3 ms·
But Samsung hasn't lost yet and IMHO it was a stupid move from Apple's part -- besides the fact that Samsung also produces chips for them, Samsung has the right
by bad_user 15y ago
But Samsung hasn't lost yet and IMHO it was a stupid move from Apple's part -- besides the fact that Samsung also produces chips for them, Samsung has the right patents to counter-sue; and they are doing just that. Apple also sued Nokia, but they ended up paying royalties to them anyway.
Do a little exercise -- try patenting something worthy that people may want to "copy" and then go to IBM telling them "fuck you IBM, I patented this so you can't use it". You'll give them a good laugh ;-)
And if IBM ever thought about copying the iPhone, even if it made the most faithful replica ever including naming it something like "xPhone", there's practically nothing Apple could do without effectively getting bitch-slapped.
Also, the term "copy" itself is misleading: it makes people think that new developments should be original, when clearly nothing is original or evolutionary. Everybody copies from everybody.
The patents system is terribly broken and rewording the current mess as something moral and just is really ignoring reality.
- jsnell 15y ago> Apple also sued Nokia, but they ended up paying royalties to them anyway. The question there was never whether Apple would be paying, but how much. Given the pittance (a few euros per phone) Nokia apparently ended up getting with the best mobile patent portfolio in the world, it hardly seems like a win for Nokia or a loss for Apple. More likely it was Nokia being desperate to get the cash now to make their Q2 results look a little bit better.