15 ms·
Early Retirement (2006)
- flowerlad 5y agoHow much money can a Silicon Valley software engineer expect to have at retirement? This article says $7 million: https://www.wealthmeta.com/blog/being-a-doctor-vs-being-a-software-developer-net-worth-simulations https://www.wealthmeta.com/blog/being-a-doctor-vs-being-a-so... Here's the back-of-the-envelope calculation: Annual salary: $250K (it is much higher at FAANG). Assume 25% tax (effective, not marginal), which leaves us with $187.5K, which is about $15K per month. Assume $5000 in monthly expenses, which leaves us with $10K per month investable money. (Note: since net worth includes house and 401(k) I have not deducted mortgage or 401(k) payments). So $10K includes those items.) Now use a compound interest calculator to see what $10K per month at 8% interest (assume investment in S&P 500 and allow for some market crashes) will result in, at the end of 30 years. It is about $14 million, which would include your house and your 401(k). Here's a spreadsheet that allows you to plug in your own numbers: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ryu_-mVYxSdJbW8lmf1z6tiOdNSYP3HaLu0YnW5-fCo/edit#gid=0 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ryu_-mVYxSdJbW8lmf1z...
- showerst 5y agoThose numbers are pretty optimistic for expenses if you live somewhere expensive, ever plan to get into a long term relationship and/or have kids, or ever plan to make a down payment on a house. I think your tax calculation is way low too, but haven't done the math.
- flowerlad 5y agoWho needs to spend more than $5000 per month, not including mortgage?
- rwilson4 5y agoPeople with kids. My daughter's preschool is more expensive than my college was!
- JKCalhoun 5y agoWait until your nest is empty.
- showerst 5y agoYou don't start out with a mortgage, unless have some unusual circumstances.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mikedouglas 5y agoWho has a mortgage without interest payments?
- robertlagrant 5y agoI think in the US the interest is deductible.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoA very small portion of people in the US benefit from the mortgage interest tax deduction ever since the standard deduction was greatly increased. You have to itemize (forego the standard deduction) in order to take advantage, and only 13% of tax filers itemize on their taxes in the US.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- colinmhayes 5y agoNo one needs to do anything, but most families living in silicon valley are probably spending more than 5k a month. 8% is also probably too high. S&P historical returns are 7%, plus 15% tax.
- bloaf 5y agoIf you do a little algebra and make some simple assumptions, it turns out that "years of work required for retirement" is a function of your savings ratio only, that is savings/take-home pay. https://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/01/13/the-shockingly-simple-math-behind-early-retirement/ https://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/01/13/the-shockingly-si...
- showerst 5y agoI like MMR, but like many people in that genre these over-simplified calculations only really work for a very narrow set of circumstances. What happens if you want to buy a condo in a competitive market that requires a 200k downpayment? Or have a medium-sized wedding? Or have two kids in day-care? I understand that the FIRE response would be that you don't _have_ to buy into all that stuff, but saying that it's just a little algebra and some simple assumptions is fantasy unless you want to live like a single 24 year old your whole life.
- tejohnso 5y ago> unless you want to live like a single 24 year old your whole life. Controlling expenses and living a humble life style is pretty much the opposite of living like a single 24 year old. At least for me and most of the single 24 year olds I knew back then. It takes wisdom and maturity to realize that you don't need all that stuff. And if you can find a partner with the same outlook, you can certainly avoid spending tens of thousands on a wedding, or buying a condo in a competitive market. And there should be no need for day care if you're retired.
- showerst 5y ago> It takes wisdom and maturity to realize that you don't need all that stuff This is _exactly_ what I take issue with. Look, "live below your means and be thoughtful about what spending will make you happier" is great advice. So is "plan for a future where you don't have to work". "Get a high paying remote job from a young age with no student loans, move somewhere cheap, actually find a partner there, don't dare find someone that makes teacher or non-professional salary or has health problems or student loans, wait until you're retired at 38 to have children, don't dare have kids with health problems or special needs, and lecture everyone else about how easy it is." is perhaps not the wise and mature advice you think it is. I'm just the right age (37) to have grown up alongside the FIRE thing. I have a number of friends who tried it, some of them to the point of being smarmy about it. 100% of them hit late twenties and realized that the combo of "making a high income while having very low expenses" involves significant trade-offs, and is super hard to keep up. All of my friends eventually abandoned it, but I don't think that's the rule. Describing FIRE as easy and saying that anyone who fails to do it is somehow less wise or immature is nonsense peddled by a bunch of people who retired early by writing "how to get retire early" blogs.
