6 ms·
Understanding Heidegger on technology (2014)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- imbnwa 5y agoDespite the actual historical research not being so hot or voluminous, I find Bataille's theory of General Economy a much more robust and more tangible way of describing the conditions of modernity while also indicating a specific response/solution, namely, that we have to re-learn to sacrifice, not accumulate, excess, like our ancestors did for most of human existence. We don't build ridiculously grand and inefficient structures like Pyramids and Cathedrals or practice ritual sacrifice because we no longer entertain the notion that human economy necessarily involves realms that require the destruction of excess production (and no, the destruction of excess dairy or agricultural production in the name of market controls on prices is not that). All the way up to early modernity humans unanimously understood economy like this to some extent, even if Abrahamic religions changed the flow around so that economy of surplus came to revolve around the excess of desire-production in humans specifically rather involving the entire realm of goods (Judaism still understood the older arrangement to a certain extent: we know that Cain and Abel burned produce to God, or that Jacob was on the cusp of sacrificing his only son to God; in Christianity, as Nietzsche noted, the debtor, God, pays himself back with his own flesh, and Christian practice proper is this immolation of the 'excess of the flesh', human desire, to our own more godly selves, our souls).
- maxbendick 5y agoLove to see Bataille and Heidegger on hn :) The concept of the accursed share seems pretty applicable to space races of the present. Maybe it's a sign the flux of capital is saturating?
- kaycebasques 5y agoWhat is Bataille's seminal work on the theory of general economy? The Accursed Share? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Accursed_Share https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Accursed_Share
- imbnwa 5y agoYes, those texts
- juliend2 5y agoI don't want to be too pedantic here ;) , but it was Abraham who was on the cusp of sacrificing his only son to God. But you were close; Jacob was his grand-son. And I'm not sure what Nietzsche said exactly about it but God is considered to be the creditor (not debtor), who pays for us the humans (indebted by our sins), to himself, with the flesh of his only son.
- imbnwa 5y agoYeah wrote all those out off the top of my head, a draft phase woulda been useful indeed, these corrections are all true
- sn41 5y agoAbraham was asked to sacrifice his son, Isaac, I think. (Ibrahim and Ismail in Islam?)
- Mark_Kumleben 5y agoVery interesting to see this on HN - Heidegger's theory of technology was ground-breaking then and has only become more timely. If anybody has questions about this article, Mark Blitz was my advisor in grad school and I wrote an MA thesis applying Heidegger's theory to modern AI research. Happy to clarify any of the issues raised here since, even with Blitz's explanation, Heidegger can be a tough nut to crack.
- maxbendick 5y agoWould love a short explanation/link to your MA thesis, that seems very interesting!
- syntaxfree 5y agoHubert Dreyfus worked on Heideggerean critiques of AI while at MIT rubbing shoulders with Marvin Minsky and the like. There’s a good documentary called “Being in the world”; last time I checked it had been posted on YouTube.
- Mark_Kumleben 5y agoFor sure! Of course, the official website has it paywalled, so here's a Google Docs link: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1WL1F-sEazLeo8uFjNpPyFLaktinB3vhAxCtJ74vLYWI/edit?usp=sharing https://docs.google.com/document/d/1WL1F-sEazLeo8uFjNpPyFLak... The Heidegger stuff is in the fourth section, 'Artificial Intelligence In Technological Society', but a rough summary: Heidegger argues that the essence of technology involves a command to human beings to order the world as standing-reserves of resources. Our specific place in this schema is as the being who can do the work of ordering, of revealing the world as orderable standing-reserve and then actually putting it into a particular order (e.g. of a supply chain). However, modern AI, with its emphasis on pattern-recognition, search, optimizing for a goal, etc., is also working towards that function. This has two implications. First, it suggests why AI research heads in this direction, because it's the way human intelligence manifests in the technological framework (and, thus, suggests that AI research could potentially benefit from trying to replicate other aspects of the human mind). Secondly, it means that modern AI might affect a Heideggerian theory of technology by making it possible for humans to delegate the work of ordering to AI, which wouldn't have appeared a possibility in Heidegger's day. If we can in fact hand off the task of ordering to AI, how should we do that and what effects might it have on human culture? While it appears a loss of agency, it may even have a liberating effect in the same way other technologies have liberated us from previous forms of labour.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kaycebasques 5y agoI don't remember the details but I recall Philosophize This! having an accessible series on Heidegger (with one episode [1] specifically discussing his views on technology). [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C_BxMwRywEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C_BxMwRywEk
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MichaelZuo 5y ago“ Experiencing technology as a kind — but only one kind — of revealing, and seeing man’s essential place as one that is open to different kinds of revealing frees us from “the stultified compulsion to push on blindly with technology or, what comes to the same, to rebel helplessly against it and curse it as the work of the devil.” Indeed, Heidegger says at the end of the lecture, our examining or questioning of the essence of technology and other kinds of revealing is “the piety of thought.” By this questioning we may be saved from technology’s rule.” The article assumes a strange contorted definition of ‘technology’ to try to jam a certain point in. By most definitions, human language would be considered as part of ‘technology’, certainly the written word would be considered so by nearly all. From that understanding, to question at all requires ‘technology’ thus making the final sentence absurd.
