4 ms·
Vaccine immunity IS "natural" immunity. It works the same way, by exposing the body's immune system to virus components such that they product a response. The
by ajross 5y ago
Vaccine immunity IS "natural" immunity. It works the same way, by exposing the body's immune system to virus components such that they product a response. The only difference is that with a vaccine those components don't add up to a viable organism.
But yes: expect newer vaccines tailored to currently-circulating strains to appear; the existing mRNA vaccines produce copies of the spike protein sequenced more than a year ago. That's what we've done for influenza for decades, though not with the same kind of precision.
- chuinard 5y agoDamn you got downvoted real quick.
- kfprt 5y agoIt's not quite the same, delivery (mechanism/location/encapsulation) is different.
- JimBlackwood 5y agoSure, but there is a real difference in response between vaccine/virus. I think, given the difference in response, the term natural immunity makes sense. You have to choose something and I don’t think ‘natural immunity’ says anything about vaccine immunity being unnatural.
- nickthemagicman 5y agoHow is an mRNA strand that encode for a single very specific protein on a virus the same as the entire virus? The antibody memory made from a Natural Infection seems like it would be much richer and have much more variety than the mRNA vaccine. I would imagine the attenuated virus vaccine would be closer to Natural immunity.
- Buttons840 5y agoYour body might accidentally create an immunity to a portion of the virus that mutates. Perhaps the protein produced by vaccine mRNA forces your body to create an immunity against a portion of the virus that is less likely to mutate. I don't know if this is the case, but I offer this as an example of how our biological systems may be complicated beyond intuition.
- arein3 5y ago>our biological systems may be complicated beyond intuition. right, that's why the natural way provides the best immunity
- shadowgovt 5y agoThe spike protein is part of COVID-19's infection mechanism. The thinking (if I understand correctly) in targeting the spike protein was that mutations to the spike protein may render the vaccine less effective, but would also render COVID-19 less infectious. It's a clever hack to rely not on whether the spike is mutation-prone, but instead on the odds that a mutation would result in a less effective virus that the vaccine wouldn't be necessary for.
- User23 5y agoThe Red Cross disagrees[1]: “One of the Red Cross requirements for plasma from routine blood and platelet donations that test positive for high-levels of antibodies to be used as convalescent plasma is that it must be from a donor that has not received a COVID-19 vaccine. This is to ensure that antibodies collected from donors have sufficient antibodies directly related to their immune response to a COVID-19 infection and not just the vaccine, as antibodies from an infection and antibodies from a vaccine are not the same.” Interestingly this means if you have natural immunity and are a regular blood donor you shouldn’t get the vaccine since it deprives the healthcare system of a lifesaving treatment. [1] https://www.redcrossblood.org/donate-blood/dlp/coronavirus--covid-19--and-blood-donation.html https://www.redcrossblood.org/donate-blood/dlp/coronavirus--...
- maxerickson 5y agoThey are following the FDA guidance for the convalescent plasma EUA, which does allow people that were sick prior to vaccination to donate plasma...it seems the Red Cross isn't interested in trying to communicate that to potential donors. https://www.fda.gov/media/136798/download https://www.fda.gov/media/136798/download If you expand the boxes on your link, you'll also see that they aren't specifically collecting convalescent plasma, as demand has decreased. Perhaps that is changing with the recent uptick (but given the demographics of blood donation, they'll probably have to change their rules if they need a lot of it; most people donate ~1 time).
- User23 5y agoYes I read the link I myself posted, and yes I see the above since that's why I specifically said "regular blood donor." Obviously casual donors should just get vaccinated.