- ryandrake 5y agoThe salary numbers are very optimistic, too. A small number of tech workers at a small number of FAANG companies in a small number of locations, will be making $250K from the start or even average that much throughout their careers. I know, I know, everyone on HN makes $400K and drives a Ferarri, but that's very optimistic number for most people. EDIT: Also: house should not be included in your net worth for the purposes of calculating retirement draw-down, unless you plan to liquidate your home equity to live on.
- isthis129283 5y agoYou should subtract capital gains. Unless you know of a way to put $84k/year into a roth account.
- flowerlad 5y agoIf you invest in S&P 500 index fund you don't need to sell until after retirement.
- isthis129283 5y agoI agree. But a material chunk of the $14M belongs to the government (not available for the individual to spend). If someone takes out a $2M loan at the age of 58, and retires at 59 (before any of it is paid back), do you think that should be money considered in a retirement calculation?
- flowerlad 5y agoAny growth in the "government's portion" is yours until you sell. Also, if you sell after retirement the tax rate is going to be low if you don't have much non-investment income.
- isthis129283 5y agoI agree it's yours until you sell. We are just debating semantics (does retiring with $14M mean retiring with $14M you can spend, or $14M minus taxes that you can spend). Also, Capital gains is treated differently than ordinary income. Your income tax bracket is irrelevant in determining your capital gains rate (at least for now).
- neogodless 5y agohttps://www.nerdwallet.com/article/taxes/capital-gains-tax-rates https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/taxes/capital-gains-tax-r... Income tax bracket doesn't directly correspond with capital gains brackets, but total income affects the capital gains tax rate.
- awb 5y ago> Retirement forces you to stop thinking that it is your job that holds you back. For most people the depressing truth is that they aren't that organized, disciplined, or motivated. Maybe, but I don’t know anyone who’s less happy being retired. They might not be living their retirement fantasy, but the pressure and stress of having to work is gone.
- dagw 5y agoMaybe, but I don’t know anyone who’s less happy being retired. I've known lots of people who spiraled into various levels of depression after retirement. It's even more likely if the retirement wasn't voluntary.
- defaultname 5y agoRetirement is such a loaded word because to many it means "wealthy enough to do whatever they want", whereas traditionally it meant "no longer useful to employers". In the former case we have stories of 20-somethings "retiring", the word repurposed into just a meaningless boast. In the no longer useful to employers vein, in the working class town I grew up in there was a common observation that retirement was a harbinger of death. That when someone retired their lifestyle would quickly decline to sedentary decay, boredom medicated with alcohol (or other things). Death would quickly follow. As an aside, tangentially there's a wonderful passage from Mark Twain in Tom Sawyer - “Work consists of whatever a body is obliged to do. Play consists of whatever a body is not obliged to do.”
- Domenic_S 5y agoThe article discusses this. In part: > Americans cannot imagine stopping work before they've either (1) purchased everything that they could conceivably want, or (2) collapsed from physical exhaustion. If your material needs and desires are sufficiently low, and your resources sufficiently high, you could retire. Age or usefulness to an employer could be an upper bound, I suppose. I look at it like this: finances are like a bathtub. What you spend is the drain, your income (whether salary, interest, cap gains, etc) is the faucet, and your resources are the water in the tub. Retirement is the point where you can turn off (or turn down) the faucet and not run dry. Some people have big drainpipes and need a big tub and lots of water; others can live with a trickle.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoHe's always been an interesting chap. I wish him well. > Most important, do not retire in the expectation that it will be easy to find rewarding non-profit volunteer work. Thankfully, this has not been an issue with me. I definitely don't have the massive nest egg that another commenter mentioned, but I've got enough to avoid starving, and I am happier than I ever thought I'd be.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoThank you for writing this. I was worried that I was planning to retire soon but never made a $250K salary, will not have $7M.
