3 ms·
From the end of TFA: >And everyone should stop driving fossil vehicles starting now. [ ... ] There’s no excuse not to. Admirable sentiments, but can anyone po
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
From the end of TFA:
>And everyone should stop driving fossil vehicles starting now. [ ... ] There’s no excuse not to.
Admirable sentiments, but can anyone point definitively to the net gain/loss in CO2 terms of actually ditching a fossil fuel based car and replacing it with a new EV? And how does that look if the FF car is something like a Honda Fit (good mileage, lower than typical emissions)?
I'd be willing to dump our Fit for some sort of EV, but I'm really not convinced that it's helping climate change to do so.
Change my mind?
- gameswithgo 5y agoSure, here is one such full lifecycle study: https://sustain.ubc.ca/sites/default/files/2018-63%20Lifecycle%20Analysis%20of%20Electric%20Vehicles_Kukreja.pdf https://sustain.ubc.ca/sites/default/files/2018-63%20Lifecyc...
- lucb1e 5y agoConclusion: > [EV and ICE vehicles were] comparatively analyzed by dividing into five categories: raw material production, vehicle manufacture, transportation, operation, and decommissioning. The analysis [...] revealed that electric vehicles have a markedly lower impact in both categories, especially in regions with clean power sources like British Columbia. This conclusion is reached after consideration of the higher environmental burdens of raw material production and decommissioning inherent to electric vehicles. The significantly lower impacts from the operation stage had the strongest effect on the results. Sensitivity analysis showed that a longer lifespan shifted the efficiency balance further toward the electric vehicle.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- perl4ever 5y agoThat's great, but it's biased in several ways that make it not relevant to my lifestyle. 1. I'm never going to live in Vancouver, so my electricity is probably never going to be near as clean, even though it is relatively low carbon by US standards. 2. I'm never going to own a Ford Focus - my car gets much higher mileage, around 50 mpg, which is a big reduction in CO2. There are a few different options with similar mileage, too. 3. I'm never going to own a clown-car Mitsubishi EV; at present, I think the plausible choices are a Nissan Leaf, a Chevy Bolt, or a Kia/Hyundai (I forget the models). I don't know these would increase the CO2 from manufacturing a lot, but it wouldn't surprise me.
- lowbloodsugar 5y agoWhat is your car? It doesn't actually get 50mpg unless its a hybrid or you only drive it long distances on a freeway. If its a hybrid, it has all the environmental impact of having two complete power systems, the negative effects of a battery etc. If its not a hybrid, then you aren't getting 50mpg around town.
- perl4ever 5y ago>If its a hybrid, it has all the environmental impact of having two complete power systems, the negative effects of a battery etc No, it doesn't. This is a popular thing to say, but I wish people would think about it for a minute. My car has a ~1.2 kWh battery. A Bolt or a Leaf has 40-60 kWh. I don't understand why people don't get this. With a gas engine, you have 98% less battery. So you are not just adding complexity for super long trips. That's not the equation at all. If batteries get better, it doesn't change the proportion of 50:1. And batteries also become harder and harder to get perfect the larger they get. So there's no question in my mind of more chance of a defective one on an EV. https://insideevs.com/news/342671/my-chevy-bolt-is-on-third-battery-pack-heres-why/ https://insideevs.com/news/342671/my-chevy-bolt-is-on-third-...
- shagie 5y agoThe Honda Fit is 267 grams of CO2 per mile. https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/Find.do?action=sbs&id=40076 https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/Find.do?action=sbs&id=40076 If you include the upstream costs, that's another 56 grams of CO2 per mile. The Prius is 158 grams of CO2 per mile and an upstream of 33 grams. https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/Find.do?action=sbs&id=42810 https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/Find.do?action=sbs&id=42810 For a 3 way compare with the Fit, an Insight and a Prius - https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/Find.do?action=sbs&id=42810&id=40075&id=43948 https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/Find.do?action=sbs&id=42810&... Select the "Energy and Environment" tab. Note that the Prius has a function grid sources. https://www.miloslick.com/EnergyLogger_files/State_Electricity_and_Emissions_Rates.pdf https://www.miloslick.com/EnergyLogger_files/State_Electrici... . 1 kWh in Wyoming is 2.278 lbs of C02 while its 0.456 lbs of C02 in Oregon. Based on https://www.novatotoyota.com/blog/how-many-miles-does-the-2021-prius-prime-get-on-a-tank-of-gas/amp/ https://www.novatotoyota.com/blog/how-many-miles-does-the-20... > The plug-in hybrid car also has an electric-only range of 25 miles in EV Mode with an 8.8 kWh battery. That gets us to 2.84 miles/kWh. Going back to the lbs/kWh with a US average of 1.363 lbs/kWh that gives 2.84 miles / kWh * 1.363 lbs / kWh which gives us 2.084 miles/lb which is 217 grams per mile... and that's in the ballpark of the Primus value given on fueleconomy.gov Lets assume that fueleconomy.gov is correct for the US average and use an adjustment of x0.72 to get the value. Taking this to Wyoming and you've got to increase that number by 1.67x (just using the ratio of US average to Wyoming) Prius at 158 * 1.67 brings it to 263 grams/mile in Wyoming... which is the same as the Honda Fit.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoCarbon zero transportation is a two step process: electrify the transportation and green the electricity. They both have to be done, and they both take a long time. If each side waits for the other, neither gets done. At current prices, renewables are the cheapest energy sources, any increased demand for energy will bias the electricity mix greener.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> If each side waits for the other, neither gets done. But for it to get done, we essentially have to junk all current IC vehicles, and build replacements. My question was whether or not that actually puts us ahead CO2/climate-wise.
- rjsw 5y agoThere seem to be several TV series that show people converting ICE cars to electric, the cost seems comparable to buying new electric cars but with a lot less environmental impact.
- zejn 5y agoVehicles are being replaced every year. Think of buying a new ICE car as a subscription to fossil fuels, as you can't easily make fuel for ICE engine from renewable energy. The reverse is true - you can make electricity from fossil fuels, if really needed. I interpret Tim Bray's "everyone should stop driving fossil vehicles starting now" as a conclusion, that EVs are usable enough for most personal transport needs and if buying a new car, make it an EV.
- hokkos 5y agoJust look right here, 2.5 times less emissions in the USA in a life cycle analysis : https://theicct.org/sites/default/files/publications/Global-LCA-passenger-cars-jul2021_0.pdf https://theicct.org/sites/default/files/publications/Global-... If you want to test with your own car, and custom data, this tool is great : https://climobil.connecting-project.lu/ https://climobil.connecting-project.lu/
- _ph_ 5y agoIt would probably not be a great idea to destroy a perfectly fine ICE, though even that can in some cases be a win, if you drive very high mileage. But that isn't the point. We should stop buying new ICE vehicles as soon as possible. So instead of buying a new ICE vehicle, which might be on the roads for another 10-15 years, rather drive your existing one a bit longer and then switch to an electric vehicle. Currently the manufacturing capacity wouldn't be high enough to go to 100% electric vehicles for new cars anyway.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> But that isn't the point. We should stop buying new ICE vehicles as soon as possible. Well, I agree entirely with that. But TFA said we should all stop driving them now, and that's what I was asking about.
- _ph_ 5y agoWell, I didn't take it literally, because it literalyl isn't possible :). It will take some years until the car industry can supply all new cars needed, even at best effort.