3 ms·
In case someone has some direct knowledge or credible sources: I'm not sure what is stopping reform at a political level. Who is the political constituency that
by wolverine876 5y ago
In case someone has some direct knowledge or credible sources: I'm not sure what is stopping reform at a political level. Who is the political constituency that obstructs open access? The publishers seem too small, and the science and higher ed constituency too large.
- cycomanic 5y agoI can't give you direct links, but I know that large scientific/engineering organisations have not been pushing for free open access. For example the IEEE has been part of an open letter (which included Elsivier) lobbying against Plan S. These organisations derive a lot of their money from publishing, so while many (most) of the members are strongly in favor of OA, the buerocratics in the organisations often are not. Which gives mixed messages to politicians. On top of that I believe that non-scientific publishers have also been part of the lobby campaign as they see OA as weakening copyright.
- Vinnl 5y agoFunders have been relying on publishers to tell them (by means of who they publish) what researchers are worth funding. This is keeping up the pressure for academics to keep publishing in paywalled journals. There is some pressure to both make research not paywalled (Plan S is the strongest) and less costly. However, given that most of the funders' researchers can access most relevant research (albeit rather clumsily, thanks to the access mechanisms, and not 100%, hence Sci-Hub even being popular among those who do have access), and that the extracted rent on the scale of a country budget isn't that much, the pressure isn't particularly strong. Additionally, it's hard for a single funder/country to move on its own without ruining their academics' careers (hence Plan S's focus on signing on more funders).