16 ms·
What do you do with a billion grams of surplus weed?
- codevark 5y agoWhich is why there should never be a "cannabis industry". We created a food industry that produces sub-standard food and much of it goes to waste. Applying the same obviously flawed principles to cannabis is another mistake. Pot should be legal to grow/possess/use, but not to buy or sell. There's no point. It's so easy to grow. Just plant some in your backyard and smoke it. Or give it away. That's what it's for.
- QuercusMax 5y agoThere needs to be SOME kind of market. Not everybody has the time, space, inclination, or knowhow to do a good job of cultivation, and not everybody has friends who grow. You could make exactly the same arguments about alcohol. I'm an enthusiastic homebrewer, but I wouldn't say that everybody should brew their own.
- standardUser 5y agoI don't have a backyard.
- newsclues 5y agoProcess it into commodity cannabis compounds (THC, CDB, etc) and lower the prices to fair and reasonable. The Canadian cannabis market is regulated by idiots for the benefit of companies, and the consumers are taken advantage of.
- mandmandam 5y agoIt seems that they've managed to set things up in such a way that it's actually more profitable to destroy the cannabis than process it. Reminds me of the neoliberal take on housing and healthcare.
- fuzzfactor 5y agoNot just housing but even more so commercial and industrial facilities where property taxes give great incentive for scorched-earth demolition in response to only nominal downturns in occupancy or utilization. Always with less than one-year deadlines before reassessment since these are recurring taxes, one of their most destructive features. Regardless of how many nearby citizens are homeless, jobless, and/or capable of operating a prosperous small cannabis farm if they could freely grow & sell their fresh product at the local farmers' market with no different regulation or taxes than the other crops.
- shawnz 5y agoOne problem with processing it is that there are very low limits on dosages of edibles in Canada (currently 10mg THC per serving). I think lifting this absurd restriction would help enable those ideas. See here https://www.change.org/p/remove-the-10mg-thc-limit-on-edible-cannabis https://www.change.org/p/remove-the-10mg-thc-limit-on-edible...
- mandmandam 5y agoSo wait, they're holding (and destroying!) massive quantities to keep the price of medical marijuana "34% higher" than the black market price, then acting surprised that their product isn't moving? > Forced, in most cases, to sell to a provincial wholesaler along with everyone else in the sector Okay I know nothing about Canada's cannabis market, but who thought that could possibly be a good idea?
- jacquesm 5y agoCanada has a ton of such cartels, the egg board, the milk board, the LCBO and so on.
- monkeybutton 5y agoMaple syrup too! https://www.vpr.org/vpr-news/2018-03-08/quebecs-legal-maple-syrup-cartel-dictates-prices-for-vermont-maple-producers https://www.vpr.org/vpr-news/2018-03-08/quebecs-legal-maple-...
- joncp 5y agoDon't mess with those guys.
- Spooky23 5y agoOnions too. They used some trade negotiations to put a northeast US farmers out of business for certain onions, which now sell for retail at less than production price.
- WhyNotHugo 5y agoThis is really the worst kind of shit. Destroy food so they can charge more, while so many starving people could use that food. I've heard it a million times, but it'll never stop shocking me to here about this idea: Keeping market value up is more important than reducing starvation.
- gruez 5y ago
- staticassertion 5y agoWeed being legal is cool (and a huge deal and way overdue) but, until I moved to SF, I still bought from a dealer. It was cheaper and I got really high quality stuff, got to give feedback to the guy on the strains, chocolates, etc. Plus my guy would smoke me up for free a good amount of the time and we'd just chill and chat for a bit. Legal weed is wayyyy more expensive in my experience and I dislike the experience. I went to an SF dispensary and it was so odd - had to give them an ID, sit there and fiddle with some ipad, etc. Presumably there's a lot of overhead with taxes, employees, property, etc. And apparently artificially keeping prices high... Also a somewhat damning case of "we have no idea how to value this" I don't really smoke anymore, no time, but it was enough of a difference that the novelty of cutesy edibles wore off fairly quickly.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- blamazon 5y agoOnce you learn the system, dispensaries are very convenient. At practically every location you can peruse the menu and place an order ahead of time. Then, at the dispensary, show ID, receive selected cannabis products.