- nathias 5y agoCommon sense definitions are useless in philosophy.
- pmoriarty 5y ago"In his landmark book Being and Time (1927), Heidegger made the bold claim that Western thought from Plato onward had forgotten or ignored the fundamental question of what it means for something to be -- to be present for us prior to any philosophical or scientific analysis." No. "what it means for something to be" is, for Heidegger, merely "ontic being", which he was not interested in. Instead, Hedigger was interesested in "ontological being", or "the being of Being". Now, what "the being of Being" is, is itself the subject of a multi-hundred page unfinished book of what is widely considered to be some of the most difficult writing in all of philosophy. Because Heidegger's writing is so difficult and so open to interpretation (and re-interpretation), many philosophers disagree strongly about what he actually meant. For example, what "Being" itself is, for Heidegger, is one of the biggest points of contention. The entire field of Christian Existentialism[1] crystalized around interpreting Heidegger's "Being" as God. But many other philosophers don't interpret it theistically at all. His other essays outside of Being and Time are equally difficult to understand and open to interpretation. This includes "The Question Concerning Technology", and I'd caution strongly against taking any one summary or interpretation of it as gospel or the final word on the subject. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_existentialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_existentialism
- elefanten 5y agoSo what is the value of such work, which is so open to interpretation that 100 years later you will find diametrically opposed takes on its meaning? Does it not just devolve into a Rubik's Cube for literary nerds? I ask seriously. I was deeply enchanted with critical / Continental philosophy for a decade, but I don't think I came out of it with any unique insights. "Nothing can be proven to be objectively true" is an insight one can find many other places. Conjectures about what the driving forces of society are a dime a dozen, but any useful means of verifying and comparing them seems far out of our reach. So, why all this study of the Heideggers, the Lacans, the Derridas. What does it really contribute to humanity?
- pmoriarty 5y ago"why all this study of the Heideggers, the Lacans, the Derridas" I can't speak for anyone else, but my interest in Heidegger dovetails with my interest in Asian and Indian religion and philosophy, and with my interest in the illusory nature of the world and what lies behind the world of appearances. I'm not interested in Lacan or Derrida, so will leave them for others. "What does it really contribute to humanity?" Is having one's eye's opened or seeking ways to open one's eyes useful? Does something have to "contribute to humanity" in order to be of value? What did the Mona Lisa or other great works of art contribute to humanity? Should Beethoven never have written a note of music because none of it is useful? Or does Beethoven's music's use in parades finally justify its creation? Can philosophy, like art and music, somehow connect us or open us up to the core of humanity or the world? Is that useful? Does it have to be?
- 50 5y ago> “In Heidegger’s later work, he argues that technology in the modern metaphysical tradition tends to “provoke,” “force out,” and “challenge forth” the world, such that the primary intention is to “force” the world to yield energy. Heidegger calls this “the essence of technology,” and it is this essence, he says, that constitutes the “culmination of modern metaphysics.” The philosopher Bruce Foltz describes how this perceptual rupture plays out in Heidegger’s work: “[T]o be’ is ‘to be a resource,’ that is to be ‘in stock,’ in supply, ready for delivery.” To say that modern metaphysics culminates in technology is to say that there are tight and dense entanglements between the modern narrative of separation and technology. The perfectly-straight concrete road cut through a boreal forest is a thought structure “concretely” articulated, and in turn it seeds the imagination with opportunities of how to encounter (or use) that forest in ways unthinkable - and thus unreal - without the road. Likewise, a dam built into a salmon river is abstract thought physically articulated; in turn, the presence of the physical structure gathers the imagination around particularly mechanistic, utilitarian opportunities for encountering the river. Narrative and technology reinforce one another in powerful feedback loops, each contributing their share to revealing the world in a particular manner.” — Being Salmon, Being Human: Encountering the Wild in Us, and Us in the Wild, by Martin Lee Mueller
- mandeville 5y agoNot an expert, but Heidegger on technology (1950s) seems very similar to Adorno's Dialectic of Enlightenment from 1944. Funny given their differences.
- 6AA4FD 5y agoHe and Husserl has similar "differences" from my memory. The same for Arendt, I think.
- aporetics 5y ago> Whatever the full and subtle meaning of “in essence the same” is, Heidegger fails to address the difference in ethical weight between the two phenomena he compares, or to show a path for just political choice. The first half of the article has some neat summaries of Heidegger’s thought and it’s reception, but I’m alarmed about Blitz’s sudden jump into the ethical and political at this point. I know he’s a political philosopher, but these texts, especially QCT, are about where and how it us possible to experience the world as itself any more. You can’t defer to ethics to adjudicate a crisis of perception. A good reader of the essay would need, at this point, to go back and understand what is meant by the phrase “prepare a free relationship” with technology. It’s just… odd. This turn by Blitz. He knows grouping these things is a provocation. He knows the provocation is to help us try to grasp the extent to which the fate of things is determined by the “enframing” in which they (may) appear. Then he just appeals to a normie’s average sense of the ethical difference between agriculture and genocide?