- padobson 5y agoI have a church and spend some chunk of my active off-hours doing various activities there - maybe 10 hours a month. If I were to retire, I imagine that time would double or triple. That's how I'd recommend viewing non-profit work in advance of retirement. Is there a non-profit you're spending effort on now? Spend more effort there. If not, it's probably a good idea to examine your values and find some organizations that advance them and start helping out.
- MattGaiser 5y ago> How much work does the average college student get done? Almost none. Yet the same person, injected into a corporate bureaucracy, becomes a reasonably effective worker. Why? Most people have terrible time management skills. This limitation is of no consequence in public school. The school tells you where to sit and what to do and when, at least for six hours per day. This limitation is of no consequence at most jobs. The employer tells the workers where to sit and what to do and when, at least for eight hours per day. No, the average worker is not doing a lot of work. https://www.inc.com/melanie-curtin/in-an-8-hour-day-the-average-worker-is-productive-for-this-many-hours.html https://www.inc.com/melanie-curtin/in-an-8-hour-day-the-aver...
- giantg2 5y agoI agree, but it depends on what you consider work. The author in your quote is implying that in public school you get a lot of work done. I don't think this is necessarily true. Unless, we are counting sitting in school for 6 hours each day as work. If we measure work as simple attendance and adherence to a schedule, then it seems that work and school are similar (ie sit in a class lecture v sit in a meeting, with very brief amounts of work in between). But this has nothing to do with output, which most of us would consider a necessary product of work.
- MattGaiser 5y agoI agree. I don't think either setting can be considered highly productive.
- mvp 5y agoI think the point was that for a lot of people the settings are more productive than if they were left to their own devices.
- giantg2 5y agoThat largely depends on the value system. Set someone in a remote area and tell them they have to make it on their own with nobody coming to their aide, they'll work hard. Give them a salary that doesn't change based on work effort, then why would they try harder? I get way more done for my self than when I'm working for an employer. I'm not dragged down by meetings and bureaucracy.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pikseladam 5y agoI couldn't understand how he continues to work for harvard and still call himself retired.
- neogodless 5y agoBy dictionary definition, you have to have left your position of employment and left work. But there's still some meaning in "not being stuck at work" and being financially capable of choosing what you do with your time. We don't have a single word for this, but we have some phrases, like "financially independent." Once you've reached this point, you might choose to do something that people will pay you for, or you might not. Either way, you're not obligated or chained to employment any more. Using the term "retired" for that status is not a huge stretch.
- davidwihl 5y agoHe teaches occasionally at Harvard, usually a short course. This is covered under the subsection "Teaching might be the answer."
- ghaff 5y agoIt used to be a much cleaner division. You got your Rolex and you moved to Florida. (OK I exaggerate.) But for many professional people in tech, it can mean doing some consulting/teaching/writing/whatever on the side. In fact, for me, one of my questions is what are some of the specific things it makes sense for me to do when I retire that are materially different/better than what I do today?
- gfiorav 5y agoI had a version of this realization early in my life. I wanted to be a musician. I thought that school and other things in life were a burden and that once I was devoted to music, I'd be happy and full. I got my dream by 18 years old. When music became my work I hated it. Made me think differently about life.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoEverything that becomes work you will hate. I think when it is no longer your job you might begin to enjoy it again? My career turned out to be software engineering because I liked writing software as a hobby. The job does take the software-writing energy out of me. But from time to time when I have started a little project of my own I have found it to be enjoyable again.
- UnpossibleJim 5y agoI had a similar situation. I worked hard and went back to school and became a professional artist. I was paid decently, but ended up never drawing or painting for myself. I hated it. It took me close to a decade to start liking the process of creating visual arts again, and even then it was tentative. I read something not all that long ago that I wished I had read when I was much younger. "Make something you like your career and keep your passions for yourself, if you are able." Obviously, this doesn't work for everyone. Some people have that all consuming thing where the process of selling your passion doesn't kill the love for it, but it didn't mesh for me =/
- gfiorav 5y agoI took me 10 years to buy an MPC again. And I barely touch it. The scars are real. A couple good things though: - I can finally listen to music without overanalyzing it. Which is to say I can now enjoy music. - I find a lot of ways to use creativity in my job, and has given me an edge thus far (or so I think).