- WhyNotHugo 5y agoHere in the Netherlands tax for weed is really high. 50% if I recall correctly. Not sure I hate the idea -- at least tax money is put to very good use. But for those for whom it's more than merely recreational (e.g.: medicinal use), I wish they'd sell a tax-free version. Too prone to abuse I guess. However, heading to a coffeshop[1] isn't a big deal. It's a person behind the stand, you pic what you want from a menu, and they hand it over. Very nice and friendly, not dissimilar to ordering at a cafe. I don't look under 25, and they've NEVER asked me for an id at any of these places. It surprised me in the US that even to sell alcohol to someone clearly over 40, they still ask for an id. [1]: Stores that sell weed here are called "coffeeshops".
- remirk 5y agoI'm not sure on the 50%. I didn't even know there was a separate tax. It seems unlikely to me as weed is still 'illegal'. The police won't look your way if you use it or sell it in shops. But everything that happens before the shop (growing and transport) is still very much illegal and you will get a big fine if you get caught. You are only allowed to have 5 grams or a small amount of plants. The government together with a few selected municipalities is starting an experiment to grow it in selected growing facilities. As far as I know no municipality has started selling those yet.
- codetrotter 5y agoA billion grams. A million kilograms. A thousand tonnes. …one kilotonne?
- _Microft 5y agoIsn’t that as much weed as the Dark Lord smoked per hour? Edit: english subtitles say „hundreds“ while it is actually „thousand“ in the German version. ~1 minute into https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DPVKaj9hVcY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DPVKaj9hVcY
- grumple 5y agoA gigagram?
- skripp 5y ago1 gigagram, for us Europeans. ;) Edit: it would most likely be written as one thousand tonnes.
- dluan 5y agoconversely, in europe, do you hit up your dealer for 10 micro tonnes of weed?
- NullPrefix 5y agoA thousand tonnes is ambiguous because you cannot know if it's metric tonnes or not. A billion grams is unambiguous, because a billion prefix for the regular reader would mean pretty much the same as infinity. The 0.0000001 as the multiplier after billion prefix doesn't discount that, because you still have to read the billion out loud.
- Clewza313 5y agoOddly enough, "one billion" can mean different amounts in different countries: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_and_short_scale https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_and_short_scale
- 5y ago
- gedy 5y ago> The business model at that time didn’t demand actual weed sales: selling hype, selling the potential of selling weed, was proving lucrative. That's kind of everything these days.. Tech, stocks markets, housing, etc. is less about fundamentals as it is the "potential".
- h2odragon 5y agoMany planning failures in the field. Last year lots of people planted hemp around me, as it just become legal and there was a small market opening. Very, very few of these people had any notion what it would take to harvest, process and store their crop, and no notion of how or where to market it once in. I've seen multiple Craigslist ads attempting to sell garbage bags of wet, mouldy, untrimmed hemp. I've been told that anyone who has a sales channel has been inundated with "buy my crop" offers. Ive heard one guy had grown and harvested several acres or so and had a couple truckloads in round wrapped bales he was looking to sell. People didn't dive into cotton farming this way, when it became viable in the area again.
- treis 5y agoI did the math on this a few years ago and it came out to be less than 10 farms to supply the entire US with weed. Edit:. Found my post: For comparison, bulk price of tobacco is a few bucks a pound. Admittedly I am not an expert in marijuana vs tobacco cultivation, but I doubt it's 1,000 times more expensive. Ultimately, the problem with profiting in a legal marijuana industry is that people simply don't smoke that much pot. Say that there's 260 million adults in the US and they all smoke 1 joint per day. Assuming: 1 joint = 1 g of marijuana 1 lb = 454g 1 acre can yield 600 lbs of marijuana 1 farm is 1000 acres If you do the math, that means we need roughly 350 farms worth of marijuana. Or in terms of acreage, roughly 0.04% of all the acreage in the U.S. under cultivation. In other words, even if we assume a ridiculous level of smoking there's simply not a huge demand for pot. Using more realistic amounts, a handful of large farms could produce all the marijuana consumed in the country.
- h2odragon 5y agoTobacco is harder to grow and cure than good cannabis. The tobacco industry consolidation bent the market to the point that "tobacco" as sold is the result of a large industrial process that happens to use nicotina plant matter as an input. I think the cannabis industry is flying hellbent to that point just to have an excuse for spending all the investor money. As well as a literal distaste for burning plants as a social thing.
