4 ms·
Take a close look at the way this works. If there are enough hash matches, Apple apparently gets to look at all the pictures on the phone. The description says
by Animats 5y ago
Take a close look at the way this works. If there are enough hash matches, Apple apparently gets to look at all the pictures on the phone. The description says "threshold reached, all content visible and unlocked". "All", not "Matched".
Matches can be forced from the outside, by sending pictures to the phone. They don't even have to be from the known-bad image set. Using an adversarial system to try to create hash matches might allow generating innocuous pictures which trigger a phone dump.
Expect a toolset for doing that to be developed. Although it may take a while for word of it to leak out. This has applications for entrapment, swatting, political retribution, etc.
- zimpenfish 5y ago> If there are enough hash matches, Apple apparently gets to look at all the pictures on the phone. Not according to the technical summary PDF they released[1], "Only those images that have a voucher that corresponds to a true CSAM match can have their vouchers’ data decrypted [...] Even if the device-generated inner encryption key for the account is reconstructed based on the above process, the image information inside the safety voucher for non-matches is still protected by the outer layer of encryption" [1] https://www.apple.com/child-safety/pdf/CSAM_Detection_Technical_Summary.pdf https://www.apple.com/child-safety/pdf/CSAM_Detection_Techni...
- 0xy 5y agoThis is spin by Apple, driven by ignorance or deliberately misleading statements. NCMEC's database contains images that are not CSAM, not illegal and are not even borderline (grey area). The fact there is a match in NCMEC's database does not mean the content is CSAM. It does not even mean it's illegal. In fact, it doesn't even mean there's a single person in the picture frame. And no, this is not theoretical. NCMEC's database is this much of a mess today. In fact, given there's a threshold at all I'm pushed into believing that Apple know the database is faulty.
- zimpenfish 5y ago> NCMEC's database contains images that are not CSAM, not illegal and are not even borderline (grey area). Got a handy link about this? A quick search doesn't show anything obvious. > This is spin by Apple, driven by ignorance or deliberately misleading statements. The claim was that Apple got access to all the pictures on the phone which isn't correct according to their technical summary. Nothing to do with the validity of NCMEC hashes.
- ziml77 5y agoI think the problem is that no one will ever be able to validate what's in that database. "I need to see that database so I can ensure that it's all CP" isn't going to go over well.
- dannyw 5y agoEven regardless of whether it's all photos or all matched photos, the issue is that Apple is actively and publicly building adversarial black boxes that run on your device, on a OS level (on iOS AND macs!), with the sole and explicit goal of snitching on you to the government for possessing information that is deemed wrong. The actual specifics of what material is currently deemed wrong is irrelevant, because it will be expanded. This. Is. Not Okay. This is something you'd expect China to mandate, not a Western company like Apple to advertise as a feature.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- polyomino 5y agoI don't see why this is surprising at all. Apple has never cared about the privacy of their Chinese users. Privacy was never a principle for them, merely a marketing feature for technically illiterate westerners.
- axiosgunnar 5y agoYou are a 100% right and I feel so ashamed of myself to have fallen for that.
- guessbest 5y agoAnyone can already do that by sending a iOS user an incriminating message via airdrop or sharing an album. Unless this search is limited to only photos saved to the personal Photos Album, all apps on the iOS device become an evidence plant attack vector including the built in mail app, third party apps that can accept image messages or have planted illegal images, and even iMessage.
- dannyw 5y agoThis is especially important given that NSO Group's Pegasus' works through sending multimedia iMessages/WhatsApps with exploits. The former auto-uploads to iCloud, and the latter can be configured to auto-upload all received media to iCloud. It almost sounds like a feature Apple is building to explicitly support the imprisonment of dissents through tje false planting of child pornography. What the actual f--k?
- zimpenfish 5y ago> It almost sounds like a feature Apple is building to explicitly support the imprisonment of dissents through tje false planting of child pornography. But you can already do this without these changes - cf the UK police officer currently under investigation for having CP on her phone that someone else sent her and (she claims) never opened. https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2020/aug/02/former-police-chief-convicted-over-child-abuse-video-granted-appeal-hearing-robyn-williams https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2020/aug/02/former-polic...
- dendriti 5y agoOnce again, "People can already do this" is not a rebuttal or a defense.
- zimpenfish 5y agoIt's a rebuttal to "is building to explicitly support the imprisonment of dissents" when this is already possible without this new feature.