2 ms·
Yes these are expressly libertarian outfits. Liberty is a good thing! Also, the Koch Brothers fund a lot of things, including criminal justice reform: https://w
by rayiner 5y ago
Yes these are expressly libertarian outfits. Liberty is a good thing! Also, the Koch Brothers fund a lot of things, including criminal justice reform: https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/03/charles-koch-overcriminalization-115512 https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/03/charles-koch...
- tptacek 5y agoWait wait wait wait wait wait, Rayiner. Liberty is a good thing. It does not follow axiomatically that libertarianism is a good thing. Libertarianism has a quirky and unpopular orthodoxy, one that equates drivers licenses to "a license to make toast in your own damn toaster", and creates utopian New Hampshire townships that are ultimately overrun by bears. Give me liberty, as the saying goes, but also drivers licenses, and hold the bears. Libertarianism isn't bad on spec. But it is not reasonable to suggest that people shouldn't be made aware when their sources are all libertarian, as these ones are, for the same reason that it's good to know if your sources are Jacobin, Current Affairs, and In These Times.
- R0b0t1 5y agoThe same reason the ACLU challenges the no-fly list also serves to challenge driver's licenses, and actually exposes that we are accepting very strong prior restraint on the right to travel. You can keep people from driving, but not proactively. Some other arguments though, yes, they go too far.
- tptacek 5y agoI'm not even saying Libertarians are wrong about drivers licenses, just that they're idiosyncratic and unpopular on that issue, and it's worth knowing what you're getting yourself into if you take their word for everything. I think Reason is generally pretty sane! (But they were idiosyncratic and unpopular on the opiate crisis, by way of example.)
- seibelj 5y agoThe drivers license, “but who will pave the roads?!” criticism of libertarians is the laziest, no-thought method and shows you have no interest in rational discussion. It’s like if someone is a Democrat and I immediately accuse them of wanting to seize the means of production. Not every libertarian believes in the most extreme viewpoints of the ideology. Some very basic shrinking of the ever-expanding state would be a fine start. The privatization of the roads could come after we stop increasing our debt by tens of trillions of dollars.
- tptacek 5y agoI didn't say anything about "who will pave the roads", you did. But I mean, there's a reason that keeps coming up! Regarding seizing the means of production: see my previous comment, where I said that is indeed an ideology you'd want to be aware of.
- rayiner 5y agoSure, insofar as we’re also willing to go around saying “liberal newspaper the New York Times says, …”
- tptacek 5y agoWe do that incessantly!
- cloudfifty 5y ago> Libertarianism isn't bad on spec How is it not? It's deeply anti-democratic, basically handing over power to corporations and wealthy people. It's not like its biggest proponents are advocating "a great reset" where all people will start at zero property again or something, it's just a power grab for the already propertied.
- tptacek 5y agoSince I'm not a Libertarian, I'm the wrong person to ask to mount a defense of it.
- cloudfifty 5y agoAlright. I'm just annoyed that such obviously reactionary stuff get the benefit of the doubt constantly, and to add insult do injury, call it freedom.