5 ms·
> The number of insects have dropped dramatically Are you referring to the 2017 "Insect Apocalypse" paper? It has not done well under subsequent examination.
by pfdietz 5y ago
> The number of insects have dropped dramatically
Are you referring to the 2017 "Insect Apocalypse" paper? It has not done well under subsequent examination.
https://ecologyisnotadirtyword.com/2019/12/20/moving-on-from-the-insect-apocalypse-to-evidence-based-conservation/ https://ecologyisnotadirtyword.com/2019/12/20/moving-on-from...
"From a scientific perspective, there is so much wrong with the paper, it really shouldn’t have been published in its current form: the biased search method, the cherry-picked studies, the absence of any real quantitative data to back up the bizarre 40% extinction rate that appears in the abstract (we don’t even have population data for 40% of the world’s insect species), and the errors in the reference list. And it was presented as a ‘comprehensive review’ and a ‘meta-analysis’, even though it is neither."
- spiderfarmer 5y agoThis was clear within weeks after publishing it. Years later it’s still cited or paraphrased in every article about bees or other flying insects. Sigh.
- mandmandam 5y agoAnyone with eyeballs can tell there are far far far far far fewer insects than there were thirty years ago. This isn't a fuddable topic.
- rootusrootus 5y agoI'd prefer actual science, human memory is extremely unreliable and often tends to be self-serving.
- Dumblydorr 5y agoWhen does preference for "actual science" become satisfied, given we on HN skeptically pick apart all presented evidence of anything? The above is in Nature for goodness sakes, is that too weak of a journal? If so I'm weaker than a weak scientist who publishes there. I'd say entomologists should judge what is actually good science, the rest of us? We do have valid if flawed memories of more insects previously. Combined with the invasive species, widespread pesticide use, and all this evidence, I don't think it's wise to slow-walk our response to such a pivotal biological foundation's crisis. We slow walked cigarettes, millions died. We slow walked climate, and we're on a path of worst outcomes. Shall insects be another failure of humans to respond? When do the skeptical technicians lay down their doubtful instincts and push for change?
- pfdietz 5y ago"Anyone with eyeballs" is clearly below the threshold.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mandmandam 5y agoNot in this case. I really don't know how anyone can deny the massive cuts in insect numbers. Even if you missed the news about bees dying, even if you don't follow the science showing unprecedented and extremely alarming drops in biomass and species counts, even if you haven't noticed the loss of fireflies and mantises and crickets, even if you haven't noticed the extreme drop-off in bugs on windscreens - how the fuck do you ignore everyone else talking about these things?
- ABCLAW 5y agoI think this is interesting because it's such a common issue on this board. You can tell when people are requesting evidence to shut down a discussion vs. to broaden a discussion by the way they reply - if they bring in their own counter evidence and address the points being raised they're probably engaging in good faith and using evidence to find nuance.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- staticassertion 5y agoI think it's OK to say "hey we need to really think about our usage of pesticides" and less ok to say "anyone with eyeballs can tell". I don't recall there being more/ less insects at any given point in my life, I haven't noticed anything at all in that regard. I'm completely willing to believe that insecticide use is bad and that there are less insects, fwiw.
- ruined 5y agowe're soaked. rain was in the forecast. i say it's really coming down out here, you tell me to wait for the inches measured at seatac
- rootusrootus 5y agoIf you want to make policy based on the rain, yeah, I'd prefer to wait for it. Otherwise your 'really coming down out here' might be my 'light drizzle.' Especially if you've ever lived in the midwest.
- ABCLAW 5y agoOkay, go nuts: More than 75 percent decline over 27 years in total flying insect biomass in protected areas https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0185809 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- rootusrootus 5y agoI've read it. There has been a huge backlash over that paper, from actual scientists critical of the methodology and conclusions. They make a compelling case that this one particular study should be taken with a grain of salt.
- ABCLAW 5y agoAll of the backlash I've seen over the paper has to do with the precision and effect sizes measured - I haven't seen an argument, let alone a credible argument, that the effect itself is not real. Follow-up research has confirmed that the effect is real and significant: Arthropod decline in grasslands and forests is associated with landscape-level drivers https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-019-1684-3 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-019-1684-3 The follow-up indicates that the effect sizes are greatest for agricultural areas.
- sjwalter 5y agoThis is hilarious. "Actual science", presumably meaning, "peer reviewed paper". Science is not some elitist endeavor. It is available to all of us, to observe the world around us and form hypotheses and discuss them and test them, if we're motivated and it's possible. This attitude is so, so bizarre. You won't believe the changes in the world around you, easily observed, are even happening unless there's "Science The Meme" being done about it. This short youtube video succinctly explains the problem with this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CqEhPFIlH3U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CqEhPFIlH3U
- esyir 5y agoWhen people say this, my main gripe is that it's used to legitimise anecdote, rather than well structured citizen science. The key thing that separates well constructed datasets from shoddy anecdote is a keen eye for potential confounders and proper data metrics and collection protocols.
- zhynn 5y agoAnother datapoint is dead-bugs-on-windshield. It's so many fewer than there used to be.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThere are confounding factors for this observation. Many insects move very little (like dozens or hundreds of yards) over the course of their lives and increased salt usage has increased the number of roads with seriously disturbed ecosystems along side them and width of said disturbed areas. I'm not saying pesticides aren't the cause or aren't part of the cause but roads have all sorts of other terrible stuff that can decimate insect populations going on. The sooner we switch to beet juice the better.
- pfdietz 5y agoAnother confounding factor is requirements for increasing gas mileage. One way to do that is reduce wind resistance, which could mean a more sloped windshield with less turbulent airflow. Insects could just be diverted more effectively now without striking the windshield.
- drran 5y agoOld cars are still on the road. Even very old ones.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- handrous 5y agoOwned a sleek and sporty (styled, anyway) '98 sedan, around the turn of the millennium. Just as with my parents' cars in the 80s and 90s, the windshield got splattered all the time. Had to clean it on road trips. Owned a far less-sleek '01 minivan... from like 2015 on, not when it was new. Near-zero "ew" bug impacts, even on road trips. I'm not sure I ever cleaned the windshield at a gas pump, which used to be routine.
- refurb 5y agoThat’s not how science works.
- harpiaharpyja 5y agoNo. He's referring to direct observation.