4 ms·
It is fascinating how copyright holders are forcing the removal of some of the history. "EDIT: Had to remove about 3.5 mins of this due to a claim by "Apri
by latchkey 5y ago
It is fascinating how copyright holders are forcing the removal of some of the history.
"EDIT: Had to remove about 3.5 mins of this due to a claim by "April Wine"...I really tried to get them to understand that this was an historical archive, *not* an attempt to steal money from their band....They didn't want to hear it...All the other artist were totally ok with this but "April Wine" said FU. Go Figure : / EDIT: EDIT: Video was taken down again because Cliff Richard suddenly decided that I was ripping him off and shut down the video...I wrote back trying to get him to change his mind but no deal, had to chop Cliff out of the video for it to be posted again. Sorry everyone."
- andrew_ 5y agoImagine being this persnickety about any use of a song that was relevant more than 30 years ago, and hasn't really been since.
- netr0ute 5y agoThat's why you don't use YouTube and instead use a decentralized platform.
- latchkey 5y agoNo. Ignoring copyright law and people's desires for their own content, isn't the solution. I suspect that using a platform where there isn't any way to profit at all is a better solution. But in this case, the CR owners have probably been burned for years and just don't want to have any more discussion around the matter. It is easier to just say no. Finding solutions that make it harder to say no seems like a better goal... of course that probably means paying them.
- netr0ute 5y ago> Ignoring copyright law and people's desires for their own content, isn't the solution. If this were actually true, then all these other platforms wouldn't exist.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Perstone 5y agoThe only way to get them to play nice is make it impossible for them to do otherwise. These artists all way come out of the woodwork to support some garbage laws that are used to censor the internet in one form or another or put some garbage spyware/security hole in our OS or browsers. I am fed up of these psychopathic companies making billions for old (and mostly crap) music that should have been made public domain decades ago (especially with some of garbage Cliff Richard has produced over the years).
- marcodiego 5y agoThis belongs to archive.org not youtube.
- latchkey 5y agoI agree with that sentiment for sure.
- squarefoot 5y agoImagine if the Rosetta Stone was digital and all ancient text inscribed there was rendered unreadable due to some for of copyright claim and following takedown. Today we would likely know squat about ancient Egyptian language. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosetta_Stone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosetta_Stone Copyright laws are a good thing, but when they become abusive, then they do a lot more damage than having no copyright laws at all.
- pix64 5y agoImagine purposefully erasing your own tiny slice of history. Congratulations, nobody cares about you and nobody will ever again.
- marcodiego 5y agoCopyright shouldn't ever turn into a threat to culture preservation.
- latchkey 5y agoI agree, but I don't think there is a threat here. I think this person genuinely wants to preserve culture or else they wouldn't be editing the video, giving credit and trying to contact people. That said, youtube probably wasn't the best place to upload the video in light of all of that.
- User23 5y agoThat’s why fair use is a thing. Which this obviously is. But most people don’t have a couple hundred k to drop on counsel.
- throw7 5y agoI guess you could say april wine were radio stars.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoLol, I get the reference, but, in this case, it’s radio stars killing video rather than vice versa.
- bigiain 5y agoThe reference is from about 20-25 seconds in to that video, from memory. Edit: 1:17 in. I'd forgotten about the moon launch bit...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kfprt 5y agoThis is why copyright should be ~10 years. Most money is made within the first year and it's a steep drop off after.
- jay_kyburz 5y agoI have an online video game and it has been making a few thousand bucks a year for over 10 years. I'm not really ready for all its art to become public domain just yet.
- cpach 5y agoGood point! OTOH author’s death + 70 years feels way too long.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoI'm curious what you think the art becoming public domain would do. Do you think you'd be swamped with competitors if they didn't need to spend what you did on art assets? Or other things would use that art and then users would find your game and not try it as they've seen the art?
- edanm 5y agoWhy is this a reason for copyright to be 10 years? I mean, that's a valid perspective (though I disagree with it), but this case doesn't provide any new information. For the record, were did you get the idea that most money is made within the first year? Sure, for the biggest stars this might be true. But lots of "middle-tier" creators depend on royalties from copyright works early in their career to sustain them their whole life.
- nostromo 5y agoThat’d probably work with music. But it’d be a disaster for authors. Often it takes more than a decade to go from book to movie, for example. I think copyright should be much shorter, but I’m not sure it’d be right to have a bunch of knock off Harry Potter books, movies, and merch as soon as 2007. Tolkien is the counter example. There’s no reason we should be protecting his work still today, 50 years after his death. They should be public domain by now.
- smcl 5y agoPretty wild that MTV would have been playing someone like Cliff Richard. At a time when MTV considered itself at the cutting edge of cool, he just strikes me as so deeply ... not.
- cpach 5y agoOTOH, wasn’t there a little bit of ’50s revival during the ’80s…?
- smcl 5y agoAh, could be!
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoyeah but I think that was caused by the Stray Cats being big with their videos on MTV - so Cliff Richard shouldn't have shown up first?
- cpach 5y agoIt could also be that MTV were desperate for something to show so they had to resort to old clips that where cheap to license (^_^)
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoyour logic has no affect on me! This was obviously the work of time traveling rockabillies!
- cpach 5y agoAh. How could I not think of that? Silly me!
- mikub 5y agoMy favorite story about copyright is that the Beatles denied NASA to put "Here comes the sun" on the Voyager golden record, because NASA didn't want to pay them royalte fees.