4 ms·
There is a complicated legal and political process because there are a lot of things which are criminal that really shouldn't be. Historically, the law has been
by roenxi 5y ago
There is a complicated legal and political process because there are a lot of things which are criminal that really shouldn't be. Historically, the law has been used to come down hard on people who:
* Say bad things about the king.
* Said good things about the king.
* Are homosexual and attempting to live their life.
* Are black and attempting to live their life.
* Are foreign, regardless of activity.
* Are female and attempting to own property.
* Are local but not the right type of local.
* The actual person is OK but they're trying to help the Jews.
* Own the wrong book.
* Worship the wrong god.
And in hindsight it is generally agreed that those laws were poorly thought out. Giving the police tools to enforce 100% compliance with the law is by no means a sane thing to do. And if that is the plan it would behove us to make sure the law is good first. Which it obviously isn't there are gaping holes in every legal system.
- anticodon 5y agoWhat has really changed? Now in the West there're just as many taboos. You can't openly discuss lots of things. Maybe there's no criminal penalty for this (although in some EU countries there's already a criminal penalty for wrong^H^H^H hate speech, same is planned in Canada), but by saying "wrong" things you'll be expelled from society, expelled from your job. Is taking one taboo and just turning it upside down actually good? Punishing homosexuals was wrong but is forcing people to change gender, brainwashing children with homosexual propaganda and persuading children to change the gender by chemical and surgical means better? I predict that in 5-10 years in USA it would become obligatory to participate in "pride parades". People who avoid them would be put on "the list". This situation is not symmetrical and it looks absurd. There's a writer famous in Russia - Victor Pelevin. In his last book he stated something that was almost obvious to us: USA now is the same totalitarian society as was USSR. «Современная Америка — это тоталитарный совок 1979 года с ЛГБТ на месте комсомола, корпоративным менеджментом на месте КПСС, сексуальной репрессией на месте сексуальной репрессии и зарей социализма на месте зари социализма». Но разница в том, что «в совок 1979 года можно было привезти джинсы из Америки, а сегодняшняя Америка — это такой совок, в который джинсы уже никто не привезет». «Американская культура в современном виде — это проект ГРУ. Яд "novichok" отравил североамериканскую душу и заструился обратно в Россию. (…) Когда все, связанное с Россией, демонизировано на Западе, сетевые дурочки, прививающие здесь американскую культурную репрессию под зычный храп ФСБ, кажутся по-своему трогательными: геройкам слава! Но если рассказать им, что на самом деле они внедряют созданные ГРУ химеры, они столкнутся с таким сарказмом судьбы, который перенесет не всякая душа», — пишет в своем романе Голгофский. (too long to translate, but basically: "Contemporary USA is a totalitarian Soviet state from 1979 with LGBT in place of comsomol, corporate management in place of Communist Party, sexual repression in place of sexual repression, and dawn of socialism in place of dawn of socialism. But the big difference is that it was possible to bring jeans and bubble gum from USA into Soviet state of 1979, while there's no place from where you can bring "jeans" into contemporary USA" (mocking the myth that jeans and bubble gum were tokens of western "freedom" in USSR).
- ptato 5y agoNobody is forcing people to change their gender or brainwashing children with homosexual propaganda. You should examine your biases.
- s0q 5y agoMaybe you should read the news on the other side of the fence. In the UK, LGBT training is a compulsory class for children. Many Muslim families are pulling their children out of school because they're not being given the choice to withdraw their children from classes where opinions about sexuality are being presented as fact in contrary to the principles they want to raise their child with. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-48294017 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-48294017
- bgeeek 5y agoMany? You sure about that? Also, "opinions about sexuality are being presented as fact in contrary to the principles they want to raise their child with". How do you think things like that help? We want a tolerant and inclusive society, thank-you. I know gay Muslims in the UK. Can you imagine what life is like for them?
- wizzwizz4 5y ago> In the UK, LGBT training is a compulsory class for children. This is way overhyped. It's barely more than “gay people exist, don't bully them” most places. One lesson in PSHE class – maybe two or three, if you get lucky and your teachers decide to teach you about binary trans people too, or if sexuality is mentioned in the Equality Act lesson (which mostly focuses on disability and maternity leave). > opinions about sexuality are being presented as fact By this logic, we should ban other children from talking about their religions in schools; they're likely to say things like “Jesus is God” or “God isn't real”. It's unlikely a religious child would get particularly confused with a teacher exposing them to different views on morality, given how much they're already exposed to that.
- ptato 5y agoWhat does "LGBT training" mean? What I gather is that what they are teaching kids is, in essence, "be kind to each other". Do these families that are protesting not have the same biases against gay people that the person I originally responded to has?