3 ms·
To "organize the world's information and make it universally accessible and useful" sounds like a great mission to me. Unfortunately the "universally accessibl
by musicale 5y ago
To "organize the world's information and make it universally accessible and useful" sounds like a great mission to me.
Unfortunately the "universally accessible" part seems to be incompatible with current copyright law, so amazing resources like the Google Library Project are reduced to a glorified card catalog/search index rather than an actual online library.
Unlike Google, Sci-hub has so far managed to evade copyright law, so it can fulfill more of the "universal access" part.
- dredmorbius 5y agoGoogle's been stymied by copyright. The Internet Archive and Open Library ... to a much greater degree ... have not. And much of the material there is the result of Google scans. I still prefer unencumbered sources (LibGen, ZLibrary, Sci-Hub), but at least having the option of access through the Archive is helpful. Reading books on my own device with local optimsed software remains superior to Archive.org's Bookreader, though the latter is pretty darned good.
- repsilat 5y agoI agree, but would add -- five years ago "Google has been stymied by copyright" was most of the story for them, but today "Google is subject to political pressure to exercise editorial control" (to put it charitably) is as important. Not to diminish the disappointment over Google Books being curtailed (Google actually went to court for it!), or DMCA takedowns on Youtube or Google Search results. But we also have to admit that today Youtube is exercising editorial control to ban opinions they don't like, and that Google Cloud is as quick to drop "the wrong kinds of customers" as the payment processors everyone was complaining about ten years ago. Maybe "getting ahead of the censors" minimises the damage, maybe it encourages the censors. I don't know. I guess the company is run by smart people who want to make as much money as possible in the long term, so it's likely good for consumers on net. That said, it's a shame we don't see them fighting for those principles today.
- musicale 5y ago> Internet Archive and Open Library ... to a much greater degree ... have not. And much of the material there is the result of Google scans Are Google scans really in the Open Library? If so, that's very interesting. The Open Library does seem to be operating under the shadow of copyright law, since it deployed DRM that attempts to eliminate some of the innate properties (unlimited readers, instant free copying and distribution, etc.) of ebooks, presumably to avoid copyright claims - and then got in trouble for reducing those restrictions briefly during a global pandemic.