2 ms·
> say a chocolate bar contains 80% chocolate and 20% food wax. A year later it contains 70% chocolate and 30% food wax. No inflation measure in the world accura
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> say a chocolate bar contains 80% chocolate and 20% food wax. A year later it contains 70% chocolate and 30% food wax. No inflation measure in the world accurately measures that. You can't measure for it because there's too many judgement calls if you do.
I think the bigger problem is that it's difficult to tell when this happens. There are judgment calls you need to make to adjust for this, but it's not an intractable problem. Official data sources have to make more subjective judgment calls than this constantly.
- amrcnimgrnt 5y agoThis is a huge problem, thank you for writing it down. Grab a Hershey chocolate bar. How much chocolate is in there? Who knows?
- def_true_false 5y agoIt's somewhat easier to measure if you ignore brands and look at commodity prices instead. Whole chicken (price per kg) instead of Big Mac, 100% cocoa instead of some random chocolate bar, etc. Of course, for many (most?) people, that will be even less relevant than the current consumer basket.
- amrcnimgrnt 5y agoBut that skips all the processing steps whose price can increase before it makes it to my plate. For example, tracking bulk beef prices won't capture the labor costs of the would-be-butcher COSTCO can't hire.
- def_true_false 5y agoI don't see why not? It just has to be more specific -- chicken breast requires processing, but one is pretty much like another, unlike say, some morning cereal from TV ads. Actually that might be a good heuristic, I don't remember the last time I bought food that even has ads. The store itself does have some ads that feature some of the items, I guess.