- 5y ago
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> A recent survey conducted by Abacus Data for Medical Cannabis Canada found that those who access medical cannabis legally pay on average 34 percent more for their medicine than if they bought from the unregulated market. I’m unfamiliar with the weed market in general, but it seems like this problem is self-inflicted. They’re simultaneously oversupplied and overpriced. Lower prices and both problems sort themselves out, plus they can slowly out-compete the illegal sellers by undercutting their pricing. It seems the real problem is that they are afraid to cut their margins because it would break their financial models and risk the stock price. It’s strange that they’d rather destroy excess product than try to move it at a steep discount. I’m also afraid this could create other problems by giving them a huge incentive to try to push more and more weed consumption among the public. Whatever your thoughts about weed, I hope we can all agree that over-consumption is not good and that it could be a problem if multi-billion dollar companies are stuck in a situation where they need to greatly increase the public’s consumption of weed to become profitable.
- Closi 5y ago> those who access medical cannabis legally pay on average 34 percent more for their medicine than if they bought from the unregulated market. I mean, that’s true with most things isn’t it? If you buy meat from the dodgy guy in a pub then it’s cheaper. Bloke selling televisions from a van? Cheaper. Cigarettes from a corner store that have been imported from a low tax country? Cheaper. Getting the electric/gas done in your house from someone who is unlicensed? Cheaper. Not sure why we would expect this to be different.
- slapfrog 5y ago> Cigarettes from a corner store that have been imported from a low tax country? Probably just smuggled across state lines. Bought in a state with low taxes, then sold in a state with high taxes. The store pockets the taxes instead of passing them along to the state, which it can do because the cigarettes being sold were smuggled so the high-tax state doesn't have any record of them existing.
- 5y ago
- kevmo 5y agoUnprofitable growers should maybe turn to growing food.
- cushychicken 5y agoAli G always had the best answer to this question: "Why doesn't you give it to charity?"
- latchkey 5y agoThis was easy to predict. Anyone who's been in the industry knows that there is not only not enough demand, but it is also seasonal. Other than the heaviest users, people don't consume 365 days out of the year, they go through phases. If you grow weed year round in high tech facilities that maximize production, you're going to just have massive piles of it that you cannot unload. Making it legal didn't really create that much more demand because it was already easy enough to get in most places where there were enough consumers. I drove through Oregon not too long ago. There is literally miles of weed shops right next door to each other. There are more weed shops than gas stations... and the gas stations usually have one right next door anyway. I have no idea how they all stay in business, but it couldn't be good. Now this is the comparison to tulip mania that kind of works.
- slapfrog 5y ago> There are more weed shops than gas stations... and the gas stations usually have one right next door anyway. In Washington state [or just Seattle? I'm not sure], there are laws restricting how many square feet the signage for a weed store is allowed to have. In response to this, weed stores devised a trick where they buy up neighboring businesses and run them under the same brand name as the weed store, with very large signs. So next to "Bubba's weed store" with small signs, you have "Bubba's Car Wash" with very large signs. Anybody looking for Bubba's weed will see the huge sign for Bubba's car wash, and know they found the right spot.
- latchkey 5y agoIt'll be interesting to see what happens to the secondary business when the primary fails and Bubba realizes he doesn't want to run a car wash...
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y agoI sort of question the framing here? Not yours, but the article's. There is exactly enough demand, because however much people want of a mostly harmless plant is how much people should want of that plant. Nobody turning a profit should be no surprise: farmers barely turn a profit either, because selling commodities is not a means of getting rich quick. Considering how low-risk buying pot was before legalization, it boggles the mind why anyone thought there would be a huge growth in consumption, especially when the legal product is priced so much higher that it might as well still be illegal. As far as why such a low fraction of transactions are in the legal market: the only way to move pot transactions out off the black market would be to either make it substantially as convenient to buy it legally, or to dramatically increase enforcement against black market transactions at the same time that weed was legalized. It seems Canada did neither.
- stef25 5y agoWhat's the advantage of handing out these licenses to companies that will then be run like a Silicon Valley start-up? Why not just allow dispensaries to grow a small amount of their own stuff on premise, say 20Kg / month? Limit each customer to a 5g purchase. You just need a proper space and half a dozen staff (if that). No need for massive investments and all this maxed-out capitalist accounting trickery. Legalisation should put dealers out of business on day 1. There's no way I'm going to engage in criminal activity, texting a dealer and waiting on a street corner if I can just walk over to a bar and buy what I need, super chill like it is in Holland. Unbelievably sad they managed to screw it up so badly.
