4 ms·
It really all comes down to if Apple has and is willing to maintain the effort of human evaluations prior to taking action on the potentially false positives:
by karmakaze 5y ago
It really all comes down to if Apple has and is willing to maintain the effort of human evaluations prior to taking action on the potentially false positives:
> According to Apple, a low number of positives (false or not) will not trigger an account to be flagged. But again, at these numbers, I believe you will still get too many situations where an account has multiple photos triggered as a false positive. (Apple says that probability is “1 in 1 trillion” but it is unclear how they arrived at such an estimate.) These cases will be manually reviewed.
At scale, even human classification which ought to be clear will fail, accidentally clicking 'not ok' when they saw something they thought was 'ok'. It will be interesting to see what happens then.
- jdavis703 5y agoThen law enforcement, a prosecutor and a jury would get involved. Hopefully law enforcement would be the first and final stage if it was merely the case that a person pressed “ok” by accident.
- karmakaze 5y agoThis is exactly the kind of thing that is to be avoided: premature escalation, tying up resources, increasing costs, and raising the stakes and probability of bad outcomes.
- gtyras2mrs 5y agoDo you think once you are charged with possessing child porn - will you still have your job, your friends, your family, your life as you know it? Will a court decision - months or years later - restore what you have lost?