3 ms·
For anyone saying "the system is broken" a challenge: Provide a design for some system that is not broken and never will be. You can't stop at "at least fix it
by AlbertCory 5y ago
For anyone saying "the system is broken" a challenge:
Provide a design for some system that is not broken and never will be. You can't stop at "at least fix it so this doesn't happen."
The most important question for you is: how will this system be staffed? Can non-college-educated people be hired? Will it be unionized? How much will the staff be paid, and can you attract the sort of staff you want with that salary? Or will you get TSA-level people?
How will disputes be adjudicated? Via civil lawsuits, arbitration boards, or what?
Will the heads of it be elected or appointed?
The point of this is that "the system" doesn't exist as pages in a textbook. It also doesn't exist in Denmark. It exists in the real US. Some systems work out better than others, but they all bear the thumbprints of actual hands.
- aaron-santos 5y agoAs much as it's nice to provide a solution along with evidence that something's broken, it isn't a requirement. Knowing something is broken is a different skill than fixing it. It's the reason we have mechanics, doctors, and QA to name a few. I'm willing to bet there are much more socio-political creative types that can imagine systems much better than I can. After all, I'm just a layperson in that domain. Challenging lay people is exactly as absurd as challenging them to come up with a fix for their join pain before consulting a doctor.
- munificent 5y ago> Knowing something is broken is a different skill than fixing it. This is a fair point. But I think many people saying "the system is broken" implicitly or explicitly advocate a fix by throwing out the entire system. Those people often don't seem to realize that "no system" is a system too, and you need to compare that system's emergent behavior to the current system before you can make a wise choice.
- AlbertCory 5y agoExactly. It's fair to propose minor tweaks to a system while (implicitly) admitting that it's fine otherwise. It's quite something else to say "the system is broken" while having no idea whatsoever how some new system would avoid all those problems.
- AlbertCory 5y agoNo, actually, it isn't. It's more like "I assert that my joint was badly designed by evolution and a competent human could make it better" without having any actual ideas how it might be better. Your examples are also flawed. Mechanics and doctors fix one instance of a system. They are not charged with fixing all of them.
- aaron-santos 5y agoOk, car designers, and bio medical engineers then. Hope that makes more sense for you.
- x86_64Ubuntu 5y agoNo one needs all of this. The man's fingerprints didn't match and it would have been easy to verify. They chose not to.
- AlbertCory 5y agoOK. So if he gets paid a very large cash settlement, and maybe the people responsible for his case are disciplined or fired or sent to jail, then that solves the problem? Or are you asking for something more general?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 5y ago"The system should be better" can coexist with "the system cannot be perfect".
- dennis_jeeves 5y ago>Some systems work out better than others, but they all bear the thumbprints of actual hands. Yep, ultimately any system will be only as good as the people manning it. No amount or reworking a "system" will help it beyond a point.