- voisin 5y agoA bit off topic, but for the smokers here what are your thoughts on lung cancer and other negatives associated with smoking? I bought a vaporizer but not sure it is actually healthier than smoking joints. Tried edibles but can’t stand the lack of uniformity and time to kick in.
- anglicanchurch 5y agoVaping is quite substantially healthier than joints/bongs. You aren't burning the material but baking it at oven temps. I tried to get my stoner buddies into vaping and everyone's switched except the guys that are culturally infected to give up being the "joint smoking guys".
- tayo42 5y agoI switched from bongs to dabs and felt better cardio wise. Live resin extracts are suppsedly pretty minimal in extra stuff. I think the vape oils have a lot of extra crap. I went back to smoking for a bit though I think the dabs are to potent and I was getting panic attacks
- Maursault 5y ago> A bit off topic, but for the smokers here what are your thoughts on lung cancer and other negatives associated with smoking? No one knows if smoking weed causes lung cancer, but if it did, you'd think someone would have noticed sometime in the last 10K years. However, everyone knows that smoking tobacco causes lung cancer. But this notion is technically not true. Smoking national brand cigarettes definitely causes lung cancer because what is in national brand cigarettes is not tobacco. It is about 50% tobacco and 50% additives, and also intentionally includes about 300 added carcinogenic chemicals to increase the addictiveness of nicotine... that is what is causing lung cancer, not natural tobacco. Pipe tobacco is just tobacco, nothing added, and pipe smoking (or rolling cigarettes from pipe tobacco), whether inhaled or not, doesn't cause lung cancer. Tongue cancer? Mouth cancer? Maybe to probably. Emphysema? A surity. Here are a few quotes from the US Surgeon General Report on Smoking and Health[1] No. 1103, p.112: "Death rates for current pipe smokers were little if at all higher than for non-smokers, even with men smoking 10 pipefuls per day and with men who had smoked pipes for more than 30 years." No. 1103, p.92 "Among the pipe smokers.... The US mortality ratios are 0.8 for non-inhalers and 1.0 for inhalers." ...which means pipe smokers who inhale live as long as nonsmokers, and pipe smokers that don’t inhale live longer than non-smokers. [1] https://biotech.law.lsu.edu/cases/tobacco/nnbbmq.pdf https://biotech.law.lsu.edu/cases/tobacco/nnbbmq.pdf
- blacksqr 5y agoDon't bogart it!
- forkLding 5y agoI've bought edibles and weed in Canada, mainly in Toronto. It used to be a lot stricter but now a lot less people check my ID or whatever. Overall the process feels more informal than before and less go through all these checks etc. Could be I look a bit older although I was able to buy weed at different places when I was much younger without showing my ID either back when it was stricter. Also I've stopped calling them dispensaries because the places that sell weed have diversified, specialized or started marketing themselves with different products that it isn't just a buy weed location anymore so it's hard to put them in one category.
- grawprog 5y ago>Barely more than half of all pot sales today are conducted through the legal market When the government won't pay more than $850/lb no matter the quality of the weed, what do you expect? The weed in legal dispensaries is straight trash. It's dry, usually packaged months before in containers or bags, costs more than the old medical dispensaries or literally anyone else selling weed. There is zero reason to go into a legal dispensary, spend between $25-$40 for 3.5g of weed that's going to be pure garbage when I could get high quality weed for $15-$20/3.5g from pretty much any street dealer or delivery service. Why would I spend more money on 10mg edibles when I can spend less money on 100mg + edibles. It's completely mindboggling how badly the government fucked this up. It's hard to believe it wasn't intentional.
- rubatuga 5y agon=1
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Animats 5y ago"The business model at that time didn’t demand actual weed sales: selling hype, selling the potential of selling weed, was proving lucrative." Where have we heard that before?
- taurath 5y agoThis is a new era though where companies can survive for over a decade on hype and the promise of future profits. In fact present profits make it seem like you’re running out of room to grow. Not that any of the companies anyone here works for work the same way.
- derefr 5y agoIn 2017 a good number of the VCs investing in blockchain in Vancouver, pivoted to investing in weed. I guess their investment thesis was actually "invest in things that can be sold on hype alone."