- UnpossibleJim 5y agoI do think the fast ideation strategies I learned in art school definitely help me in software development, as well as not becoming overly attached to my children and accepting criticism. There are, for sure, many wonderful lessons to be learned in creative classes that cross over. I haven't been to a "Code Camp", but I have to imagine that this form of purely technical training (on its own) would have its down sides (though, I only have a liberal arts education as well, who stumbled into a technical field because of my hobbies).
- pugworthy 5y agoA tangent comment, but his website is such a fun throwback. I remember finding the Philip and Alex's Guide to Web Publishing (https://philip.greenspun.com/panda/ https://philip.greenspun.com/panda/) when it was first put up. What an amazing eye opener for me at the time to what the internet would/could be. Plus I loved his napkin-style diagrams and interspersed photos.
- jeffreyrogers 5y agoEvery now and then I come across a link to one of his webpages. I'm glad he's kept them up for so long.
- ghaff 5y agoTravels with Samantha was probably one of the earliest things you really wanted to read on the Web: https://philip.greenspun.com/samantha/ https://philip.greenspun.com/samantha/ That was in the days when you could have a personal homepage with "the" interesting stuff on the Web worth going to.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoI was hoping to find some nuggets of wisdom in this blog post but came up empty I'm afraid. I kept busy writing games, doing art, making things from wood before my career/family, I see no reason why I will not again when retired. As I do have a family (and nearly an empty nest now) I have become quite comfortable not having much of a "social life". I still want friends, still need the occasional connection, but it is not nearly as central to my life as it was when I was younger. No, I expect I will do just fine as a retiree. (Maybe I should add, I still have managed to squeeze in projects this whole time in my off hours even while holding down a job + family. I know there are plenty of unmotivated people and so maybe I was not the target of the post.)
- david927 5y agoThis person seems to have extreme, simplistic views that they hold as the truth. Non-profit organizations exist to provide their staff with great jobs"? He honestly believes that? How many has he worked with? I've worked with non-profits my whole life, and some are flawed, but many do tremendously valuable work. No to the beach? Depends on your preferences. To the author: Taking personal, anecdotal experiences and drawing "objective" rules from them is the modus operandi of the fool. Maybe take your retirement time to learn to be less of a fool.
- someguy321 5y agoIf you read more of Philip Greenspun's writings it's apparent that he likes to inject a bit of satire into them. Both self-deprecating and deprecating others. I figure that he hit it on the nose with that bit.
- snotrockets 5y agoHe's punching down, and is toxic in general. I forgot about it until I clicked the link (or maybe didn't notice it the first time I read it)
- 52-6F-62 5y agoAnd people say studying humanities is useless... Before you can even begin to approach questions like this, you have to get a lay of the land at least... read an article on philosophy and religion in the encyclopedia. These aren't new questions. They've been dissected and applied to the furthest reaches of our understanding. It's all written down and at our fingertips 24/7. They underlie the primary question in the article. Retirement is irrelevant. In a very roundabout way it seems like that is what Mr Greenspun is trying to say, but it kind of comes across as (the illustrious Gordon Lightfoot put it) a "rich man's spiritual". > In olden times, the average person didn't expect to be happy. How can this even be proposed? Maybe I just read way too into this. Is it a joke? edit: I don't like leaving such negative comments. I envy Mr Greenspun. I'm not 37 yet but I'm not too far off, either. If I could retire at that age and spend the rest of my life exploring philosophy and leisure... well I could hardly think of a finer place to end up in one's life. Starting to ask the questions at all is how to start. Kudos.
- nafizh 5y agoYou can read all the philosophy in the world. It doesn't automatically turn into actionable realities. Also, any philosophy is subjective, you are a human, you said something, I am a human, I beg to differ and so on and on....
