39 ms·
This is literally why I'm still not buying the "searching is better than organizing" line that so many companies, including Google, try to push down our throats
by TeMPOraL 5y ago
This is literally why I'm still not buying the "searching is better than organizing" line that so many companies, including Google, try to push down our throats.
Searching is only better than organizing if searches are exhaustive, and I can trust that they are exhaustive. My experience with variety of products, including Evernote, Google Drive and GMail, tells me I can't trust that. I had plenty of instances when I searched for a thing I knew I have stored, and search returned nothing.
It's because of this why organizing is still better than searching - if you're able to sort your stuff into some hierarchy ("groups", "folders") and then be able to browse that hierarchy, you can do a fully exhaustive check manually, by just going over everything.
- lucb1e 5y ago> I'm still not buying the "searching is better than organizing" line From what I see around me, though, most people just do not have any digital organizing skills whatsoever. It's honestly exceptional that I meet someone who has files going back more than five years and those files are not on their desktop in a "previous computer" directory; and even that category of people includes only those with tech friends that helped them move the data over and set the new system up. I don't disagree with you, but we might just be the minority.
- eloisius 5y agoI agree with GP, and I'll pat myself on the back for having pretty damn well organize data going back over ten years, which has come with me over four computers. I still want powerful search on top of that, but I'm usually much more efficient at locating my own data than Spotlight is. Back when I had an MP3 collection, it was the same. I had a well-organized folder structure and it felt easier manage than Spotify. I recognize that us power users are a minority, but I really wish there was a shop out there that would build software for us instead of everyone converging towards "user-friendly."
- SilasX 5y agoYeah, I've noticed that searching my Gmail account on iPhone will often fail to find messages entirely even when I know the exact phrase in the email or the sender.
- tim333 5y agoI have my notes in one large disorganised plain text file. Sublime text searches it exhaustively in a fraction of a second. Works quite well though syncing across devices is still an issue