20 ms·
The technical challenges aside, I’m very disturbed that my device will be reporting me to the authorities. That’s very different from authorities taking a snea
by mrtksn 5y ago
The technical challenges aside, I’m very disturbed that my device will be reporting me to the authorities.
That’s very different from authorities taking a sneak peek into my stuff.
That’s like the theological concept of always being watched.
It starts with child pornography but the technology is indifferent towards it, it can be anything.
It’s always about the children because we all want to save the children. Soon they will start asking you start saving your country. Depending on your location they will start checking against sins against religion, race, family values, political activities.
I bet you, after the next election in the US your device will be reporting you for spreading far right or deep state lies, depending on who wins.
I’m big Apple fanboy, but I’m not going to carry a snitch in my pocket. That’s “U2 Album in everyone’s iTunes library” blunder level creepy with the only difference that it’s actually truly creepy.
In my case, my iPhone is going to be snitching me to Boris and Erdogan, in your case it could be Macron, Bolsonaro, Biden, Trump etc.
That’s no go for me, you can decide for yourself.
- baggy_trough 5y agoTotally agree. This is very sinister indeed. Horrible idea, Apple.
- zionic 5y agoSo what are we going to do about it? I have a large user base on iOS. Considering a blackout protest.
- mrtksn 5y agoIMHO, Unless everything being E2E encrypted becomes the law we can’t do anything about it because that’s not Apple’s initiative but comes from people whose job is to know things and they cannot resist keeping their hands out of these data collecting devices. They promise politicians that all the troubles will go away if we do that. Child pornography, Terrorism? Solve it the old way. I don’t know why citizens are obligated to make their jobs easier. We survived the times when phone calls were not moderated, we survived the times when signal intelligence was not a thing.
- munk-a 5y agoUnless I missed a big part of this story Apple isn't being compelled by a court to comply - so if the presence of this tech causes a larger PR stink than publicly backing out of the rollout then Apple will read the writing on the wall. Public and political pressure is definitely an issue - but it's still soft-pressure so applying more pressure in the other direction will be compelling to Apple.
- mrtksn 5y agoApple was supposed to E2E encrypt everything. Then reports surfaced that FBI complained and they stopped. The are speculations about this being Apple’s solution to government demands so that they can continue migrating to E2E. They are trying a solution where the device reports you to the authorities so that Apple gets out of the business of knowing your data.
- mrtksn 5y agoJust to clarify, this "on device content control" defies all the benefits of the E2E encryption because it is "at the end". It will enable Apple to implement E2E and give the authorities a channel to program the devices to report users in possession of content deemed unacceptable by the authorities.
- HWR_14 5y ago> Solve it the old way. In fairness, in the "old way" it was impossible for two random people to communicate in real-time between continents without the ability of authorities to observe/break it. Privacy and security is quite important, but let's not lose track of the fact that there are many tools authorities have lost in the past few decades. In WWII major powers weren't able to have the same security of military communications as an idiot can today. And that's relative to codebreaking technology. If I had a good solution, I'd tell you.
- mrtksn 5y agoThe difference is that previously you had to be targeted and intercepted. Thinking that someone is listening was something that paranoid people would do. Now your device is actually watching you and reporting you. Today only for child porn but there’s no technical reason of it not being extended to anything.
- Blammar 5y agoWrite an iCloud photo frontend that uploads only encrypted images to iCloud and decrypts on your phone only?
- p2t2p 5y agoWon't help, the detection of on your phone now. I wonder if one can have a local VPN with a profile installed which could MITM iCloud upload process and take those matching envelops out. But in the end of the day the only robust way to communicate privately is good old Linux with good old mutt with good old PGP
- brokenmachine 5y agoAt that point, it's time to think very seriously about finding a different hardware provider.
- asimpletune 5y agoI have been a big Apple fan ever since my first computer. This is the first time I legitimately thought I need to start thinking about something else. It’s kind of sad.
- echelon 5y agoGood! These assholes have been building a moat around all of computing, and now it's almost impossible to avoid the multi-trillion dollar monster. Think about all the startups that can't deploy software without being taxed most of our margin, the sign in with apple that prevents us from having a real customer relationship, and the horrible support, libraries, constant changes, etc. It's hostile! It's unfair that the DOJ hasn't done anything about it. A modern startup cannot succeed without Apple's blessing. To do so would be giving up 50% of the American market. When you're struggling to grow and find traction, you can't do that. It's so wildly unfair that they "own" 50+% of computer users. Think of all the device owners that don't have the money to pay Apple for new devices or upgrades. They can't repair them themselves. Apple's products are meant to go into the trash and be replaced with new models. We want to sidestep these shenanigans and use our own devices? Load our own cloud software? We can't! Apple, from the moment Jobs decreed, was fully owned property. No alternative browsers, no scripting or runtimes. No computing outside the lines. You're just renting. This company is so awful. Please call your representatives and ask them to break up the biggest and most dangerous monopoly in the world.
- jeromegv 5y agoGenuinely curious, why? This scanning was already happening server-side in your iCloud photos, just like Google Photos, etc. Now they are removing it from server-side to client-side (which still require this photo to be hosted in iCloud) What changed, really?
- zekrioca 5y agoYou answered your own question and still don’t get it.
