4 ms·
For a more complete answer on where oil does come from (spoiler: not dinosaurs --- TFA actually does a nice job of tying that myth to Sinclair Petroleum's adver
by dredmorbius 5y ago
For a more complete answer on where oil does come from (spoiler: not dinosaurs --- TFA actually does a nice job of tying that myth to Sinclair Petroleum's advertising mascot), see Jeffrey S. Dukes, "Burning Buried Sunshine" (2003): https://www-legacy.dge.carnegiescience.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_ClimChange1.pdf https://www-legacy.dge.carnegiescience.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_C... (PDF)
The beauty of this piece is that it breaks down just how much primordeal biomass goes into producing the oil (and coal and gas) we burn today, and how much ancient time is represented in each present year of consumption. (It's millions.)
I've submitted this numerous times to HN with little uptake, most recently: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27827505 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27827505
- lmilcin 5y agoAlso worth to point out Earth needed millions of years to sequester that CO2 we release to atmosphere each year.
- jonsen 5y agoThe atmospheric CO2 is not a that slow sequestering process. It has varied considerably over much shorter time periods than “millions of years”. “Carbon dioxide concentrations have varied widely over the Earth's 4.54 billion year history.”: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth%27s_atmosphere https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth%27s_...
- lmilcin 5y agoI guess you don't understand what "sequestering" means. Sequestering is a process where carbon becomes unavailable for biological processes. So you have carbon circulating (present in biomass, returned to atmosphere, then back to biomass, etc.) and you have carbon that is not available for circulation. Carbon in atmosphere is part of circulation. When a supervolcano erupts and emits a bunch of CO2, this adds carbon to atmosphere but then that carbon may very quickly be bound in biomass (for example algae, forests, etc.) This doesn't mean it is sequestered. The algae can die and ferment and forests can burn, releasing CO2 back to atmosphere. Earth has ability to very quickly bind large amounts of CO2 from atmosphere, true. But it does not have ability to sequester it, because as long as the carbon is present in biomass, that biomass can burn or rot and change to methane/CO2. Current coal, oil and gas deposits are due to the fact that at early stages of evolution there was no bacteria that could process some parts of biomass. For example, plants rather than rot would just be covered with more plants and become coal deposits. Today, it is not possible to form new coal or oil deposits, because any biomass would be quickly digested/fermented/rotted before it could be sequestered.
- FooHentai 5y agoThe pre-bacteria theory is pretty shaky fyi. There is evidence for relevant biomass-degrading bacteria being ubiquitous at the times of coal/oil formation. A more plausible theory imo is that geological conditions in the paleozoec/mesozoeic era lent themselves to greater fossil fuel formation - greater tectonic activity alone would produce the flooding and interment processes necessary to push significant volumes of biomass down to fuel the process.
- lmilcin 5y agoFor a significant mass of biomass to be pushed down it first needs to be present. Have you ever been in a coal mine? Coal deposits can be very thick and can consist of practically pure coal with very little anything else. Our densest forests if suddenly "pushed" (I guess covered by ash or anything else, without loosing carbon) would be millimeters in width.
- yxhuvud 5y agoSo why can't peat deposits turn into coal under the right conditions? Those form all the time under certain conditions, but they can sequester a fair amount of biomass.
- dredmorbius 5y agoAFAIU they can, but it takes a very long time, as well as depth, pressure, and temperature. (Not my area of expertise.)
- FooHentai 5y agoI'm unclear on how this supports a theory of pre-bacterial formation. Yes I've been in a coal mine. What a strange stat check.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThere's a fairly large amount of biomass that does get sequestered. Bogs, swamps, and tundra are particularly prone to this, and peat is effectively a low-grade coal (it played a major role in the development of Holland as well). There is a huge amount of sequestered carbon in such landforms. I don't know how that compares with primordial carbon formations. One factor that seems to have been significant in the formation of the coal belt that runs from the present-day Czech republic through Germany, France, northern Spain, England, and the Apallachians is that this was a region of forest and/or swampland adjacent to mountains (the Appalachians, which are literally older than dirt), with the swamps sinking rapidly into a shallow seabed. That may also have played a major role in depriving the biomass of oxygen which would permit it to rot. My own rampant speculation: even given decomposers capable of breaking down woody plant tissue, it's possible that these were insufficiently numerous, or inefficient, or otherwise limited, in ways that aren't currently relevant, such that decomposition is more efficient and rapid today. Interesting questions. Unlikely to be answered by any of us here soon.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe values from Dukes's paper are illuminating. - The fossil fuels burned in a year represent about 400 years' worth of accumulated ancient biomass. That is, you'd need to capture all the biomass grown for four centuries to give the fuel we consume in one year. - But conversion and preservation aren't perfect. So it took five million years to form just the oil we consume annually (or did in 1997, though values have remained reasonably constant since). That is, only about 0.008% of ancient biomass was stored as petroleum. I don't know the figures for carbon-cycle sequester and release rates, though at best we're looking at centuries to remove what we've put into the atmosphere in decades, if not longer.
