5 ms·
I actually view this as not a good sign. That many are still in the very very early stage of shock, what Apple is doing does not align with their perceived valu
by ksec 5y ago
I actually view this as not a good sign. That many are still in the very very early stage of shock, what Apple is doing does not align with their perceived values. Deducting points from Apple in their own mental model. They write these letter because they think Apple is still mostly good and hope they could have a change of heart.
What would happen as some others have pointed out, people will forget about it. Apple will bump out decent Mac products line, along with very good iPhone hardware in a few months time. Which will add points back to their mental model.
"May be Apple is really doing it in good faith"
"They aren't so bad, let's wait and see."
Apple's marketing and PR have changed in the past 5 - 6 years. My guess is their KPI had changed. And they will ( successfully ) white wash any doubt you have. And 2022 Q1 results ( That is the iPhone 13 launch quarter ) will be record breaking again.
And that is not even including competition. I mean for pete sake is Microsoft or Google even trying to compete? ( I give credit to their Surface Laptop and Pixel team, but still far from enough )
- busymom0 5y agoFair point and you are probably right. However, this is getting them a ton of bad press from pretty major players in the privacy world (Edward Snowden for example). This has high chances of a lot of people abandoning Apple products (I'll no longer purchase new apple products and already switching over to de-googled Android). Privacy is obviously just a marketing play by Apple but this time, they can't hide it and it might actually hurt their bottom line.
- parasubvert 5y agoI actually expect most to support Apple’s approach here. But it is early.
- fsflover 5y ago> I mean for pete sake is Microsoft or Google even trying to compete? Forget the evil monopolies. Consider GNU/Linux phones, Librem 5 and Pinehone. They may not be ready for an average user, but the HN audience can take advantage of them and help their develoment.
- nix23 5y agoI would love a phone based on the ideas from Plan9.
- bborud 5y agoWould you? How often do you come into contact with the OS when developing for a phone, let alone use a phone? Phones are products for people who use them. What sells phones is not what OS is underneath layers and layers of code, but user experience. If we are to even hope for alternatives, this is where the focus needs to be. If the OS underneath mattered the Nokia Communicator would have been a runaway success. It wasn’t. It was a useless brick of a computer that almost couldn’t do anything compared to even the first generations of smart phones from Apple and Google.
- nix23 5y ago>How often do you come into contact with the OS when developing for a phone, let alone use a phone That's exactly the point, Maybe you don't know what Plan9 is, but see it like that: The Phone is just a Terminal. If i want todo business i connect my terminal to my Workplace-servers, every application, datas and settings are there, the calculation heavy stuff and backup is made on the server. If finished i connect to my private plan9-cluster, the Phone is just a bit more than a intelligent Terminal. The difference is with a plan9 phone you would ~never have anything todo with software ON the phone, let alone having to worry to "sync" to the cloud to make backups, update Apps or need to encrypt the datas in case of loss. It's a bit like Cloud-gaming or Virtual Desktops with thin-clients, but much much more integrated.
- theptip 5y agoSlightly problematic when your phone loses service, but I get where you are coming from. It would be nice for that to be viable, we’re probably decades away from having good enough network connectivity.
- 5y ago
- nicce 5y agoIt might be hard to understand, but iOS is a blackbox. Based on what they add and say, we still don't know what exactly is happening. All we have is trust. We can speculate that with "what ifs", but same "if" is applying already. Once we take other big platforms on account, Apple is actually trying to note privacy. Other platforms just scan everything you put in cloud, but Apple tries to limit the information what they acquire, by scanning it on device. And based on their specification, they scan locally only what is going into the cloud. It took me a while to realize, but this is improvement for what has been happening in the industry for years already.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoThis is an interesting point. I think you might be right.
- sanjiwatsuki 5y agoIIRC, Apple was already scanning iCloud server-side for CSAM [0] so I'm not sure if that excuse holds. [0] https://www.macobserver.com/analysis/apple-scans-uploaded-content/ https://www.macobserver.com/analysis/apple-scans-uploaded-co...
- nicce 5y agoThey did not scan everything. Only suspected ones, this expands scope to everyone by default. But this is still improvement. We might see followup as added E2EE services which was not possible before.
- croutonwagon 5y agoSo are they only scanning things you specifically upload to iCloud, aka if you disable iCloud and photo syncing you are fine. Or does that include ancillary data like images in iMessage chats (even if you have iCloud data basically shut off) I read the scans were done on device but prior to upload. Just unclear what that really means to me.
- walshemj 5y agoDepends Apple is on my "call first list now" on my CV along with Chem and Bio weapons and payday loan type companies. And I wont be buying the ipad I was thinking about.