4 ms·
I cannot shake some fondness for those old blocky UIs. It's so less capable than 2020s js/css3 but still it's so grounded to me.
by agumonkey 5y ago
I cannot shake some fondness for those old blocky UIs. It's so less capable than 2020s js/css3 but still it's so grounded to me.
- ant6n 5y agoWhat's less capable about it? To me it looks less slick, but in terms of affordances it's way better.
- agumonkey 5y agodom + css (+ layered compositing) is an extremely versatile and free form UI system the old ui widgets can't really (I assume) vary that much in properties or location (the layouting is stricter and will break if you push it too hard)
- herio 5y agoYou'd be surprised how flexible some of the GUI toolkits on the Amiga actually were. MUI is based on the concept that layout is dynamic and flexible. It would dynamically calculate a minimum window size based on the components inside and you could then resize the window as you wanted with things calculating and resizing as you go, adapting to font selections and themes. The actual implementation is archaic by todays standards but it did use attributes on UI objects to determine min/max sizing and other things, similar to CSS in concept.
- agumonkey 5y agooh ok, I assumed wrong. Is there any video I can see about that ?
- agent327 5y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNEwb7eRmXo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNEwb7eRmXo Sadly no font sensitivity on display (possibly because Amiga owners take it so much for granted that they don't think of it as special), but it shows what MUI can do in terms of GUI elements, window resizing, etc. After leaving the Amiga for Windows, the three biggest things I hated about its GUI were all those endless non-resizeable windows, the complete lack of font sensitivity, and the horrible scrollbars that didn't show your actual content size (and that snapped back if you moved out of some invisible box). And here we are, twenty years later, and nothing has improved at all...
- tomxor 5y agoThey are far more capable. UI is a strange type of visual functionality. The late 80s and 90s UIs manage to minimise ambiguity and make implied function painfully clear... never did anyone hunt for a button amongst a sea of non-interactive content in any of these UIs. To be blunt, a lot of modern UI are like pretty glass Norman doors... lest you dirty our pretty frosted glass with your filthy hands for the sake of usability, what will the stake holders think! I am not blind to aesthetics, but I believe form should emerge from function, as per Dieter Rams. Hopefully we will swing back towards prioritising function, but it doesn't have to look dated.
- agumonkey 5y agoI agree, the current era got drunk on visuals and capabilities (animations that quickly stop providing any useful value). It's also a sign of over-mainstreamification of computing. Old layouts required you to think just a little more upfront I believe, now it's a very playful but less efficient.