3 ms·
The bill has nothing to do with ‘raising money’. There are no new taxes or sources of revenue in the bill. It’s about two things: 1. putting greater surveillanc
by jl2718 5y ago
The bill has nothing to do with ‘raising money’. There are no new taxes or sources of revenue in the bill. It’s about two things: 1. putting greater surveillance on crypto than cash, and 2. making operation of crypto/defi impossible and therefore illegal.
The amendment is simply making it not illegal to not do the impossible (miners and programmers issuing 1099s to users). Without it, operating a crypto network or writing smart contracts is illegal in the United States, except for a few giant exchanges and funds of course. Wall St. can have it, but you can’t. At that point I’ll agree with all the anti-crypto posters that it’s just a big scam on retail investors.
Now it’s 100% transparent that this is her goal. I keep restating: this is exactly the reason that cryptocurrency has any value at all.
https://mobile.twitter.com/documentingbtc/status/1395789620026163204?lang=en https://mobile.twitter.com/documentingbtc/status/13957896200...
On a long enough timeline, I think it will be impossible to exchange self-custodied cryptos to or from fiat. At that point, it’s either a medium of exchange, or it’s worthless. I have a lot more to say about that, but I will save it.
- cratermoon 5y ago> simply making it not illegal to not do the impossible What?
- jl2718 5y agoThe bill makes it illegal to write code or validate blocks without issuing a 1099 to users. That would be impossible, so it’s illegal to not do the impossible. The amendment makes the above not illegal. Their logic, not mine.
- cratermoon 5y agoYou're still speaking with too many negatives. Try phrasing with positive words in place of "without", "impossible", or "illegal", and especially avoid "not illegal".
- jl2718 5y agoI did this intentionally. There is no such thing as a law making something ‘legal’. It can only make something ‘illegal’ or ‘not illegal’.
- cratermoon 5y agoPray tell, what law school did you go to where this was taught?
- jl2718 5y agoLaw school doesn’t make laws, but this is also taught in law school: https://hls.harvard.edu/academics/curriculum/catalog/index.html?o=65721 https://hls.harvard.edu/academics/curriculum/catalog/index.h...