4 ms·
> it is said to increase the risks of cardiovascular diseases How? Salt is a convenient bogeyman, but nobody can demonstrate what it role it plays as an agent
by kevin_thibedeau 5y ago
> it is said to increase the risks of cardiovascular diseases
How? Salt is a convenient bogeyman, but nobody can demonstrate what it role it plays as an agent of disease. Every cell in your body regulates isotonic balance and excess sodium is rapidly excreted. Complex lifeforms wouldn't exist without this fundamental ability.
- Mikeb85 5y agoIt was demonized because of the vast quantities contained in many processed foods but you're right and to add to that you'll die much quicker from a lack of salt than from excess salt.
- sithadmin 5y agoThe link between high sodium intake and elevated blood pressure is well documented. This is mostly because of the attempt of body systems to maintain isotonic balance. There’s also a signficant portion of the population with a genetic predisposition to have above-average increases in blood pressure shortly after consuming large amounts of salt, to the point that it will even cause hypertension in some people that had otherwise normal blood pressure. Salt -> elevated blood pressure -> complicating factor in pulmonary and cardiac disease.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoIt is very simple. If you suffer from high blood pressure (above 140/90mm Hg) and your sodium intake is considerable, your blood pressure rises even more. You can easily set up a study with a control group and test it repeatedly, the results will be the same. However, the mitigating factor is potassium. If you consume an adequate amount of foods rich in potassium, the negative effect of sodium on your blood pressure is neutralized somehow. The exact behaviors depend on the amounts of each. And here's the problem: in salt, sodium is very concentrated. You would have to eat a large amount of foods considered rich in potassium, such as tomatoes, in order to neutralize a teaspoon of salt.
- sithadmin 5y agoYou don’t even have to have high blood pressure for above ‘normal’ (~2000mg/day) salt intake to create the effect. It’s observable in people with normal blood pressure as well, and pronounced in a subset of the population with a gene that appears to worsen the effect. The potassium factor is why many doctors often recommend sea/himalayan salt — these salts usually have a bunch of other minerals, including potassium. For anyone wondering, no, it’s not a good idea to try to self medicate the combination of high blood pressure + a sodium heavy diet with potassium supplements. Do it wrong and you’ll end up with hyperkalemia, which is both very uncomfortable and potentially life-threatening.
- unmole 5y ago> doctors often recommend sea/himalayan salt Himalayan salt is 99% sodium chloride and doesn't contain significant potassium to make a difference. Someone recommending it as a healthier alternative should not be taken seriously.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y ago> If you suffer from high blood pressure People who already have a disease that requires salt regulation doesn't prove any causative role.
- danaris 5y ago> If you suffer from high blood pressure (above 140/90mm Hg) and your sodium intake is considerable, your blood pressure rises even more. You can easily set up a study with a control group and test it repeatedly, the results will be the same. How do you square this with jonasmerlin's sibling post of a Scientific American article, pointing out that the foundations of this belief do not stand on rigorous science?
- Justin_K 5y agoEXCESS salt raises BP, which raises the chances of a cardio event. Excess sodium is not rapidly excreted, in fact the body requires far more hydration to balance it out. https://www.heart.org/en/healthy-living/healthy-eating/eat-smart/sodium/sodium-and-salt https://www.heart.org/en/healthy-living/healthy-eating/eat-s...
- failwhaleshark 5y ago"Nobody" but countless doctors and scientists of the AHA. "The AHA recommendation to reduce salt intake is based on strong science, not just extrapolations or complex math," Sacco says. "There have even been randomized trials, the strongest evidence we have that show people who follow lower-sodium diets have lower blood pressure and fewer heart attacks and strokes." https://www.webmd.com/heart-disease/news/20110504/study-shows-salty-diet-good-heart-group-disagrees https://www.webmd.com/heart-disease/news/20110504/study-show...
- nomel 5y ago> Every cell in your body regulates isotonic balance and excess sodium is rapidly excreted. If I eat something salty for dinner, I wake up with swollen eyes, with others in my immediate family doing the same. My family uses very little to no salt. My wife can eat as much salt as she wants, without any visible effect at all. Her family uses, in my perspective, extreme amounts of salt. My naive assumption is that salt sensitivity is somewhat genetic, with research suggesting the same [1]. Maybe related, near hypotension runs in my family, while hypertension runs in hers. 1. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/07/180705115632.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/07/180705115632.h...
- wins32767 5y agoHigher salt levels raise blood pressure. High blood pressure leads the body to strengthen blood vessel walls, which make them less flexible. Less flexible blood vessels put more strain on the heart, which in cardiac patients (who are operating with a damaged heart) is obviously suboptimal. There is a ton of studies about this and heart patient life expectancies have been going up for the last several decades because we have figured this (and a few other things) out.
- spfzero 5y agoSalt is something regulated well in all higher organisms. Probably dating from when we evolved in a salt-water ocean. That said, in a modern diet with lots of sodium, but also lots less of other important minerals like magnesium, potassium, etc., who knows? Probably depends on the totality of the diet, for instance if you are getting a lot of salt "artificially", and eating an otherwise nutrient-poor diet, maybe lowering salt intake is a good thing. But if you are eating a varied and mostly natural diet, so that you're getting a wide variety of vitamins, minerals, sun-exposure etc., your absolute sodium intake may not matter much.