5 ms·
SEC approves Nasdaq's plan to require board diversity
- gedy 5y agoI don't suppose there'll be a requirement for someone from a poor background though. Not trolling, honest observation.
- shephardjhon 5y agoPoor people can still become rich but you can't undo 300 years of racism, and policies like redlining. Also there HAVE been provrams for the kind of thing you are asking for, the home loan program after world war 2 where only 2 black soldiers were given loans and the homestead act where spccifically white people were given free land. Then there was stuff like taking away Bruce's beach under imminant domain. These policies are aimed at fixing a wrong that caused such lopsided poverty in one race.
- thoughtstheseus 5y agoOr public colleges. A handful of elite schools continue to dominate decision making in corporate America. It’s disappointing. I’m from an area with a significant percentage of poor white people and the universal view is these types of policies blatantly discriminate against them.
- 908B64B197 5y agoAre these policies aimed at discriminating against "diverse" candidates? Now on a board there will be those who got there on merit, and those who maybe got there on the quota or merit...
- ericb 5y agoI thought race/sexuality being a part of the hiring decision was the problem?
- _-david-_ 5y agoWait, it is ok to hire based on race, gender identity, and sexual orientation?
- unmole 5y agoI wonder how it applies to non-American companies listed on Nasdaq. I'm not sure who would count as a racial minority for Infosys.
- deepserket 5y ago- so, how did you get there? - well... they needed a woman to meet the quota
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Proven 5y agoCan't wait to see diversity in Asia- and Africa-based Nasdaq-listed companies!
- gibba999 5y agoMy experience is that this is a good thing for shareholders. The current qualifications -- part of a network -- aren't actually very merit-based or constructive. Boards composed of rich, white, Anglo-Saxon males tend to not understand customers or employees very well. A bigger step forward would be international representation. Companies mess up or completely miss markets like the billion plus people in Africa, the billion plus people in India, or the billion plus people in Muslim-majority countries. Even nominal international representation would be huge. People tend to fetishize the types of people on boards, but I've worked with a fair number, and the skills which they have -- being able to become a board member through complex political and networking games -- aren't actually very well-aligned with maximizing shareholder value.
- jl2718 5y agoIf it’s better for shareholders, then why didn’t they vote for it already? Your post implies that you believe that the white male board members are inept, there only for their network, and the new diverse members will be more competent in the specific business, better with customers and employees. Please enlighten us with the evidence that supports this assertion.
- gibba999 5y agoMy evidence is having seen boards operate. I wouldn't quite use the word "inept," but I would say the in most companies, at least 10% of the workforce would do a better job than the board members. You live in a democracy. If your municipal politicians were corrupt, why didn't you vote them out? The answer is that information is that the efficient market hypothesis isn't correct. Every so often, I receive a list of board members to vote for on the few stocks I hold. The list is as long as the number of seats. I know nothing about them except for at best a 1-paragraph description. If there were more, it would not worth my time as an individual shareholder to do more research. That's a minority of my investments. Most are in index funds and mutual funds. There, someone votes on my behalf. I'm not sure who -- I know which company, but absolutely nothing about the person or process. And yes, I've seen companies I've worked at or followed closely target 300 million person markets instead of 7 billion person markets.
- mchusma 5y agoI think that this policy, and similar ones, will likely hurt the people it purports to protect. The perception will now be reinforced that women or minorities hired to boards are to "meet quota". Also interesting that this article implied that some of these problems were fixing themselves, with the rate of female and black directors increasing. If you believe that there is systemic racism, then you believe there is an arbitrage opportunity, which for profit companies are likely to take advantage of. (This implementation however doesn't appear to be the worst implementation of this idea, so that has merit)