3 ms·
I get the feeling that society in the large is all about vague implementations and vague evaluations models that are vaguely good enough to not be cancelled. S
by agumonkey 5y ago
I get the feeling that society in the large is all about vague implementations and vague evaluations models that are vaguely good enough to not be cancelled.
Society is extremely inefficient
- ironmagma 5y agoInefficient when compared to what alternative though? To actually get anything perfect would require an infinite amount of time, so any requirements are a balancing act.
- agumonkey 5y agofair enough, in the context of energy savings you'd have a point, but I was mentioning this as a general problem even for non pressing issues it seems to me that we could still provide more with less (resources and time), without going in analysis paralysis
- Meandering 5y agoYes, yes, and yes. The problem is "virtue signaling" and the ideological capture of politics. People know what they want at the end of the day. "I don't want to destroy the earth" or "I don't want to poison the well" are common enough goals for most environmental people. The problem is a society where worker specialization has ostrated people from function knowledge and the time to understand the full scope of any given issue. We are now dependent on public sentiment towards possible solutions which is normally pushed via politics. We are pushing extremes to break through into action which diminishes the effectiveness of any resulting system. We gather around buzz words or a sentence from some academic article to justify the righteousness and effectiveness of one piece of a complex system. Since people can't be honest in a political environment, we cannot identify the cons or initiate substantial dissent within an approach. We are unified by the common denominator of our intelligence and access to information in order to roar through legislation. We are left with an ineffective system at an unreasonable cost resulting in a poor ROI. *steps off soapbox
- wolverine876 5y ago> The problem is "virtue signaling" and the ideological capture of politics. An example: Instead of talking about green buildings, you 'captured' the conversation into politics, repeating well-worn cliches that don't inform us - everyone has heard them before, as you know - but do signal something.
- Meandering 5y agoThe issue is that buzz words and politics are an integral part in the system. The types of technologies and methods that receive government and NGO support will prevail. Tax credits are use to incentivize the adoption of certain technologies while building codes favor certain techniques. The point is that attempting to create green buildings is inherently political and the inefficiencies of politics is preventing the execution of science.
- wolverine876 5y ago> attempting to create green buildings is inherently political There is nothing 'inherent' about your individual actions. Instead of being interested and curious and talking about science, you dismissed other people's perspectives with political stereotypes.
- Aerroon 5y agoPeople want justifications for their choices. Being able to point at reasons why x is better than y makes us feel better about the choices we make. That's why you buy the gizmo that can do 6 things rather than 2 - it's easier to justify in your mind. We analyze the benefits and costs of our choices, but only on some specific metrics. We remain (sometimes intentionally) blind towards what we might not know. And if others justify things the same way, then we feel more secure in our choices. If everyone says that x is green and green is better then we believe it. We don't question whether it's actually better. Eg promises of recycling vs actual recycling.
- marcinzm 5y agoA slight improvement is better than no improvement due to perpetual planning deadlock.
- rualca 5y ago> I get the feeling that society in the large is all about vague implementations and vague evaluations models that are vaguely good enough to not be cancelled. Well, western society didn't adopted central planning, in a good part as central planning's failure to meet society's needs. Anyway, I don't think it's fair to criticize these efforts by depicting them as some sort of failure or the result of incompetence or shortsightedness. We have to have some humility when discussing these topics specially if they are from a field where we have no insight at all. In this case, we should keep inind that valuing energy efficiency and externalities is something that's extremely novel where society as a whole is just starting to take it's first steps. It's quite literally a highly transformative change that involves changes in all steps of an entire industry, including in building regulation and even urban planning. Change is happening as we speak, but what you are looking at, and criticizing, is society's first step in a much needed direction.
- agumonkey 5y agoit's true, it's easy to criticize from a chair, but I've noticed way too much failures (wind turbines failures if not scam at times, who also set back a lot of other projects due to the bad press; extremely bad public sector policies causing bad work environment + bad work quality + multi-year long delay) I think it's fair to at least voice it out, I'm just trying to dig out what are the real reasons and potential new ideas.