- 52-6F-62 5y agoAbsolutely you can read it to death and still glean nothing from it. I don't know how many times I've had to reread, and I usually continue to do so. And to that end it takes more than just reading it, but if one wants to ask some profound questions about the world around oneself now that one doesn't have someone breathing down one's neck then one should probably start where others left off. It'll save a little time. The point where you took a wrong turn was assuming that philosophy is all based on hearsay. There's been a lot of effort to ground pretty fundamental ideas to what we understand about reality, to the extent that we understand it. It's worth working to grasp some of that. It helps. If you like quantizations and mathematical/logical formality that exists as well, but mind that you'll probably want to do a lot of comparative reading. To put this in programmer's terms: why would you re-implement libc when you haven't even looked at the existing source code or surrounding arguments? That would look like a fool's errand: not because the effort isn't worthwhile, but because you could save yourself a lot of time and use the lessons of the past to inform your next efforts rather than blindly making all of the same mistakes or rediscovering what was already known (to our best efforts). Worse, you might end up wandering around ranting about how someone should implement a core supportive library for a common systems language without ever looking to find out if there is one in the first place.
- cfeduke 5y agoThe greatest expense for me in retirement is now health insurance so it makes sense for me to instead work for insurance coverage and put my wealth towards an inheritance for my children. I used to naively believe once I paid off my mortgage, had a substantial retirement account and savings - a couple million dollars - I'd no longer work. It's also very difficult to get off of the treadmill of spending a lot of money on products and services - requires a massive life change I haven't been ready to perform. It helps that I love to write software; I'd just continue writing software in retirement. I tried to retire once and I ended up writing software anyway, so might as well as get health insurance coverage.
- neogodless 5y agoTo avoid repeating myself, I'll link a reply to a sibling comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28062162 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28062162 The gist is that lowering your other expenses and qualifying for ACA could dramatically lower your health insurance expenses as well.
- kache_ 5y agoMy plan is: - Move to America, become rich - Move back to Canada, retire - Win :P
- xyzzy_plugh 5y agoJust an FYI that if you avoid permanent US residency via green card or US citizenship you can potentially take advantage of a step-up of the cost basis of ALL your taxable assets when you move back to Canada, thus erasing any tax on the capital gains -- both short and long term. (In Canada, there is no distinction of short or long term gains). Assuming that you have little-to-no Canadian assets now, dispose of everything at no-to-low cost when you leave, move to the US for a decade or so and rack up a lot of RSUs/exercised options, maybe surviving an IPO or two, while enjoying a strong USD, you can move back comically wealthy compared to your peers. You may or may not have to toy with your employer's immigration lawyers as they scramble to get you a green card while you avoid filing any paperwork. (This is not financial advice, contact a licensed professional, tell your friends, etc.)
- magwa101 5y agoThis reads a little like taking your competitive work environment forward into retirement. You have to learn to let it go, and that takes time...maybe years...maybe all of them.
- dayvid 5y agoPeter Drucker wrote a really good essay called The Second half of your life. I can’t find it online outside of buying the Essential Drucker, but this article covers some of the points: https://www.asme.org/topics-resources/content/peter-druckers-principles-total-life https://www.asme.org/topics-resources/content/peter-druckers...
- jorblumesea 5y agoIf you've ever talked to anyone that has done FIRE or just retired a few years early, it's always health insurance. The current US system of healthcare via your employer is a huge blocker to any kind of alternative lifestyle. Have to wait until 65 (or like 68 by the time most of us can retire)
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe current system is not healthcare via employer. Anyone can go to healthcare.gov and get the same insurance plans. The main benefit of employer purchased health insurance is that you buy with pre tax dollars.
- jorblumesea 5y agoSorry, affordable healthcare. Sure, public plans exist, but most state exchanges are 2k a month. It's not the same, because the insurance pools are different. Check the coverage plans: https://www.wahbexchange.org/new-customers/coverage-basics/plans/#2021 https://www.wahbexchange.org/new-customers/coverage-basics/p... Except for a few situations, it's mostly bottom tier insurance pools. Meanwhile, my insurance PPO ranged from $0.0 month (high deductible) to max ~$50.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThey are not that different in my experience. The same metal level plan on healthcare.gov are pretty similar to what employers will be offered by the insurance companies. There might be some savings for those working at white collar firms with younger employees like tech and finance and law, but that will not apply to most people in the US. Your portion of the insurance premium was $0 to $50 per pay period via your employer, but the cost of your insurance was still much higher, probably the same as healthcare.gov. Check code DD in box 12 of your W2 to see how much your employer paid, and you can compare the actual price of your health insurance. Edit: NJ puts out a nice document that anyone can estimate their premium for based on metal level and age. Note that $2k per month would be for family coverage of 2 old people, but for young people it would be a third. Also note that prices for young people are extra high due to subsidizing old people due to stipulations in ACA limiting premiums for old people to be 3x those of young people. See “age rating factors” box at bottom of pdf. https://www.nj.gov/dobi/division_insurance/ihcseh/ihcrates2021.pdf https://www.nj.gov/dobi/division_insurance/ihcseh/ihcrates20...
