3 ms·
It's interesting that you single out Americans. I don't actually know if it's especially true for Americans, but I do think that events of the last decade or so
by jfengel 5y ago
It's interesting that you single out Americans. I don't actually know if it's especially true for Americans, but I do think that events of the last decade or so suggest that Americans do seem to engage an awful lot with conspiracy theories.
I'm sure there are many factors, but I believe that a key one is the American belief in individualism. We celebrate the ability of geniuses who saw past the prevailing ideas and became great. We think America rewards hard work and talent, and that if you're not successful, either you're dumb, lazy, or somebody is holding you back.
And of course you, yourself, must not be dumb or lazy. So it must be the third thing.
It's easy to find that dark, oppressive force if you go looking -- via confirmation bias, cherry picking, and other tactics. And everybody else is either dumb or complicit if they don't see it.
The moon landing hoax is a great meme to believe in. It doesn't actually cost you anything to be wrong -- it's not like Buzz Aldrin is going to punch you in the face (as long as you're carefully separated by the Internet). You can live your whole life believing it without it actually mattering. The worst that can happen is that people get aggravated by your fanaticism -- you can't change your mind and won't change the subject. But that just tells you who your friends are.
Believing in a conspiracy theory makes you feel powerful. Americans in particular seem to crave that need to feel powerful, that they're in on the secret and thus better than everybody else.
Couple that with the particular time of the moon landing -- Vietnam, Nixon, the CIA and FBI doing a ton of genuinely awful stuff, etc -- and distrusting the government is easy. We've never really gotten over that.
It's unclear to me just how much of moon-landing denial is real and how much is just trolling. Trolling and conspiracy theories are two sides of the same coin. People want to feel powerful by knowing a "secret". The secret of trolling is that it's not hard to violate the social contract that allows us to live civilly with one another. That gives you power over other people, as long as you're at sufficient distance to avoid repercussions and sufficiently safe that you don't care what strangers think of you.
Anyway, that's a lot of words and only barely scratches the surface. But perhaps it gives a hint.