3 ms·
Who the heck is buying these VMs that cost 5x real hardware? Right. This has already been tried in the "game streaming" business. There have been multiple serv
by Animats 5y ago
Who the heck is buying these VMs that cost 5x real hardware?
Right. This has already been tried in the "game streaming" business. There have been multiple services where you rent a PC in "the cloud" by the hour, or for some number of hours per month. Either they cost too much, and fail for lack of customers, or they are underpriced as a loss leader, and get shut down after losing money. Google Stadia and NVidia Cloud Gaming are currently live, but Stadia is likely to join Google's list of discontinued products, and NVidia's offering involves being kicked off if you stay connected too long.
- skeeter2020 5y agoselling dekstop pcs to businesses is totally different than selling gaming to consumers.
- hogFeast 5y agoIt isn't. Some of the companies that do the latter are also doing the former.
- Closi 5y agoYou are talking about Microsoft and Google - two of the largest computing companies on the planet. By the same logic, you could say that game streaming is like a search engine, because some of the companies that do the latter are also doing the former. The idea of provisioning remote cloud VMs is far older than Stadia or Xbox Cloud anyway.
- hogFeast 5y agoI am not talking Microsoft or Google. There are lots of smaller companies that provide this service. Your point about game streaming being like a search engine is nonsensical.
- Closi 5y agoExactly, just because two or more companies offer both game streaming and VMs doesn’t necessarily mean that those things are similar. They may be, or may not be, but your logic to say that they are similar isn’t right (otherwise other product lines must be similar by extension).
- hogFeast 5y agoRight, but these are small companies that offer no other services. In both cases, they just offer VMs. Game streaming is a VM. I am not talking about Microsoft and Google. I know a guy who runs one of these companies: they offer VMs for gaming, they offer VMs for offices, the machines are set up identically.
- KMnO4 5y agoI play video games about 8 hours per month. At 40c per hour, it would cost me less than $40/year to rent a gaming computer in the cloud. Even $400/year seems pretty reasonable. It’s only not cost effective if you use it a lot (which is the case for most pay-per-use commodities).
- sofixa 5y ago> NVidia's offering involves being kicked off if you stay connected too long. 8 hours, which is a pretty decent gaming session. You can reconnect just afterwards anyways. > but Stadia is likely to join Google's list of discontinued products Highly unlikely, they're spending tens of millions to get EA and Ubisoft's catalogues on Stadia. In any case, cloud gaming works, sells, and is very useful for some subset of users, even more so with the ongoing global chip shortage. I have both Geforce Now and Stadia and I'm very happy with them. Playing on my laptop and TV ( with a Chromecast) is great. Playing from my phone in a hotel room is a fun experience. Stadia even makes financial sense, because there's a free version ( at 1080p/30fps), you only need to buy the games ( which you would anyways regardless of the platform), saving you hundreds of (insert currency) in the process. The paid one is 10 eur/usd/month for better quality and some free games. And if you're the type of person that wants 4K 120Hz 60fps, this isn't for you and isn't the point.
- sbierwagen 5y ago>Highly unlikely, they're spending tens of millions to get EA and Ubisoft's catalogues on Stadia. Loon also cost tens of millions, made no sense, and was eventually canceled.