4 ms·
One aspect of this phenomenon that I find amusing is how low the bar is set in terms of programming to qualify as a "hacker." e.g. "I hacked together this RoR s
by mindcrime 15y ago
One aspect of this phenomenon that I find amusing is how low the bar is set in terms of programming to qualify as a "hacker." e.g. "I hacked together this RoR site over the weekend" makes me think, "You used a popular, well documented website building framework for it's intended purpose... how exactly is this hacking?"
I'll argue that it is hacking, where "hacking" is largely about exploring the unknown and/or creating things that didn't exist before. Just because the tool your using is common, doesn't mean the result is. So depending on what the RoR site is (or maybe I should say, what it does) I think it's construction could justifiably be called hacking. But that's just me...
- evilduck 15y agoI agree, I think it depends on what the focus of the activity is. A while back I made http://crimesagainstcode.com/ http://crimesagainstcode.com/ as a weekend hack. It's built on Rails 3.1/CoffeeScript simply because that's was I was also playing with at the time, but the "hack" part for me was the fiddling with QR codes in a pretty obtuse manner to see what I could safely manipulate, not the underlying technology of the site itself.
- sequoia 15y agoI'm of a different opinion here. One classical definition of hacking is tied closely to "Using tools or technology in a way not originally intended by the tool's creator." So e.g. blueboxing phones, cooking meat in your car's engine, running linux on your wristwatch etc.. This is the definition that I find the most acceptable, so for me using a television to watch Glee is not hacking; you're using the tool as it was meant to be used. Making your television receive analog FM radio signals to listen to NPR, on the other hand, is hacking, because you're misusing the technology to some useful end. MS Kinect hacking is a good example here: users making the tool do things it wasn't intended to do my Microsoft.
- mindcrime 15y agoFair enough... I just think a programming language and a framework are - by design - made for creating new things, things that didn't exist before. And I equate hacking largely with that sense of exploring what's possible, in terms of "what can I create?" That's why I find most - but not all - coding to be hacking... if your coding and creating something new, that's enough to meet my personal bar of "hacking." I will admit that it's a fuzzy and subjective bar though...
- esrauch 15y ago> MS Kinect hacking is a good example here: users making the tool do things it wasn't intended to do my Microsoft. Based on your other examples, I don't you should consider this hacking. None of the MS Kinect hacking has made it do anything that it wasn't actually intended to do. "Kinect hacking" is akin to having a tv that only has composite input, and you figuring out a way to get HDMI input to composite. I guess it's slightly more of a gray area, but the Kinect's sole purpose is to output depth data to USB with the intent for it to be used with motion capture, and that is all that "hackers" use it for.
- sequoia 15y agoI guess so... my understanding was that the Kinect was produced exclusively to connect to the xbox and play xbox games. When people reverse engineered it in order to connect it to different things and do things other than play xbox games, that was a hack. On the other hand, my "definition" means that it would be technically impossible to hack with the Arduino because it's intended for hacking. :p So back to the drawing board :)