- 2sk21 5y agoI retired early recently - I am in my mid 50s. It's not anywhere as hard as people seem to think. With a disciplined approach to investing, I think that it's very much possible to reach financial independence with a typical tech salary in the US. I achieved FI without an extraordinarily high salary, stock grants or participating in an IPO. There is a treasure trove of information in the Bogleheads wiki: https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Getting_started https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Getting_started
- ok2938 5y agoMy problem is, I'm kind of anti-capitalist, to make it short. Labor and capital and not just production factors, but they constitute a power relationship (and often a quite asymmetric one). I cannot bring myself to "invest" in something or believe that "my money works for me" - that's delusional. Money does not "work". People get all upset about the stance, but all I am saying is that everyone wants to profit off someone else' work and I do not think that's the best way forward. Especially not in an era, where labor overall will decrease in value (we will continue to automate more and more) - which just means poverty for anyone w/o capital (it's that simple). Edit: Also, I'm not speaking as a "loser" of this system - but on track to the first million - it's just that I can imagine another world and so many people take the "capitalist framework" as a given - which it just not is. There are ways to think about society in a more nuanced way, without losing all the competitive niceties of capitalism.
- brianwawok 5y agoSo if you don't invest, do you just save money in a savings account? Over a 50 year career S&P Index Fund vs stuff in a savings account is the different between... having 20k a year to pull from savings, vs having 100k a year to pull from investments. It's a pretty stark portfolio difference.
- throwaway894345 5y agoIronically if you put the money in a savings account, someone much richer than you is going to be investing it on your behalf and taking the lion's share of the interest that you're leaving on the table.
- evo_9 5y agoMy dad told me after he retired it was his biggest mistake in life. He'd started a business with a friend in the 1970's that became quite successful in the Detroit Metro area. He retired and like a good Italian, bought a house in Florida and played golf everyday. After a few months he hated his new life, and wished he'd never sold his business. He realized after he retired that his work was something he enjoyed doing, that his clients - most of whom he knew for 20+ years - were people he loved to see and visit. All that changed after he retired and sold the business to my older brother and a another business partner. There was no going back, and that was that.
- neogodless 5y ago> bought a house in Florida and played golf everyday It sounds like this was one of the big mistakes. Hindsight being 20/20 and all, it's hard to see it all now, but it sounds like he could've attempted to transition some of his best business relationships into personal ones, with lunches and/or some other kinds of personal meet-ups. Of course, enjoying the work, it does sound like he sold too soon! This is still a personal anecdote though. As per the article, we aren't very good at predicting or evaluating what makes us happy. We think retiring and doing "other things" is what we want, but is it? It might be working, running a business, or golfing. You have to figure that out for yourself, and ideally in a way that doesn't require irreversible decisions.
- _wldu 5y agoWhy isn't healthcare insurance more like car insurance? Almost everyone can afford to pay car insurance and are not worried about going broke and filing for bankruptcy if they have an accident or get a speeding ticket. A friend got covid, almost died and then got a large five figure medical bill. They had insurance via the employer, but the hospital ER/ICU they were transported to was out of network. How is a very sick person in the back of an ambulance suppose to handle this in America?
- germinalphrase 5y agoBecause (most) cars are not worth much?
- brianwawok 5y ago> Almost everyone can afford to pay car insurance and are not worried about going broke and filing for bankruptcy if they have an accident or get a speeding ticket. Wealthy people actually buy an umbrella policy or something else to protect their wealth. Crashing into a 2 million dollar car or causing the deaths of a few people is going to put 1+ million in damages back on you. If your net worth is 50k, maybe doesn't matter. If it is 5 million, it could be life changing.
