3 ms·
I really want to believe this, because "once an addict, always an addict" has always sounded like an unsupported, junk-science, catchy thing to say, and not som
by kelnos 5y ago
I really want to believe this, because "once an addict, always an addict" has always sounded like an unsupported, junk-science, catchy thing to say, and not something based in reality. And I don't really want to believe (yes, I know this is an emotional take), that some people's brains are just fundamentally "broken" in a way that means they can't enjoy some nice things without destroying their health and relationships.
I think also the idea of addiction (or an "addictive personality") as this inherent, unchangeable thing just doesn't pass the smell test for me. Our understanding of the human brain is still pretty limited, and making a blanket statement like that just doesn't make sense.
I can certainly understand this attitude for practical reasons: if you can get an alcoholic to stop drinking, and stay sober for the rest of their life, yes, you've certainly solved that problem. But I also suspect you haven't solved some of the underlying issues (e.g. around anxiety, dealing with emotion, etc.) that probably led them to drink excessively and uncontrollably in the first place.
But I know very few people who have (to my knowledge) gone through this sort of thing, so while I can intellectually spout off what I believe to be true, it's not coming from a position of experience.
The only real data point I have that perhaps aligns with this article is my father, and this is only from what I was told (by him, decades later). In his teens and early 20s, he drank heavily (to the point of doing some pretty unsafe things), nearly every night of the week; he was friends with the bartenders at many of the local bars, and would stay after closing to continue drinking. But during my childhood, I'd only known him to have a beer or two at a family get-together or neighborhood block party, so I asked him what changed. He said that he wanted to marry my mom, and that required him to put all that behind him. She was ok with the occasional social drink, but binge drinking or any kind of drunkenness was not kosher. He told me all this when I was in my late 20s, while we were having dinner at a brewery... drinking beer, of course.