3 ms·
> UltraFlex/MegaFlex arrays Those fit on satellites in zero g. The moon has gravity so you support them at an angle you need bracing on something else, or for
by Retric 5y ago
> UltraFlex/MegaFlex arrays
Those fit on satellites in zero g. The moon has gravity so you support them at an angle you need bracing on something else, or for extra long panels connected to a structure you need bracing inside these ultra flex panels.
In space panels can radiate from their back sides into space, but that doesn’t work on the moon as it hits 260 degrees Fahrenheit in the day. Look up panel efficiency curves with temperature. Cooling during the day is a major concern for a long term lunar base, but also needed for panels.
Further you need cables from wherever they are to where up your using power.
Lunar dust again is an issue for solar panels on the moon vs satellites.
All added up doubling weight may be generous.
> https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20060008706 https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20060008706
Sure, and that worked wonderfully a lab. But, production systems need to worry about a great deal of stuff that doesn’t apply in a lab setting. I don’t mean this dismissively yes I completely agree in theory it could work, but it’s just not working technology yet. I haven’t looked recently so hopefully there is a system demonstration out there.
- jhgb 5y ago>Those fit on satellites in zero g. The moon has gravity so you support them at an angle you need bracing on something else UltraFlex/MegaFlex is rated for 3g acceleration on those satellites even when fanned out, why do you think it would have problems with 0.16g? That's one twentieth of what they're supposed to withstand. >but that doesn’t work on the moon as it hits 260 degrees Fahrenheit in the day That's just not the case on the Lunar south pole: https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/cms/asset/60707425-279b-4609-b8e2-307165678391/jgre20604-fig-0011-m.jpg https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/cms/asset/60707425-2... > Further you need cables from wherever they are to where up your using power. High-voltage cables are not that heavy. > Sure, and that worked wonderfully a lab. But, production systems need to worry about a great deal of stuff that doesn’t apply in a lab setting. I don’t mean this dismissively yes I completely agree in theory it could work, but it’s just not working technology yet. Of course you don't; you're just disingenuously moving the goalposts.
- Retric 5y ago> why do you think it would have problems with 0.16g? That's one twentieth of what they're supposed to withstand. You seem to be stuck on just one issue, heat is vastly more of an issue than this. Anyway, flexing isn’t breaking. https://www.americaspace.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/LIFE-Phoenix-on-Mars.jpg https://www.americaspace.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/LIFE... The actual panel on Mars isn’t flat or particularly big. Now, if we’re assuming the Moon mission is going to be at it’s equator then laying them directly on the lunar surface is fine. But big arrays at an angle need to be rigid or you’re losing poster from a using a worse angle due to the curve, either option means more weight for a given power output. > That's just not the case on the Lunar south pole Sure, and that deals with heat but now the solar array needs to deal with being at the poles.
- jhgb 5y agoThis is an absolutely meaningless level of deformation. The array will be perfectly fine in Lunar gravity. And even if it weren't, instead of a fan, you could equally well shape it into a folded vertical curtain hanging from a beam with pretty much the same parameters. > Sure, and that deals with heat but now the solar array needs to deal with being at the poles. "Now"? It needed to deal with being at the pole the whole time. There was never an intention to put it elsewhere.
- Retric 5y ago> you could equally shape it into a folded vertical curtain from a beam with pretty much the same parameters. Attaching a beam at one end requires a more rigid structure which is more weight, which is exactly what I said the problem was several times. > There never was an intention to put it elsewhere. I just said you could lower weight by laying them flat at the equator. My point was simply that isn’t an option, therefore you they need extra support. Operating closer to the poles has both clear advantages and downsides, access to water is a big benefit but it’s not quite as obvious a choice as often assumed.
- 5y ago