- 5y ago
- Klonoar 5y agoI would really like people to start answering this: what exactly do you think has changed? e.g, >That’s very different from authorities taking a sneak peek into my stuff. To be very blunt: - The opt out of this is to not use iCloud Photos. - If you _currently_ use iCloud Photos, your photos are _already_ hash compared. - Thus the existing opt out is to... not use iCloud Photos. The exact same outcome can happen regardless of whether it's done on or off device. iCloud has _always_ been a known vector for authorities to peek. >I’m big Apple fanboy, but I’m not going to carry a snitch in my pocket. If you use iCloud, you arguably already do.
- xuki 5y agoIt makes even less sense, given that they are currently doing this with your iCloud photos. Now they have this tool that can match to a database of photos, how do we know they wouldn't use this to identify non-sexual photos? Maybe Tim Cook wouldn't, what about the next CEO? And the one after that?
- Klonoar 5y agoThe questions re: what the CEO would sign off on here don't really matter, as the question could apply whether it's server side or client side. It _does_ make sense client side if you view it being done server side as a blocker for E2EE on iCloud. There is absolutely no world where Apple could implement that without keeping the ability to say "yes, we're blocking child porn".
- tialaramex 5y agoWhat makes you think that Apple has a database of actual child sex abuse images? Does that feel like a thing you'd be OK with? "Oh, this is Jim, he's the guy who keeps our archive of sex abuse photographs here at One Infinite Loop" ? If you feel OK with that at Apple, how about at Facebook? Tencent? What about the new ten-person SV start-up would-be Facebook killer whose main founder had a felony conviction in 1996 for violating the Mann Act. Still comfortable? Far more likely Apple takes a bunch of hashes from a third party in the law enforcement side of things (ie cops) and trust that the third party is definitely giving them hashes to protect against the Very Bad Thing that Apple's customers are worried about. Whereupon what you're actually trusting isn't Tim Cook, it's a cop. I'm told there are good cops. Maybe all this is done exclusively by good cops. For now. Now, I don't know about the USA, but around here we don't let cops just snoop about in our stuff, on the off-chance that by doing so they might find kiddie porn. So it should be striking that apparently Apple expects you to be OK with that.
- cyanydeez 5y agoyou have to realize though that the panopticon is limited only by the ability of "authority" to sift through it for whatever it is it is looking for. as this article points out, the positive matches will still need an observe to confirm what it is and is not. lastly, the very reason you have this device exposes you to the reality of either accepting a government that regulates these corporate overreaches or accepting private ownership thats profit motive is deeply personal. you basically have to reverse society or learn to be a hermit, or more realistically, buy into a improved democratic construct that opts into transparent regulation. but it sounds more like you want to live in a split brained world where your paranoia and antigovernment stance invites dark corporste policies to sell you out anyway
- dylan604 5y ago>but I’m not going to carry a snitch in my pocket. I wonder how this will hold up against 5th ammendment (in the US) covering self-incrimination?
- ssklash 5y agoI assume the third party doctrine makes it so that the 5th amendment doesn't apply here.
- dylan604 5y ago"The third-party doctrine is a United States legal doctrine that holds that people who voluntarily give information to third parties—such as banks, phone companies, internet service providers, and e-mail servers—have "no reasonable expectation of privacy." A lack of privacy protection allows the United States government to obtain information from third parties without a legal warrant and without otherwise complying with the Fourth Amendment prohibition against search and seizure without probable cause and a judicial search warrant." --wiki Okay, but the users of said 3rd party are doing it under the assumption that it is encrypted on the 3rd party's system in a way that they cannot gain access to it. The unencrypted data is not what the user is giving to iCloud. So technically, the data this scan is providing to the authorities is not the same data that the user is giving to the 3rd parties. Definitely some wiggle room on both sides for some well versed lawyers to chew up some billing hours.
- gpm 5y agoWith you up to here, but this is jumping the shark > I bet you, after the next election in the US your device will be reporting you for spreading far right or deep state lies, depending on who wins. The US is becoming less stable, sure [1], but there is still a very strong culture of free speech, particularly political speech. I put the odds that your device will be reporting on that within 4 years as approximately 0. The extent that you see any interference with speech today is corporations choosing not to repeat certain speech to the public. Not them even looking to scan collections of files about it, not them reporting it to the government, and the government certainly wouldn't be interested if they tried. The odds that it's reporting other crimes than child porn though, say, copyright infringement. That strikes me as not-so-low. [1] I agree with this so much that it's part of why I just quit a job that would have required me to move to the US.
- efitz 5y agoApple has a shitty record wrt free speech. Apple hates free speech. Apple likes “curation”. They canned Parler in a heartbeat; they also police the App Store for anything naughty.
- gpm 5y agoCanning Parler is Apple choosing not to advertise and send you an app they don't like, i.e. it's Apple exercising it's own right to free speech. Agree or disagree with it, it's categorically different from Apple spying on what the files you have are saying (not even to or via Apple) and reporting it to the government.
- wyager 5y agoApple also disallows you from installing things without going through them, so “choosing not to advertise and send” has a lot more significance than your wording implies. It’s not like they have a curated App Store for apps they like; there’s literally no other way to add software to the device.
- 5y ago