- snotrockets 5y agoCar insurance has capped payouts, and any policy which is considered by the insurer to be too much of a risk would be denied. Unlike a car, health costs are both unbound, and good health has infinite utility (you'd always be willing to pay as much as you can for good health,) and unlike car ownership, is also a basic human right.
- underseacables 5y agoI’m terrified of retirement. I’ve got about 30 years to go, and I’m only just now seriously thinking about saving for retirement. My two greatest fears are that I will retire and have to take a part-time job to make ends meet, or worse, there’s a health crisis that completely wiped us out financially. Our plan is to slowly develop a small real estate portfolio of rental properties to bring in secondary streams of income, as well as some investing, 401(k), and hard assets. But it’s absolutely terrifying. Aside from 401(k), what are some of the ways that you were saving for retirement? Investments? Stocks? Assets and real estate?
- brianwawok 5y ago> there’s a health crisis that completely wiped us out financially Do you have at least catastrophic health insurance? This is a fear you can solve for not that much money.
- kevinventullo 5y agoIRA’s get you a little more tax shelter on top of the 401(k).
- splistud 5y agoIf a man is physically fit to work in some capacity, and has learned to live on little income, that man has little to fear. By all means learn to save and invest, but it's not as important as staying healthy, and learning what things you spend money on that are unnecessary to your life, health and happiness.
- goostavos 5y agoI completely share the medical fear. The cost of american health care is absolutely terrifying. I'm only in my 30s, but got a taste of a bleak future when I had to get a whole suite of tests done to weed out what my doc thought may have been a major illness (turned out to be nothing, thankfully!). Those multiple x-rays, an MRI, and visits with specialists basically deleted a chunk of my HSA savings (even with my "good" insurance). fwiw, retirement wise (baring a health event deleting everything), I just do the "invest everything" strategy outlined in books like I Will Teach you to be Rich and Get Rich Slowly. I only keep 7mo of "emergency" cash liquid. All tax protected accounts get maxed out, and everything else goes into an index fund.
- justinram11 5y agoPerhaps I'm a bit naive in my mid-20's, but I actually don't think that I'd hate working 15-20 hours a week (at a low-stress company) for the rest of my life. Or at least until I was physically unable. I've recently been wondering if I should instead be trying to view life as a "sustainable marathon" rather than trying to cash out quickly (FIRE).
- bboylen 5y agoHow easy is it to find these positions though
- neogodless 5y agoThere's nothing particularly wrong with this mindset, but let's be explicit about your options: 1. Spend any extra money you make, knowing that you'll work 20 hours / week at least until social security arrives. If you start to hate work or having trouble finding work, you likely have very little to fall back on. Social security might not support your lifestyle, so expect a very pared back retirement late in life. 2. Spend a lot less than you make, but still spend amply to cover qualify of life and the things you enjoy and value. Invest the extra and have a cushion that covers unexpected job loss, periods of burnout, and the option to go long periods without any work at all if you have other interest you want to pursue. Be prepared for retirement now or when you're much older, but always having everything you need to cover the lifestyle you've designed. 3. Be miserable now, spending way less than you make, hating your job and hoping once you have a huge nest egg, you can make yourself happy! Some people think early retirement is #3 but it's really #2. And many people do #1 until they start to realize they don't love being tied to a job at 40 as much as they enjoyed it at 20. (And that spending lots of money doesn't always make up for the obligation to work as well as they hoped.)
- learnvella 5y agowhy does spending way less than you make imply hating your job and being miserable? i dont think the idea of spending money as a primary mechanism for life happiness holds up. if you're a happy person internally it doesn't really matter if you use cheap hand towels at home or silk ones- it doesn't matter if you're eating filet mignon or chicken legs. > hoping once you have a huge nest egg, you can make yourself happy! this is a super uncharitable way of putting the ideas of fi. i would suggest the idea is more like "learn to view money as apart from happiness and recognize that the things that make you happy are more on the intrinsic side of things- self growth, real relationships with people near you, serving others and dont waste the time you have on earth by giving it to some corporation or other entitiy unless you want to"
- nabla9 5y agoFamous for Greenspun's tenth rule of programming: "Any sufficiently complicated C or Fortran program contains an ad hoc, informally-specified, bug-ridden, slow implementation of half of Common Lisp." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenspun's_tenth_rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenspun's_tenth_rule >The rule expresses the opinion that the argued flexibility and extensibility designed into the programming language Lisp includes all functionality that is theoretically needed to write any complex computer program, and that the features required to develop and manage such complexity in other programming languages are equivalent to some subset of the methods used in Lisp. >Other programming languages, while claiming to be simpler, require programmers to reinvent in a haphazard way a significant amount of needed functionality that is present in Lisp as a standard, time-proven base.