- pfdietz 5y agoCO2 is mostly sequestered by reaction to form carbonates, not by reduction to biomass, but yes it will take a long time. In the intermediate it will dissolve into the deep ocean (mostly), but even that takes a while.
- dredmorbius 5y agoBy chemical / geological processes, or as organic limestone (mostly shellfish / plankton skeleton) deposits?
- pfdietz 5y agoBoth? The calcium to make the limestone has to come from somewhere.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI'd consider that biological origin, if not primarily then through an obligate mechanism.
- zozbot234 5y agoThis reaction can also be accelerated by crushing basalts and other readily-available rocks to a fine sand/dust, and exposing that to the open air by spreading it over large areas of ground, such as fields or beaches. The process is not cheaper than other kinds of carbon sequestration, but it's definitely comparable and long-term sequestration of the carbon seems especially likely, since we're simply enhancing the existing geological carbon cycle.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- creddit 5y agoAlso worth to point out Earthly life existed for millions of years with that CO2 unsequestered ;)
- manachar 5y agoIs it really worth pointing this out? Why? This is (mostly) a non-sequitur to any modern discussion about climate, the atmosphere, and its effects on human life and civilization. Life, at this point is used to a particular equilibrium. Sure, life has existed at different equilibriums. But we also know when those equilibriums are massively disturbed (via a great oxygenation event, massive asteroid, major volcanic eruptions, etc.) much of the life dies out (obviously depends on the intensity of the disruption) and it takes many years for life to adjust to and make a new equilibrium. Humanity should be deeply concerned with how deeply we have disrupted the equilibrium, as this disrupts the world and biosphere that sustains us. It might be useful if you're building an argument that humanity will be better off after the current mass extinction event is over. However, I tend to find this point more often leads to a George Carlin-esque cynicism and nihilism about earth being better off without humans (or human civilization) anyways.
- zzzeek 5y agoit needs to be turned into a flashy webpage with lots of JS animation. pretty tough to get lots of traffic on a pdf file.
- irrational 5y agoI’m on a phone and I simply can’t read it.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI can see that as a factor. Do you not have a desktop / laptop on which you could read the article later?
- irrational 5y agoI do, but I’m not going to go get it out just to read a pdf. It needs to be mobile responsive if there is a desire for people to read it on the devices they probably are usually on.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThanks. Just my own view, but I find that highly-recommended PDFs are often vastly more worthwhile reading than much of what is easily found in HTML format. My preferred platform is generally an e-ink reader or tablet. At 8" or larger, they're quite good for reading most print-oriented material. My own is a 13.3" Onyx device, and I'm loving it. They're much better for reading, and tend to reduce distractions.
- umvi 5y agoHow do we know oil doesn't bubble up from the Earth's mantle? As far as I know, the mantle has a vast supply of carbon and water, and under the high temperatures and pressures of the mantle could form hydrocarbons that bubble up into the crust
- dredmorbius 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28106291 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28106291 TL;DR: coal, oil, and gas and/or the strata in which they form contain fossils and chemical signatures of ancient plant life, and are found in zones (ancient marshes/forests for coal, ancient shallow seabeds for oil) which correspond to a biotic rather than abiotic origin. The mantle exists at depths too great for fuel formation --- the materials would be broken down at the temperatures and pressures found. Kerogenesis is depth-limited on the same basis.
- throwawaysea 5y agoThanks for the link to the previous discussion. Looking at the numbers in there, I don’t see how this conversation isn’t about overpopulation. We need such massive equivalents of land because there are too many of us, and we value living high quality lives (high standards of living with substantial consumption). The alternative is that everyone lives very constrained lives but I don’t think that is feasible or even desirable.