2 ms·
This article is irresponsible hand-waving. “ When Apple releases these “client-side scanning” functionalities, users of iCloud Photos, child users of iMessage,
by Spooky23 5y ago
This article is irresponsible hand-waving.
“ When Apple releases these “client-side scanning” functionalities, users of iCloud Photos, child users of iMessage, and anyone who talks to a minor through iMessage will have to carefully consider their privacy and security priorities in light of the changes, and possibly be unable to safely use what until this development is one of the preeminent encrypted messengers.”
People sending messages to minors that trigger a hash match have more fundamental things to consider, as they are sending known photos of child exploitation to a minor.
The EFF writer knows this, as they describe the feature in the article. They should be ashamed of publishing this crap.
- itake 5y ago> they are sending known photos of child exploitation to a minor How do you know its a known photo of child exploitation? The original image that was hashed and then deleted. Two completely different images have the same hash. WhatsApp automatically saves images to photos. What if you receive a bad image and are reported due to someone else sending the image to you?
- Spooky23 5y agoYou’re obliged to report that image to the police. These types of images are contraband.
- itake 5y ago> You’re obliged to report that image to the police. Is this a legal obligation for all countries that iPhones operate in? I wasn't able to find a law via a quick google search for the US. For US law, are there protections for people that report the contraband? I'm not sure if good samaritan or whistle blower laws protect you.
- morpheuskafka 5y agoYou’ve got it mixed up. The messages are scanned for any explicit material (which in many but not all cases is illegal), not specific hash matches. That’s only for uploads to iCloud Photos. Additionally, you are not “obliged” to report such photos to the police. Uninvolved service providers do have to submit some sort of report iirc, but to require regular users to do so would raise Fifth Amendment concerns.
- Spooky23 5y agoNo, I’m not. You’re confusing the issues. If you have a child’s account, joined to your family group, you will get alerted about explicit images — if you decide to use it. The photos that you are obliged to report are child pornography that match a hash in a database used everywhere. If you don’t report, you’re in a place where you may have criminal liability.