3 ms·
Looking at Provincetown, it's far from obvious that this is what happened. It seems more likely that a lot of vaccinated people got the virus in close proximity
by noduerme 5y ago
Looking at Provincetown, it's far from obvious that this is what happened. It seems more likely that a lot of vaccinated people got the virus in close proximity to unvaccinated people, but the chain of transmission mostly stopped there. Numbers in Provincetown have fallen and there were no reports of major outbreaks when vaccinated people returned home. So it would seem like you could have vaccinated-to-unvaccinated spread in some cases, but vaxed-to-vaxed is multiples less likely.
With the large majority of the world still unvaccinated, and most spread (apparently) curtailed between vaccinated individuals, the evolutionary pressure on the virus will still be toward longer incubation and less lethality. Perhaps if we ever reach a point of worldwide herd immunity by vaccination, and still have large scale circulation of the virus among the vaccinated, we'd be looking at a different evolutionary drift. But it's also worth noting that the relevant mutations in Covid-19 are on the spike protein, and there aren't so many configurations, only a few hundred; it's likely that all possible configurations have already been "tried", and are currently competing in the wild.
- __blockcipher__ 5y ago> Numbers in Provincetown have fallen and there were no reports of major outbreaks when vaccinated people returned home. So it would seem like you could have vaccinated-to-unvaccinated spread in some cases, but vaxed-to-vaxed is multiples less likely. I think time will show this to be false. A shockingly high number of the vaccinated have actually already had COVID (some of them explicitly knew they had it yet chose to get vaccinated anyway, sometimes at the advice of their doctors, which is horrifying to me insofar as it reveals fundamental ignorance about natural immunity), but of those who haven't been exposed to real SARS-2, a strain capable of readily infecting them will just as easily pass to their vaccinated friend, given the "strategy" of the virus is to acquire point mutations on the S2 subunit that render the vaccines (which protect ONLY against the spike protein) ineffective
- loopz 5y agoReport show that vaccine may provide broader defense though: https://www.nih.gov/how-immunity-generated-covid-19-vaccines-differs-infection https://www.nih.gov/how-immunity-generated-covid-19-vaccines...
- shock 5y ago> Looking at Provincetown, it's far from obvious that this is what happened. It seems more likely that a lot of vaccinated people got the virus in close proximity to unvaccinated people, but the chain of transmission mostly stopped there. That doesn't seem to be the case in Gibraltar. There is a ~100% vaccination rate there and an increased number of infections recently.
- noduerme 5y agoGibraltar has an open border with Spain, which is nowhere near fully vaccinated. They've had an uptick (a few hundred cases since April, though almost no deaths). It seems rational to think that most of those cases among the vaccinated were brought there by unvaccinated people from Spain, and are not running wild in vax-to-vax chains of transmission. The only "news" pieces I could find about Gibraltar having some massive surge were from hardcore antivax websites - the top one was something called welovetrump.
- shock 5y agoI did not say there was a "massive surge" of cases in Gibraltar. With regards to the open borders, most of the EEA has open borders, Gibraltar is not special in that regard.