4 ms·
Let me get this straight- the iPhone will now scan your iCloud account and compute hashes for images. These hashes are then compared against a known database of
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago
Let me get this straight- the iPhone will now scan your iCloud account and compute hashes for images. These hashes are then compared against a known database of child abuse images. When a certain threshold of "hits" is reached then steps are taken to notify authorities?
There seems to be little chance of false positives here. I keep seeing references to machine learning algos and that's not what they are doing at all. I do still lament losing yet more control though. A device that I buy should not be working for somebody else, for better or worse.
CSAM is not new and is already in widespread use. The difference here just seems to be that your device itself will sell you out.
Edit: Follow up question- They run this on images before they are uploaded to iCloud. Why has Apple chosen to do this on-device rather than just run it in iCloud? They say for privacy reasons:
'Apple’s method of detecting known CSAM is designed with user privacy in mind.'
- whitepaint 5y agoIsn't this very very silly? You just need to change one pixel and the hash will be different.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- krapp 5y agoNo, perceptual hashes don't work that way. It's a comparison of similarity to a target, not just making an MD5 hash of an image. Here's Apple's documentation on it : https://www.apple.com/child-safety/pdf/CSAM_Detection_Technical_Summary.pdf https://www.apple.com/child-safety/pdf/CSAM_Detection_Techni...
- whitepaint 5y agoOh nice, didn't know about this.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoVery helpful. Thanks! Will give this a read.
- dosshell 5y agoThats not how it works. The fingerprints/hashes do not need be exactly the same. Just close enough. The fingerprint/hash is designed to not change much if the pictures are similar. Simplified: If you draw a circle and i draw a circle, their fingerprints will be closer then if I would have drawn a rectangle.
- hermannj314 5y agoBased on an article I found from 2015 on MD5, it takes about $0.65 in compute and 10-12 hours to make small mods to an image to achieve an arbitrary hash. I dont know this hash used here, but would it be reasonable to create a 'make small changes to this image until it has this hash value'? If so, there will be false positives but they will be intentional. Black hat can send a collection of 100 modified but innocent meme images with nefarious hashes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]