4 ms·
Reed Elsevier and the other rent seekers got no reason to live. That said: in the legal world, where PACER extracts $0.10 per "page" even now that you get thin
by AlbertCory 5y ago
Reed Elsevier and the other rent seekers got no reason to live.
That said: in the legal world, where PACER extracts $0.10 per "page" even now that you get things electronically and the cost is near zero:
There's a service RECAP (PACER spelled backwards), where you can install a browser extension which automatically copies anything you download from PACER to a free archive. So one person pays, and the rest get it free.
It is amazingly complete, much more than you would think. For instance, here's the entry for the Elizabeth Holmes (Theranos) trial:
https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/7185174/united-states-v-holmes/ https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/7185174/united-states-v...
- ipaddr 5y agoCurious if the backup service is legal?
- AlbertCory 5y agoIt's been going on for years, I know that. I don't know if the rent-seekers have ever tried to shut it down. The fact that it's so complete tells me that a huge number of mainstream law firms look the other way when their employees use the browser extension.
- erhk 5y agoLots of illicit things go on for years
- AlbertCory 5y agoTrue. This is, almost by definition, a very litigious sector though.
- syshum 5y agoIn the case of PACER, they are public records, and have no copy right attached to them as they are government documents, the government can not hold copyrights by definition everything the US government produces public domain.
- kragen 5y agoSo was the FBI. They harassed my friend Aaron for a year when he started snarfing PACER documents from public libraries. In the end they had to conclude it was legal, so they couldn't prosecute him for it; instead he was persecuted by different US Attorneys for downloading papers from JSTOR until he committed suicide.
- throwaway984393 5y ago> Reed Elsevier and the other rent seekers got no reason to live. Listen to me, HN. Stop listening to this meme. You aren't using your brains. Everyone has a hard-on for Elsevier, and no other publisher. Why is that? Because they don't know anything about publishing. They've just heard the name Elsevier (and it kind of looks evil) and so they just parrot it ad-nauseam. What about Springer? Taylor & Francis? Wiley-Blackwell? And what about the hundreds of smaller publishers that control major journals? Everyone gives Elsevier shit about suing Sci-Hub, but nobody gives the American Chemical Society shit for suing Sci-Hub. The fact is that people only hold up Elsevier as the great evil because people are tying to over-simplify a complex problem by finding a "single evil", because then they don't have to think about a more complex, nuanced problem. The fact is that there is a reason that paid journals keep existing, and it's not the profit margins of the Big Four. It's the academic research industry. Every single academic research institute in the world that publishes papers depends on the reputation of journals. Getting your paper published in a "prestigious journal" is literally the only way to progress a researcher's career, and thus get more funding. Without funding, there is no research! And the journals are providing real due diligence happening in the process of creating those journals, and somebody has to pay for that process. If the paid journals went away tomorrow, researchers would be fucked, and academic institutions would have no idea what to do with themselves. So please stop with this ridiculous meme that Elsevier is The Great Satan holding back science. Sure, they should profit a lot less! But getting rid of them entirely with no system to replace them will be destructive to scientific research.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nlitened 5y agoCan’t tell if the parent comment is sarcastic or not.
- da39a3ee 5y agoYes, that’s how it worked. The rather major point you are missing is that things change.
- AlbertCory 5y ago
- franga2000 5y agoReading this comment, I assumed PACER was a private provider who sells access to otherwise freely available material which originally might be scattered and unorganised as government things usually are. Charging for access would therefore be reasonable. But a quick search reveals that this is in fact a government-provided service. So your government charges you 10 cents per page to download PDFs from a glorified file server. The US has around 1.5M people working in the legal field. Let's say each of them does 10 document lookups every day. 15 million requests in an 8 hour workday comes out to 500 requests per second. Don't quote me on this, but I'm pretty sure a modern workstation could handle that, let alone a dedicated server or ever a few of them with good caching and client-side load balancing. SCOTUS spends 16M yearly just on building maintenance, I think it's safe to assume they can afford a handful of servers without having to resort to microtransactions...
- manquer 5y agoGoing down the cost rabbit hole is problematic, the costs are not just for the service infra. Even for the service you need project managers , product owners, devs, SREs, QAs and data entry operators who collate or atleast update the DB . Easily costs that can run in millions/year. Typically such revenue streams cover other holes in the budget not related to this service as well, and there is indirect overhead costs like Contracts, control structures, HR, vendors etc harder to amortize. Any costs for what should be free public access in not right. The argument should be that we pay already tax, this information public should have free and easily .
- franga2000 5y agoI generally agree and my estimates were of course the bare minumum, but the "we already pay tax" argument doesn't really work since, well, this service clearly isn't tax-funded given the fact that it isn't free. It might be tax-subsidised, which often makes sense for things that are very expensive and have limited usefulness to individual citizens (like many services governments render to businesses are). If we consider accessing court records to be something with very limited usefulness to most people and primarily used by companies to make money (which I do, despite having done it myself on a few occasions), how expensive it actually is to run becomes very important when convincing "the people" to fund it 100%.