- d--b 5y agoA billion gram? You mean a thousand ton?
- tartoran 5y agoSame thing but tons are hard to gauge when consumption of weed is closer to grams.
- 14 5y agoPeople buy weed in grams, eighths, quarters, ounces, and pounds typically. Not tons. I assume they went with grams because that is the most common purchase amount and people can possible get a sense of quantity.
- tenfourwookie 5y agoWe've been hearing about surplus for several years now, and yet the price of weed is going up, not down. I regularly see $400 retail ounces in Oregon for top shelf. Supply/demand should push the price to the floor with this Surplus gargantus, and yet prices continue to climb. It's like ECON 101 doesn't apply to pot. What are they going to do? Dump it in ocean? What I want to know is how retail is maintaining these obviously, artificially high prices in a crazy-lopsided buyer's market? Collusion is the only explanation I have. They're all just colluding to prevent price collapse.
- josefresco 5y ago> Collusion It's either straight up illegal collusion or a "natural" side effect of allowing only "big business" to enter the market. Combined with sky high taxes and "community impact" fees and there's not much room for price differentiation,. I live in a state that is just now seeing recreational shops open and miraculously all their pricing is exactly aligned.
- ohyeshedid 5y agoCollusion doesn't need to happen at the point of sale, it could be wholesalers or the growers setting a price structure.
- tenfourwookie 5y agoSure, up and down the chain, but with that much surplus? That would be irrational. I don't understand. Do you mean it's like farmers dumping millions of gallons of milk to quash supply and support price x? To what end? They're worried if they flood the market, price drops? (To say nothing of legality, because I know nothing.)
- atatatat 5y agoOr new entrants just pricing everything the same as previous entrants to grow the industry, and avoid competition on anything besides quality and specific needs/desires from the plant, but it's not surprising that an industry still maintaining some semblance of customer service is a weird sight to behold for folks.
- gumby 5y agoWhat's wrong with saying "tonne" instead of "billion grams"
- reissbaker 5y agoIt sounds like Canadian regulators screwed this up pretty royally. The First Nations counterexample is fairly compelling: farmers able to sell directly to consumers from a farmstand. That being said, I am a little tired of authors trying desperately to work an anti-capitalist bent into their pieces where it doesn't fit. Critiquing capitalism is trendy! But calling for market deregulation — which is exactly what the author seems to be calling for with the First Nations example (the Indigenous farmers aren't running socialist collectives where each grows weed according to their ability and to each is given weed according to their needs; they're running weed farming businesses and selling weed for profit) — is hardly a critique of "shareholder capitalism." The problem doesn't seem to be the shareholding — and the author's banal assumption that Indigenous-owned businesses have no shareholders seems a little racist — the problem is Canadian farmers aren't easily able to sell their product due to Canadian regulatory burdens, and are forced into relationships with the few giant wholesalers who are able to comply. I'm sure the farmers' shareholders would love it if the Canadian regulatory burdens were eased, and somehow I don't think it was them lobbying for the regulation in the first place.
- openthc 5y agoData from Washington State: https://data.openthc.org/ https://data.openthc.org/ (a small side project) It's mostly supply side (B2B) deals, the data about crop and harvest they provide is worthless. I could add in all the retail transactions (I just don't load them every month). You can get it too, FOIA request to the LCB, they'll send you a link to some zip files. They drop new bits every month.
- throwaway984393 5y agoWhat I have heard anecdotally from people who grow is that regulations have stymied their ability to profit. In many places there are limits on how much you can grow, or how you can sell, or how much, or to whom. Illegal sales do not have any of those problems. It's like we've tied the legal producers' hands behind their backs and then wonder what all the struggling is about.
- gwbas1c 5y ago(Joke) > What do you do with a billion grams of surplus weed? Burn it in bonfires at festivals like Coachella and Burning Man.
- kriskrunch 5y agoOr the Canadian festival, Shambhala near Nelson! But they already give the stuff away at many festivals..
- advertising 5y agoKnow a few “pot lawyers” and retail operators. The real money is in gaining a license for a dispensary. Growing is a race to the bottom. From humboldt era $5k lbs to $800 lbs
- 8bitsrule 5y agoOne thing businesses across the US do to keep surplus from cutting into profits is to destroy it before trashing it. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/aug/07/new-york-city-garbage-trash-walks-anna-sacks https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/aug/07/new-york-cit...