4 ms·
I'm confused about your position on this, though: the amendment in question ensures certain cryptocurrency-related activities won't be taxed. I agree that we s
by kelnos 5y ago
I'm confused about your position on this, though: the amendment in question ensures certain cryptocurrency-related activities won't be taxed.
I agree that we shouldn't be banning this sort of thing, but if people want to throw electricity at it in ways that I consider a huge waste of resources, I'd really like to see that taxed better. And not in a regressive way that makes every electricity user pay more.
> Obviously HN community is down on crypto.
I don't really think that's true, and please remember that the HN community is not homogeneous, and various people have very different (and strong) opinions on many things. I'm personally not a fan of cryptocurrency (I think it's a waste of time and effort, and to top it off it's currently an environmental disaster), but the top comments on this article are relatively positive right now.
I believe @dang has mentioned often that early comments on most articles end up being pretty negative, because the early posts will be more knee-jerk (which tends to bring out the worst reactions in people). Only after people have time to read and cool down will posts be more measured. This article was only posted an hour ago (at the time I'm writing this), so no surprise there's a lot of negativity here.
- saalweachter 5y ago> ... please remember that the HN community is not homogeneous, and various people have very different (and strong) opinions on many things. Honestly I'm not sure I consider HN a "community" in the same way I consider other online ... communities, communities. With notably rare exceptions you don't have a lot of sharing of personal milestones, and while you might occasionally "recognize" a poster (and we have a few "famous" ones) it's much easier to deal with each comment as a stand-alone statement without any provenance. Even meta-discussion about the nature of HN like this seems a bit gauche and is discouraged.
- macawfish 5y agoNo no no, the amendment doesn't say that those activities can't be taxed, it clarifies that there won't be KYC requirements on people who literally can't comply with them. The issue here isn't about what activities should be taxed, it's about overly broad KYC reporting requirements. Pretend the original provision was about ATMs... the language could be used to argue that armored truck drivers should be required to collect personal information and transaction data for every user of every ATM they deliver cash to. Obviously that's not really possible and would be a huge privacy issue. The risk people are seeing here is that the current language could be abused to make ATMs illegal altogether, since nobody would want to risk getting in trouble during the process of stocking them.