3 ms·
I can't believe this is actually a big issue if that's the best example they can come up with. Most of the problems could be traced to simplified models they c
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
I can't believe this is actually a big issue if that's the best example they can come up with.
Most of the problems could be traced to simplified models they claim, yet the two they actually mention in detail clearly did not. And they make no attempt to quantify the contribution (in terms of cost Vs energy waste) of the ones that do.
It seems highly unlikely that they'll rival having your heat on too high and the windows open to vent the heat.
In particular, a school in a valley in the UK having its lights on doesn't on really seem like a big deal as long as they're using LED lights. Attempting to harness natural light in this type of building sounds like a feel-good notion that can't possibly compete with decent led lighting run from a renewable grid.
- rini17 5y agoYou dismiss is as mere feel-good notion, I say it's prevention of seasonal depression. I live in a house with huge southeastern window... and when there's occassional clear winter morning, the light and later the warmth, that's...glorious! No idea how could I replicate that with LEDs, would be probably pretty expensive.
- robbedpeter 5y agoHaving gone down the indoor hydroponics/aeroponics rabbit hole, I find it likely that you could buy leds with the exact frequency or spread of light needed to counter the light perception issue - seasonal depression is probably a complex of deficiencies, though, so light alone probably wouldn't be sufficient. Some combination of atmosphere, temperature differential and duration, physical activity, and recurrence could all come into play. And vitamin d and possibly other nutrient deficits depending on seasonal food in your market. If it was as simple as light exposure, leds on glasses would be an easy cheap fix - wear light therapy glasses x minutes a day while you work or listen to podcasts, etc.
- namibj 5y agoInterestingly, solar panels and LEDs are more efficient than plants directly in the sun, due to the spectrum inefficiency of the green light absorbing dye.
- bregma 5y agoPhotosynthesis uses energy in the red part of the visible spectrum. That's why they look green. They do not absorb the green light, they reflect it. Plants store their solar energy in a hydrogen-carbon bond for storage. To compare a plant with a solar panel and LED you need to also include the storage technology, which is usually batteries. Because plants do not as a rule glow brightly, a more apt comparison would involve, say, a locomotion system. Comparing the efficiency of, perhaps, a car that drives at night powered by a solar/battery system vs. a plant/combustion system. It would be an interesting experiement.
- namibj 5y agoNo, the comparison is between a glass roof and a solar roof with LEDs underneath. And yes, I know the dye doesn't absorb green. It's still a green dye; last I checked we name dyes by their reflected color.
- cycomanic 5y agoI think your post and the reply of the previous poster is a perfect example of why comma's are important. You meant a "green, light-absorbing dye" (using hyphens to make the distinction clearer), the previous poster understood "a green-light absorbing dye".
- robbedpeter 5y agoLet's eat grandma!
- rini17 5y agoIt is sometimes as simple as not having tinted windows :)
- oldsecondhand 5y agoBut then you can't read computer screens and annoy people with the sun blinding them.
- rini17 5y agoIt's possible that in few years we'll switch to e-ink anyway. But we'll stuck with architecture based on minimising natural light "annoyance" for a very long time.
- jaggederest 5y ago> Attempting to harness natural light in this type of building sounds like a feel-good notion that can't possibly compete with decent led lighting run from a renewable grid. Most indoor lighting is below 1000 lux. Bright daylight without direct sun is 10000 lux. There's no comparison between proper daylighting and almost any reasonable amount of indoor lighting. This is why it's very difficult to see things even on a very high luminance screen like a Macbook Pro outdoors during daylight.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoAre you suggesting that being unable to read a computer screen is some kind of desireable quality in a classroom setting? I didn't mean compete in terms of max lux output, though if they actually wanted to do that for whatever odd reason (film studio? indoor weed farming?), the basic tech probably could as well. I meant effective task lighting for multiple people and multiple tasks across seasons in a large building with multiple very similar large rooms that have windows in different places but usually along one wall only (in a valley, in a cloudy country relatively far from the equator).
- jaggederest 5y agoNo, I'm saying that there's no reasonable lighting system that can approximate even "cloudy country far from the equator" brightness that comes through windows. So if they set the windows up wrong, you can't patch over it with LEDs. Especially for children, whose visual cortexes are still developing, which requires bright light and high contrast.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoYou still seem to be suggesting that a) a very large amount of light is required in a classroom setting and, b) it is beyond our current technology to achieve this level of light via LED lighting without sunlight provided by windows. Which on the face of it, seems totally absurd. Things such as Night School, and schools/offices near the poles for example, exist. Is there something more specific that you're actually saying?
- Zababa 5y ago> In particular, a school in a valley in the UK having its lights on doesn't on really seem like a big deal as long as they're using LED lights. Attempting to harness natural light in this type of building sounds like a feel-good notion that can't possibly compete with decent led lighting run from a renewable grid. Maybe that's just me, but natural light is way better for my mental health than artificial light. Being forced to depend on artificial light makes me feel like I'm in a basement, which I don't like at all.