6 ms·
The values from Dukes's paper are illuminating. - The fossil fuels burned in a year represent about 400 years' worth of accumulated ancient biomass. That is,
by dredmorbius 5y ago
The values from Dukes's paper are illuminating.
- The fossil fuels burned in a year represent about 400 years' worth of accumulated ancient biomass. That is, you'd need to capture all the biomass grown for four centuries to give the fuel we consume in one year.
- But conversion and preservation aren't perfect. So it took five million years to form just the oil we consume annually (or did in 1997, though values have remained reasonably constant since). That is, only about 0.008% of ancient biomass was stored as petroleum.
I don't know the figures for carbon-cycle sequester and release rates, though at best we're looking at centuries to remove what we've put into the atmosphere in decades, if not longer.
- pfdietz 5y agoCO2 is mostly sequestered by reaction to form carbonates, not by reduction to biomass, but yes it will take a long time. In the intermediate it will dissolve into the deep ocean (mostly), but even that takes a while.
- dredmorbius 5y agoBy chemical / geological processes, or as organic limestone (mostly shellfish / plankton skeleton) deposits?
- pfdietz 5y agoBoth? The calcium to make the limestone has to come from somewhere.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI'd consider that biological origin, if not primarily then through an obligate mechanism.
- zozbot234 5y agoThis reaction can also be accelerated by crushing basalts and other readily-available rocks to a fine sand/dust, and exposing that to the open air by spreading it over large areas of ground, such as fields or beaches. The process is not cheaper than other kinds of carbon sequestration, but it's definitely comparable and long-term sequestration of the carbon seems especially likely, since we're simply enhancing the existing geological carbon cycle.
- pfdietz 5y agoPeridotites, in particular, with lots of olivine. Olivine weathers particularly quickly because its silicon atoms are in SiO4(4-) tetrahedra that are not covalently linked to each other (a "nesosilicate"). A problem with just spreading this out on beaches and the like is that these rocks are also often enriched in nickel vs. the average crustal rock, and this would release many millions of tonnes of nickel into the environment. There is some evidence that nickel release was part of the terrible events at the Permian-Triassic extinction. Nickel is crucial to the enzymes in the metabolic pathways leading to the production of methane in anaerobic environments. There's an idea that nickel injection into the oceans by fallout from the PT megaeruption in Siberia led to massive methane production.
- isx726552 5y agoSo projectvesta.org (if it ever comes to pass) might actually end up inadvertently releasing methane?
- lmilcin 5y agoI would also point out that today it is not possible to form new large scale coal/oil deposits. Coal/oil deposits that we are using up now formed because at the time there was no bacteria that could digest dead plant/plankton matter. This is also why all coal/oil deposits are very old. There is very little deposits after bacteria has evolved. Nowadays there needs to be special circumstances for a piece of biological matter to not be digested by bacteria. For example it would have to be covered by permafrost or drown in oxygen-deficient lake for a very, very long time and then covered by soil.
- kfprt 5y agoThis was the most interesting thing I learned when studying geology. More people should know about it.
- Qwertious 5y agoIt's a controversial claim and probably false, definitely don't repeat it unless you've personally verified with an expert.
- taberiand 5y agoSo at least once we send ourselves extinct through fossil-fuel driven climate change, any intelligent life that comes after us won't have the resources to do the same.