3 ms·
dont miss the bit on "remotely beamed microwave power." "silly idea" it may be but now i want a mega-maser as described for my own sporting purposes.
by h2odragon 5y ago
dont miss the bit on "remotely beamed microwave power."
"silly idea" it may be but now i want a mega-maser as described for my own sporting purposes.
- hereforphone 5y agoDo they expect to outdo the sun?
- h2odragon 5y agoIn one very specific frequency band, at one comparatively small place, yes. by a large amount. Ocean vs firehose. Or, better: In the same way every "daytime headlight" you see is outdoing the sun.
- hereforphone 5y agoWhich 'frequency band'? https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Spectral-power-density-of-solar-radiation-5_fig1_268822609 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Spectral-power-density-o...
- rrss 5y agomicrowave
- hereforphone 5y agoBrilliant answer
- h2odragon 5y ago> Achieving a beam that narrow (1/2000000 rad) from the Earth would require a phased array spaced out over a much larger area, at least 200 km at 5 Ghz (6cm). I doubt they'd want a very large band but in microwave work I dunno what counts as "large". and i'm a little afraid to go look deeper into this because i'll wind up tearing up junkyard microwave ovens and building something i shouldn't.
- hereforphone 5y agoThe headlight vs. sun comparison (which I think was an edit?) is irrelevant because we're comparing the amount of energy deliverable over distance. The energy delivered by the sun (at a tenable band) vs. the energy delivered by the remote transmitter on earth, after the 'link budget' has been applied (taking into account distance, atmospheric attenuation, and so on) are the two things that need to be compared.
- h2odragon 5y agoI beg you pardon, im not arguing for the idea of a earth to moon microwave power link as viable. or sensible. I think it's beautifully insane, i have severe doubts about the actual practicality of such a thing, etc. But thats the thing: now i want to do a mad max maser on a truck with maybe dozens of magnetrons if i could tow a generator... It fits with my "Orbital Slingshot" project so well, too.
- hereforphone 5y agoWhat is your Orbital Slingshot project?
- h2odragon 5y agoI'm glad you asked :) It's a totally silly idea to built a big ass slingshot that throws things as high as possible. I figure calling it an "Orbital Slingshot" makes it at least as viable and investment worthy as some of the other efforts [1] and [2] forex. If I can get my daughter to do some artwork I might fire up a web page for it finally. [1] https://www.space.com/23015-slingatron-reusable-launch-system.html https://www.space.com/23015-slingatron-reusable-launch-syste... [2] https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2018/02/spinlaunch-is-using-large-centrifuges-to-accelerate-to-payloads-into-space-target-500000-per-launch.html https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2018/02/spinlaunch-is-using-la...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jhgb 5y agoThe one that the receiver is the most sensitive to. The fact that sunlight comprises many wavelengths is the reason why single-junction cells have comparatively low efficiency.
- MCllorf 5y agoI'm not trained in STEM at all but these discussions are always a little confusing for me because if our goal is to bootstrap mining/manufacturing in space, why does everyone jump to expensive, complicated and inefficient solutions like "energy lasers" when we've had power lines for like 150 years and can make them on-site much more easily?
- Uke 5y agoit might be a weight constrain?
- jdavis703 5y agoThis question is answered in the article and I guarantee you, most STEM specialities will never discuss this particular problem. Anyways, the TL;DR is all those cables weigh a lot, so launching them in to space isn’t cheap.
- whatshisface 5y agoWell, cables are going to be cheaper at some distance and power beaming will be cheaper at a greater distance, and the question is, where's the crossover.
- h2odragon 5y agoLook at the efficiency numbers on contact free charging pads. "Beaming" fails for power transmission immediately; it needs other factors to justify the efficiency hit; and once you're out of near field its much much worse.
- gpm 5y agoMicrowave transmission of power hits 70 or 80% efficiency http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2011/ph240/shu2/ http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2011/ph240/shu2/ What you're seeing with phones isn't microwave, but inductance, very different technology with very different benefits/drawbacks.
- wongarsu 5y ago
- extrapickles 5y agoIts probably more realistic to put a few satellites in orbit of the moon and beam power from them. This keeps the distances down so the transmitter and receivers can be more reasonably sized. If you also switch to laser power beaming, they can illuminate the existing solar farm so a separate receiver is not needed.
- h2odragon 5y agoI'm totally in favor of any plan that has multiple megawatt SPACE LASERS as part of it, yes.
- coatdoor 5y agoWouldn't you just use earthlight and normal solar panels? The internet says moonlight is 1/345th the power of sunlight but once you factor in Earth's larger radius and larger albedo you get 1/9th the power of sunlight. IE you just use 10 times as many solar panels to get you through the night.
- jhgb 5y ago> The internet says moonlight is 1/345th the power of sunlight but once you factor in Earth's larger radius and larger albedo you get 1/9th the power of sunlight. That sounds weird. As per Wikipedia, Sun's apparent magnitude is around -26.7, full Moon's is -12.7, so the Sun is 400000 times brighter than the Moon under the best circumstances. Earth being larger can't correct this by three orders of magnitude.
- lovemenot 5y agoEven if you are off by orders of magnitude, there may still be a useful thought in here. Find a large symmetrical crater pointing directly at Earth. Silver its surface with very cheap to transport BoPET (Mylar). Once installed, there's no need to worry about the sheets flying off or dust blowing over since there is no wind. Place a solar / thermal collector at the crater's focal point. Reap power from earth-light. If you choose a large crater, an MVP system can go live with just a small collector and small portion of the crater silvered. It can subsequently scale as your growing operations demand more power. It can do double-duty in broadcast communications too.
- shkkmo 5y agoYou won't ever be able to concentrate eartlight enough to start a fire... I doubt that you can get any real power generation from such a system.
- lovemenot 5y agoWe don't need the heat for fire. Maybe for comfort though. The moon gets mighty cold at night. Its temperature range is about 80 to 370 Kelvin. You could use the same kit to radiate away some of that intense daytime heat too. Spread it across all of Earth. Now as to solar PV, in principle it might be doable I guess. But I am not able to make the necessary calculations. How large would the crater need to be for 10MW say? Even as a heat engine, you might get useful power out. If you could achieve say 150 - 200 celsius difference between your concentrator and night time temperature of the surrounding rocks. Which rocks serve as both the engine's heat-sink and a relatively comfy foundation for your habitat.