3 ms·
Pretty sure they predicted the collapse of another ocean current like 5 years ago, yet here we are.
by refurb 5y ago
Pretty sure they predicted the collapse of another ocean current like 5 years ago, yet here we are.
- sadness3 5y agoHas never happened != will never happen.
- refurb 5y agoYes, but when predictions fail to materialize one needs to weigh future predictions appropriately.
- dubcanada 5y agolol would you prefer it to have happened? I am not fully sure you understand the implications... Also these things are HUGE and require A LOT to mess with them. It can take decades, just the same as it probably took centuries for it to start.
- midrus 5y agoYou're wasting your time. These negationist dumbasses are everywhere and doesn't matter how much you explain or how many proof you have. They will counter argument you with a link to a Twitter of some random Illuminati or similar.
- CapmCrackaWaka 5y agoYou are being downvoted for what I see as a fairly logical comment. The problem that climate change researchers keep running into is that these things are extremely hard to predict, and predictions are sometimes embarrassingly incorrect[1]. So, here is another doomsday prediction. As someone who whole-heartedly believes climate change is happening and is a very real threat, I am forced to take this article with a big grain of salt, unfortunately, unless there is an immense amount of evidence to the contrary. Also, I don't want people to assume that I am arguing 'these scientists have been wrong in the past, so they will be wrong in the future'. That is definitely not what I am saying. But at this point it is a frustrating boy-cried-wolf situation with these predictions. [1] https://www.cnn.com/2020/01/08/us/glaciers-national-park-2020-trnd/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/01/08/us/glaciers-national-park-202...
- shuger 5y agoWhen I was a kid I kept hearing in the media that in 20 years oceans levels will rise by 7meters which would mean the big cities near me would be under water. 20 years have passed and water level is the same. The problem is there is two issues: 1. Is climate change real - this can be easily verified with observation, and there is solid science proving this. 2. What will happen in the future - here we have tons of research that would not fly in other domains as it is not verifiable experimentally until it actually happens. This are just hypothesis about extremely complex system we do not fully understand. And it should be viewed us such.
- ben_w 5y agoWho was predicting a mere 20 years for 7m? Around 2001 I was only hearing about 1-2m by the end of the century. I do see a lot of wildly misleading claims in newspapers, including where the research institutes the newspapers claim to be citing release statements specifically denying what the newspapers claim they’ve said, and I’ve been confounded by comments sections under those stories where other readers read only the false interpretations and not the actual words of the researchers.
- pvaldes 5y ago> 20 years have passed and water level is the same Are you sure? https://sealevelrise.org/states/ https://sealevelrise.org/states/
- mschaef 5y agoIt's a large system and operates on timescales that are at least generational in human terms. So it feels slow to us, even if it's very, very fast in geologic times.
- refurb 5y agoImminent collapse means?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ben_w 5y agoIn this context, “imminent” can be 20-100 years. Here’s a graph of historic CO2 levels over recent geological history, note that 2008 and (forecasts for) 2100 are the same column of pixels: https://blueskiesmeteorology.com/carbon-dioxide-at-400-ppm-what-does-it-mean/ https://blueskiesmeteorology.com/carbon-dioxide-at-400-ppm-w...
- mschaef 5y ago> Imminent collapse means? Nothing without more context.
- surfsvammel 5y agoComments like this add absolutely nothing to the discussion. You are ‘pretty sure’ someone predicted something similar some time? What value does that bring to the table?
- mrow84 5y agoIt would have been the AMOC, which is the most significant component of the overturning circulation system in the global ocean, and the one whose weakening would have a clearest and most immediate impact. Unfortunately, predicting its behaviour is difficult, for a variety of reasons. However, that doesn't mean such predictions should not be made, nor that alarm bells shouldn't be rung when it appears that things might be going awry, especially given the AMOC's global significance. Surely we can agree that insisting on only considering dangers of which we are entirely certain is a foolish approach to risk management?
- Strilanc 5y agoThis sort of comment should include a source showing the 5 year old prediction. (For example, there'd be a big difference between a five year old article saying "we're worried this thing is going to collapse over the next two decades" and one saying "this will collapse by 2017". Also it matters if it's a peer reviewed publication, a pop sci article, some rando youtube video talking about another youtube video, or etc. But there's no way to tell from your comment unless you give a source.)
- refurb 5y agohttps://www.providencejournal.com/news/20170104/global-ocean-circulation-could-collapse-study-says https://www.providencejournal.com/news/20170104/global-ocean... Unspecified timeline. I mean, someone could say “asteroid could hit earth and end civilization” but that’s not actionable and this useless information.
- Strilanc 5y agoThank you. As far as I can tell, based on the mentioned author name and year and topic, that article is talking about the paper "Overlooked possibility of a collapsed Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation in warming climate" by Liu et al [1]. I'm not a climate scientist but I read the intro and discussion section of the paper. They're talking about existing models assuming AMOC will stay stable when maybe it won't, and they present a model where it collapses after 300 years if you set CO2 at double 1990 levels. So the paper does specify a timeline, but it's a centuries long timeline in a model mainly intended to clearly demonstrate an effect they want future research to model correctly. (In particular, they don't seem to be making a prediction about the actual timeline in the real world.) Seeing real world warning signs that AMOC might collapse would be very much in line with this paper's thesis of "we should be modeling the possibility that AMOC might collapse". And I disagree that the paper is failing to make actionable suggestions: they're suggesting to improve models to account for a specific effect. 1: https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/advances/3/1/e1601666.full.pdf https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/advances/3/1/e160166...
- Popegaf 5y agoWhich ocean current, when was it predicted to collapse, and what do they mean by collapse?