4 ms·
So if a tool made in China cost $20 and the same kind made in USA cost $100, which one do you think people are going to buy at the hardware store (even if the o
by ck2 15y ago
So if a tool made in China cost $20 and the same kind made in USA cost $100, which one do you think people are going to buy at the hardware store (even if the one made in China lasts 1/4th as long).
What if there was a tax that made the one made in China cost $70 - you think the one made in USA would have a fighting chance? I think so. It would create a whole bunch of jobs because there would be less impulse to move jobs overseas.
What if that $50 was used for single payer health care so that "job providers" didn't have pay for health insurance or play that game and compete with the international market.
- tomjen3 15y agoThen everything else would become way more expensive and the quality of life would decrease a lot. Protectionism never many a country rich. Only production of goods and services that people actually want will do that. This may require people to upgrade their skills, but so be it.
- ars 15y agoYou need to think on a larger scale. If everyone had to spend 3 times as much on the things they buy, then they would have even less available money than they do now. So they would probably stop buying, which would really hurt the economy. Or they would cut out health insurance and other things.
- jlangenauer 15y agoOr they would buy fewer things that they actually needed, and that would probably last longer. Not an idle consideration on a planet with finite resources and an ecosystem being pushed beyond its limits.
- ars 15y ago> Or they would buy fewer things that they actually needed, and that would probably last longer. Unfortunately that's a recipe for economic disaster. > Not an idle consideration on a planet with finite resources and an ecosystem being pushed beyond its limits. Not really. The resources are effectively infinite because they are never destroyed, they only get changed into various different forms. We can keep making things, then remaking them into different things basically forever. And the ecosystem is not anywhere near its limits (not that making less things would help it even if it was). There are definitely areas where things are bad, but the good areas far outweigh the bad.
- potatolicious 15y ago> "We can keep making things, then remaking them into different things basically forever." Woah, since when? For one thing, making things (and remaking them) takes a tremendous amount of energy, which uses fuel, of which as of yet we are still running on finite reserves (disregarding the environmental angle completely, even). Secondly, when you chop down a tree and make it into paper, that paper may be recyclable, but never in the exact same form (there's a reason recycled paper is not used in many applications of paper). Not only that, many items that we make are not practically recyclable, or dangerously so - see: recovery of precious metals from electronics. Nigh impossibility unless you want to burn the rest of it away, spewing toxic chemicals into the atmosphere and causing skyrocketing cancer rates. Until we have infinite, free energy and the ability to transmute matter at will, we cannot keep remaking things forever, not even close. No amount of recycling will even come close to the environmental and resource savings of simply not making something in the first place.
- ars 15y agoWe have plenty of fuel in the form of nuclear power. Just because we aren't using it today doesn't mean we can't. I never mentioned the word recycle. I don't expect anyone to recycle paper. Instead you compost or burn the paper, and grow a new tree. The elements that make up paper are infinity reusable. The same for the precious elements in electronics. True, we do a poor job of recovering them today, but we could change that easily, and keep making and destroying electronics forever without running out. We don't even need to recover them, we have plenty in mines. We could store the electronics in a big hole in the ground (for example in an old mine) and only use them much later when we need to. The only reason we do try to recover them is for money, not because we are going to run out. By far the majority of the stuff we build is made of just a few elements: silicon (in concrete), carbon, nitrogen, hydrogen, oxygen (those four make up plastics, wood, and lots more) and iron. We are not going to ever run out of those - the planet is made of them. We could keep making and destroying things forever without running out. All we need is energy. (There is no need to transmute elements.) The rest of the elements could be easily recovered with technology like http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_arc_waste_disposal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_arc_waste_disposal - run that on a big landfill and you get every element you need after some refining.
- bergie 15y agoThat would be quite funny, given that USA has spent much of th last hundred years promoting free trade and trying to force other countries to open up their economies for foreign imports. And I don't think a protectionist customs scheme is what you want. It could boost local manufacturing on a short them, but eventually the lack of incentive makes them fall behind. Then you have whole industries producing stuff nobody would buy, except for the fact that anything imported is way overpriced. USA has a quite large domestic economy, but it still probably isn't enough for the companies there if they are not competitive elsewhere.
- mahyarm 15y agoAmerica has a big protectionist/anti-immigration streak.
- webwright 15y agoYou know what happens if we tax the hell out of cheap overseas goods? Everything gets more expensive. Cost of living skyrockets and wages would have to go up commensurately if people were going to survive/thrive. Businesses who raised wages would have to curtail hiring because more of their revenues were going to wages. Any they'd keep shipping jobs overseas because of the healthy margins selling in overseas markets. Start taxing that stuff too and see how many corporations decide that being a US company isn't so awesome anymore...
- achompas 15y agoRight, and you're not even discussing the subsequent tariff war. Other countries would tax the hell out of American goods, global demand for our goods will fall, we'd produce less, companies would make less money, and people would lose their jobs.
- ck2 15y agoWe barely sell anything overseas as it is - what exactly are they going to "tax the hell out of" ? Have you seen the mountain of shipping containers in our ports from inbounds with no outbounds? They are stacked a dozen high over HUNDREDS of acres of land. No exaggeration. We are the only potential consumers of our own products - because every other job has been shipped overseas that can easily shipped. Most of what is left is services and assembling components made elsewhere (auto industry).
- achompas 15y agoI'm tired of hearing this from people. The US exported more than every country except China and Germany last year.[0] We're the leading producer of airplane components and engines, and we still produce a high volume of heavy equipment that goes overseas. [0] http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/eco_exp-economy-exports http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/eco_exp-economy-exports
- antidaily 15y agoAll of those negatives have already happened precisely because we don't have a smart trade policy.
- dools 15y agoI believe the economic term for that is "Protectionism".