3 ms·
> I am not claiming that my proposal is the perfect solution for all situations and has no failure points. I don't really appreciate your use of maximal edge ca
by bawolff 5y ago
> I am not claiming that my proposal is the perfect solution for all situations and has no failure points. I don't really appreciate your use of maximal edge cases to break it like it was a theorem assertion. That just seems like you're more interested in negating the idea than exploring it.
I'm not saying it fails in edge cases, i'm saying it fails in every case.
There's two possibilities:
A) the employer acts in good faith.
In which case, why would you need this? Firing someone for unionizing is the ultimate example of acting in bad faith, so if they are acting in good faith, no problem to solve.
B) the employer acts in bad faith. We're assuming the employer wants to fire the employee - why would they be reasonable? The rational thing to do would be to be unreasonable until the employee walks away.
I'm not saying that a solution has to fix everything, but it should fix something in some reasonable scenario where parties are behaving towards their interests. Otherwise we might as well simplify it to: instead of unions, employers should just stop exploiting their employees.