- baobaba 5y ago> Retirement forces you to stop thinking that it is your job that holds you back. For most people the depressing truth is that they aren't that organized, disciplined, or motivated. This resonates. I took a 1-year sabbatical after 12 years in the tech industry. I kept a big text file with all the things I wanted to do once I had the time. When I finally did, I realized I only wanted to do one thing from that list (of 30+ items). The rest sounded good on paper, but I never had the motivation to do them. This was a harsh realization, but now when I think "I wish I had time to...", I know it's an illusion. We tend to make time for what we really want. Overall, it was useful to realize.
- zemvpferreira 5y agoDon't blame yourself, one year is barely enough to decompress after a decade of work. Who knows how productively happy you could be after getting all the tiredness out of your system?
- ralphc 5y agoRetired at 55 from software development. I think it helps when your career (slash passion blah blah) is something that you don't need other people to do. I still write programs and help nonprofits with Salesforce work. Software development, writing, music, all can be done solo, and more importantly for your own fulfillment. Doctors etc. could have a problem.
- davidwihl 5y agoAFAIK, Philip is not really retired. He does a lot of expert witness work these days https://philip.greenspun.com/software/expert-witness https://philip.greenspun.com/software/expert-witness
- BlasDeLezo 5y ago"No retirement plan survives first contact with the divorce lawyer" This applies to Greenspun as much as anybody else.
- Invictus0 5y agoMost of these early retirement failure essays are from people with poor social skills. The number 1 thing that will make you happy in retirement is friends to talk to.
- DickingAround 5y ago"In olden times, the average person didn't expect to be happy" - I don't think that statement is supported by any evidence or logic. People are happy sometimes even when they're food-scarce. Only the dead are truly never happy. Similarly, the concept of 'pursuit of happiness' then referenced was a sort of adaptation of the 'right to property'. Perhaps this article would be stronger with a deeper research into history of people a few hundred years ago, or philosophy of work/life at that time.
- mvp 5y agoThat sentence was followed by 'Life could be a struggle for survival with hard work and adversity at every corner. Marriages were arranged by parents and if, after 20 years, the couple hated each other, there was no option to divorce.'. So, if you don't struggle for survival, and don't have to work hard, and are not hit by adversity, and not forcely married to a person you don't like, then you may be happy. That seems a reasonable assumption considering the objective of the essay.
- hahamrfunnyguy 5y agoI went down to three days a week four years ago and it's one of the best decisions I've ever made. At first, I planned on working on an existing business but I decided not to do that and started making YouTube videos because I wanted something else to do on my days off. That was fun at first but got monotonous fast. I volunteered for a political campaign for a year, and now now I am working on another business that I am really excited about. For me, I definitely have to have something productive to do or I get bored. I own a home with no debt and am pretty frugal so I could probably "retire" now, but will probably keep working until my new business starts making money. Once that happens, I'll probably shift over to working entirely for myself. I don't think I'll stop "working", whether it's something that makes money or not. The beauty is that since I've been pushing towards financial independence, I'll always have plenty of "extra" cash that I can use for whatever I want. If I do decide to retire, I'll probably keep my development skills active so I'll always be able to find work if need be.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nunez 5y agoWow; this is a really good article. I love how the author (I think rightfully) highlights that people use their jobs as an excuse for staving off goals they've created.
- debug-desperado 5y agoMy retirement plan involves stuffing as much money into creditor-protected assets and then declaring bankruptcy if I get a huge medical bill. I see no alternative in today's world of "surprise" out-of-network charges. The types of assets are protected in Texas: 1. 401k + IRA (plus Roth versions) 2. Home 3. Two vehicles 4. Permanent insurance (i.e. whole life / indexed universal life - not optimal unless you want to leave money to heirs) Other states aren't quite as generous with the creditor protection, so check your state's laws.