3 ms·
Solar geoengineering is unproven technology; is there even any estimate on how much it will cost and how long it may take? Lots of things can be done. Most of
by pjc50 5y ago
Solar geoengineering is unproven technology; is there even any estimate on how much it will cost and how long it may take?
Lots of things can be done. Most of them won't. People prefer denial - not everyone, but enough to sabotage progress. The pandemic has made this abundantly clear.
- alexose 5y agoIt's generally agreed to be highly cost effective. Via Wikipedia: > The annual cost of delivering 5 million tons of an albedo enhancing aerosol (sufficient to offset the expected warming over the next century) to an altitude of 20 to 30 km is estimated at US$2 billion to 8 billion. In comparison, the annual cost estimates for climate damage or emission mitigation range from US$200 billion to 2 trillion.
- pjc50 5y ago> delivering 5 million tons of an albedo enhancing aerosol (sufficient to offset the expected warming over the next century) to an altitude of 20 to 30 km ... How much CO2 is that going to emit? Is that achieved by aircraft or rockets?
- mc32 5y agoRail cannons?
- pjc50 5y agoAnother experimental technology! How many MJ/tonne does that take? How many sites do you need? How many more nuclear plants does it take running continuously to manufacture and launch all this? Who pays for this? How do you persuade them? How do you protect it from getting cut by the denialism faction as soon as they get elected?
- hnthrowaway9721 5y agoWhat exactly is your point? Things are difficult, let’s not bother doing anything at all? Just let the world burn?
- wongarsu 5y agoIf you deliver it by aircraft, that's about 40000 flights per year (assuming you use Boeing 747-400 or comparable). That sounds like a lot, but right now there are 10000 aircraft in the air, adding 40k flights a year isn't going to throw the numbers off. The bigger issue is that aerosol delays the "warming" issue, but doesn't stop ocean acidification (in addition to the issue of what happens if we ever stop for whatever reason)
- cryptoz 5y agoThe cost is not the issue most people have a problem with; it's the general idea of geoengineering without (much) regard for unknown side effects. Also, geoengineering without fixing the root cause is backwards and risky. Reducing emissions is the best thing we can do and this process is actively sabotaged by the right-wing politicians and media. If reducing emissions is such a hard sell, geoengineering will be even more difficult to do. Increase taxes on the wealthy, use the money to improve inequality and pass legislation that heavily taxes or bans pollutants at the corporate level. Guarantee long jail time for leaders caught cheating the system. None of the climate change problems that exist are technologically hard to solve. We have solved much harder IMO. The problems are all political and denial-based. Removing the denial would go much further than any particular technological solution will.
- klipt 5y ago> Reducing emissions is the best thing we can do Too little too late. The system is already moving out of its old equilibrium. Simply stopping emissions won't fix it now.
- dylan604 5y agoNo, but if you never stop emitting, you'll never have a chance.
- jacquesm 5y agoYou'll need to do better than just stopping emitting, you will have to undo some of the damage to have a chance to get back to equilibrium, all else is just a - relatively short - stay of execution. The last 200 years has seen humanity reverse a climate trend that held for many millions of years and yet there are still people that believe - strongly - that this is all just coincidence.
- dylan604 5y agoI'm re-reading my comment, and trying to see how could you construe I'm advocating for only stopping. To make it clear, I'm simply stating that if you only work on something to "reverse" or "clean" you will not be successful UNTIL WE STOP EMITTING. (emphasis, not yelling). So until we stop emitting, it's spinning wheels with no forward progress.
- jacquesm 5y agoPreparing for and dealing with something like COVID would have been highly cost effective as well. And yet, here we are. Climate change is a lot harder on the scale of problems to deal with.
- SantalBlush 5y ago>The pandemic has made this abundantly clear. In an ideal world, everyone in every country would have coordinated and stayed inside for a month while the virus died out. Now, just because the ideal measure wasn't taken, folks pretend we're experiencing the worst possible outcome from COVID. This has been far from the worst possible outcome. Let's stop acting like our response to the pandemic was a complete failure when it simply wasn't.
- jacquesm 5y agoCOVID isn't over by a long shot, we're smack in the middle of it - if we're lucky and this is the half way point -, if we're unlucky this is just the start. Of course we should do what we can. But if this is far from the worst possible outcome, imagine the relative complexity of scale between a virus jumping species and trying to undo 200 odd years of runaway emissions and the effect on our climate in the next couple of decades and gain some appreciation for the change in scale and intensity of cooperation required to achieve a meaningful difference. Optimism is a great thing to have, but let's not delude ourselves: humanity is in for a very rough ride, and there is absolutely no indication of how - or even if - we will weather this. HN is supposedly one of the smarter fora on the net, and yet, every day we are overrun by conspiracy nuts, people have been shouting down the ongoing pandemic since day one - and merrily continue to do so day by day. Forgive me if I'm not all that optimistic about how we are going to deal with something far harder.
- SantalBlush 5y agoI'm not looking at the number of comments from conspiracy nuts as a measure of success or failure, I'm looking at the confirmed case counts and death counts. Considering how pernicious this virus is, our prevention efforts have not been a complete failure. The death count could easily be an order of magnitude higher today. That's not blind optimism for the future, that's the reality of the present.
- jacquesm 5y agoYou need to add one giant qualifier there: 'in the developed world'. So far what we've managed to achieve is to stave of the worst at the expense of ruining our economy and now having to deal with a whole pile of new and nastier variations. You can't really say anything about the outcome of a fire until the fire is under control, right now we may have the illusion of control but I don't believe that we are there just yet.