and those constraints are used to rule out bogus scientific results.
- UK-Al05 5y agoYes, but the scientists aren't trained to create those proofs. But they use them.