4 ms·
Apple are proposing to do it on your phone. There is no possible way they are not going to do it to everything on your phone. That's a big policy change, since
by XorNot 5y ago
Apple are proposing to do it on your phone. There is no possible way they are not going to do it to everything on your phone.
That's a big policy change, since they're circumventing their own E2EE using their super-admin powers to do it.
The barrier when uploading to unencrypted services is that you are at least aware you're granting access. This is invading the phone to do it anyway - that's quite different.
But more importantly: when flagged this is going to send the results to human reviewers. Which has not been elaborated on: there's no way human reviewers can screen things without being sent a copy of the image in question. Which means, a neural network system is going to randomly send your personal images to human reviewers - and it will, largely, be false positives.
Note that Apple are not discussing anything about the reliability of this system: have they run it against a sample set of normal images? How many did it flag? Because, if they give a number, it'll be pretty easy for people to realize that some % multiplied by the number of phones and average number of images per phone, and I'm willing to bet what you get is: the system will false positive at least (and probably more then 1) personal photo per iPhone user, and send it to human reviewers.
And that might get people's attention: certainly more then just, unfortunately, us techies.
EDIT:
And let's talk about these human reviewers: these are not random citizens seeing something and wondering if they should be concerned. The context these people are going to be given is possible child abuse image. This is not a neutral review process - at all.