4 ms·
An interesting read, I still often have trouble discerning what irony is supposed to be versus the colloquial use. So I'll pose this as a question to the commu
by Jtsummers 5y ago
An interesting read, I still often have trouble discerning what irony is supposed to be versus the colloquial use.
So I'll pose this as a question to the community: About halfway down the article there was a link (for me) to "What Nihilism is Not" with a description "In order to preserve nihilism as a meaningful concept, it’s necessary to distinguish it from pessimism, cynicism, and apathy." Is it ironic that in an article about irony there is a link to an article on a philosophy premised on the meaninglessness of life that intends to preserve its meaningfulness?
- akiselev 5y agoDo you find it ironic? That's pretty much the only thing that matters because irony is colloquial. Every textbook definition of "irony" that I can find includes a human observer in judgement of the situation - the universe has no intrinsic concept of irony, only humans with expectations and a sense of humor do.
- sidlls 5y agoThis seems reductive to the point of uselessness. Technically every situation involving communication includes the judgement of a human observer: to extend your argument, we may as well assert there is no non-colloquial understanding of basically any word.
- chairhairair 5y agoAn interesting question! Here is my impression after reading this article on irony: It is ironic to write an article with the aim of preserving the meaningfulness of the term nihilism. It is not ironic to embed a link to that article within an article about irony.
- JohnBooty 5y agoIs it ironic that in an article about irony there is a link to an article on a philosophy premised on the meaninglessness of life that intends to preserve its meaningfulness? It's kind of funny, bordering on ironic I suppose. Irony is generally understood to involve an outcome that is contrary to expectations. It has been said that the textbook example of irony would be the bullet that nearly killed Ronald Reagan. The bullet initially missed him, but riccocheted off the bulletproof glass of his limo -- the thing meant to save him from bullets! -- and then struck him. In fact, it actually contributed greatly to his near-death: because the shooter never had a clear shot at Reagan, the initial assumption was that he had not been shot, and had simply hurt his ribs when being shoved into the car by his bodyguards following the shooting. Had he instead been shot directly, there would have been no such confusion or delay. Does an article about the meaningfulness of nihilism run contrary to expectations? If it was written by a nihilist, perhaps! If it was written by a non-nihilist, I'd say no -- it would not be unexpected for others to assign meaningfulness to a philosophy that has had some impact on the world, even if those who subscribe to the philosophy maintain that there is no meaning in things.
- _carbyau_ 5y agoWell, I have given the Nihilism "meaninglessness" bit some thought and see no problem with it. So...no, not ironic at all? The bit many people seem to skip over is that Nihilism's "meaninglessness" is in the context of long time frames. So, actions have a timeframe of impact, with varying - but not infinite - length. Knowing this, you can ascribe more relevant meaning to your actions, and hence better decide which actions to take. It can also let you put past actions you regret into perspective. You will still regret those actions, but those actions, and associated regret, come with a timeframe.