3 ms·
Perceptual hashes are not exact hashes, otherwise they would be useless for this task; you would just mirror the image or change 1 pixel. They are instead fuzz
by Conlectus 5y ago
Perceptual hashes are not exact hashes, otherwise they would be useless for this task; you would just mirror the image or change 1 pixel.
They are instead fuzzy classifiers, and thus have non-zero error rates.
- nomel 5y agoBut this trigger requires many of these false flags to exceed the threshold (most likely why it exists). I imagine the "one in a trillion" numbers they claim for false flagging rate are probably cemented in reality, and make it trivial for human review.
- skinkestek 5y agoI've explained the problem here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28099927 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28099927
- DSingularity 5y agoHow does this relate to the allegation I was responding to? There is a difference between false positives and false negatives you know. False negative is where the criminal evades the system through measures you describe. False positive — what I was responding to — is where Apple incorrectly accuses an innocent person and thus violates their privacy during the subsequent review.