3 ms·
I know people who have wasted resources on useless masters degrees, usually from for-profit schools who offer little learning and a credential with little value
by wolverine876 5y ago
I know people who have wasted resources on useless masters degrees, usually from for-profit schools who offer little learning and a credential with little value. I don't doubt there's a problem.
But I think there's a grave error in the framing of the issue, which is to measure degrees by only the latter, earnings, and not by the former, learning.
It hands over to the markets, and those who have influence in markets, the power to decide what is worth learning. While I think markets are powerful tools, we need to view them with a grain of salt - i.e., critically, the way we learn to examine things in school: they are distorted in reality (i.e., they are not theoretical ideal markets, some very far from it), and they yield many odd results. As one example, professional athletes, even those who never see the field, usually earn more than doctors and nurses saving lives, or more than the diplomatic and military leaders who are responsible for world peace and security, or more than the scientists discovering new states of matter. Wall Street employees make more than every teacher. Etc.
Our markets as they are don't reward arts, the study of history, the promotion of many social goods, basic science research, open source software, engineering privacy rights, any service to people who are poor and don't provide much revenue. That doesn't define the value of those things, or of learning those things.
It's entangled with market-based education, which requires schools to focus resources on revenue rather than on education. Again, it hands power to the markets, and to those who have influence in markets. It leads to schools investing in upgrading dorms or football programs, which attract wealthy people, rather than scholarships and assets that provide a return in education, not revenue. And it leads to useless masters degrees, but I certainly wouldn't include in that category a degree in film from Columbia, no matter how much the future earnings of the student (though market-based pricing certainly makes it too expensive).
- x86_64Ubuntu 5y agoYou're citing that looking at earnings from different fields as the place the "market" doesn't belong. If the market has no place in labor compensation, the where does the market belong?
- wolverine876 5y ago> You're citing that looking at earnings from different fields as the place the "market" doesn't belong. If the market has no place in labor compensation, the where does the market belong? I'm not sure what you are interpreting from my post, or what your first sentence means, but I will try to answer: The 'market', such as it is, determines earnings. It is deeply flawed but please don't take that to a logical extreme, that the market has "no place". For very many things, I think markets are the best solution; they are also 'free', as in freedom - not constraining individual's rights to act as they wish. I am not an economist. My guess is that reducing distortions in the market mechanism might do wonders, particularly the distortion of imbalanced market power. For example, a single large employer has much greater power than a single employee, and thus has great leverage over them that doesn't yield economic outcomes. Also, some things are not well served by market pricing. For example, the market serves those most motivated to pay, which is good, but also those most able to pay. Health care and education should not be distributed based on ability to pay. Another example is that the market serves work that is directly profitable. Some things don't generate profit or not quickly enough, such as basic scientific research.