4 ms·
The final step of this is going to be detection of terrorist materials, then we will have privacy that is based on our jurisdictions definition of terrorism. Y
by mrtksn 5y ago
The final step of this is going to be detection of terrorist materials, then we will have privacy that is based on our jurisdictions definition of terrorism.
Your device provider(not necessarily Apple) will notify authorities when you score high enough on a threat model.
In just in a decade, for the US citizens that model could include belief in fair elections(depending on who wins, you can be a terrorist of the deep state or the far right), you can be a Chinese terrorist in the USA if the friction intensifies between countries, you can be financial terrorist if the relationship between Cryptocurrencies and the state sours.
You can be traitor terrorist of corporations, because they detected inappropriate use of corporate materials on your device.
You can be cultural terrorist in a culture obsessed with self preservation.
You can be infidel terrorist a muslim state with large enough market.
There is no need for hypothetical situations, you can be a terrorist or a freedom fighter today depending on your coordinates.
It is so easy to be a terrorist these days.
This is going to get very interesting when every authority starts demanding detection of their boogyman. Why bother with anti-espionage when you can tell apple to check who does have the pictures of your new shiny thing that was supposed to be a secret?
Apple seems to provide nice technological solution that looks promising to work fine as long as the authorities do good job in not becoming totalitarian crazy nutjobs because the technology can be used for any content, does not have a capability to ensure that it works only on child porn.
Apple is giving governments a content control tool that at this time is promised to work only for specific materials.
- cwkoss 5y agoWe should hope detection of terrorism is the final step. We should be extremely concerned that detection of political activism or investigative journalism will actually be the final step.
- Prometheous08 5y ago'terrorism' is defined as whatever a governing body in charge says it is. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-iran/u-s-officially-designates-irans-revolutionary-guards-a-terrorist-group-idUSKCN1RR1BE https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-iran/u-s-officially-d... https://www.aa.com.tr/en/middle-east/iran-parliament-blacklists-pentagon-as-terrorist-group/1694673 https://www.aa.com.tr/en/middle-east/iran-parliament-blackli...
- cassianoleal 5y agoPolitical activism of many forms is already considered terrorism in many parts of the world. Investigative journalism is not hard to frame as such either in many cases. If terrorism is the final step, all that's needed to expand it is to redefine what constitutes it.
- pintxo 5y agoNelson Mandela was once considered a terrorist!
- stefantalpalaru 5y ago> Nelson Mandela was once considered a terrorist! For good reason: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UMkhonto_we_Sizwe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UMkhonto_we_Sizwe
- yosamino 5y ago> The final step of this is going to be detection of terrorist materials, I don't think so. So many surveillance laws were passed with the stated intent of wanting to use them in cases of the most serious crimes and terrorism. Now they are being used against your run of the mill criminals and innocent citizens.
- phkahler 5y agoIn the US, one would hope Apple could be forced to reveal which images were reported in court. That would be a good check on misuse. Like a lot of things, this sounds fairly reasonable but is likely to be corrupted over time. In other countries you may not be allowed to see the evidence against you. In the US there would certainly be pressure to suppress the evidence but that probably won't fly in a normal criminal court. IANAL.